Best 22 for Round 1, 2017

[Gator 16,890]

24 minutes ago, Abe said:

plus he's very hard at it.

That's the key with Smith right there. 

If he had all of these attributes but his attack on the footy was no better than Howe then I'd be less enthused.  

If you don't have a crack in this side you won't get selected. 

I fear for Garlett if he's not careful.

[stevethemanjordan 6,952]

I agree Smithy looks to have huge scope for improvement with some really exciting attributes. (Similar to Hunt before he broke through).

I don't share the view that his foot-skills are that good however and the games I saw were proof of that. He is definitely pretty hit and miss in my eyes.

Smith, Melksham and Hunt share similar strengths.

Wagner, Salem and Hibberd all share similar strengths. 

The running power and line-breaking ability of that first group is important and I reckon Goody knows that in the modern game, that pace is best utilized on the wings. Ala Hawthorn with Smith and Hill.

Thats just how I see it. 

 

 

 

 

[Uncle Fester 2,833]

I honestly don't know what our best 22 is. And I like that. 5 years ago I'd name 10 then go ... umm... Now I'm trying to fit 30 into 22 and that's without Lewis, Milkshake and Hibberd. It's a good place to be. Sorta like not caring about the top 20 in the draft.

 

[Dwight Schrute 16,722]

In my opinion..

Red are players who i believe if fit, will play round 1

black are the players i think are fighting for their spot

I think Garlett and Clarry are very likely to play also but not 100% certain for either, all depends on form and team balance 

 

Jetta T McDonald Frost

Hibberd O McDonald Hunt

Vince Tyson Lewis

Petracca Hogan Kent

Garlett Weideman Watts

Gawn N.Jones Viney

Salem Brayshaw Oliver Melksham

[Guest]

Really don't understand the lack of love for Billy Stretch - he's the only legitimate winger on our list; he's quick, makes good decisions and is clean by foot. 

 

In a team that is crying out for these things, he's a lock for round one (barring injury).

Edited November 4, 2016 by Scythe

[Gator 16,890]

33 minutes ago, Scythe said:

Really don't understand the lack of love for Billy Stretch - he's the only legitimate winger on our list; he's quick, makes good decisions and is clean by foot. 

 

In a team that is crying out for these things, he's a lock for round one (barring injury).

Those clued in have him

[Dwight Schrute 16,722]

Oops forgot billy! Out milkshake

[Skuit 9,109]

The groupthink is strong in this one. Garlett will be there round 1 barring some unfortunate injury. Please provide alternative scenarios if you disagree. 

[Gator 16,890]

1 minute ago, Skuit said:

The groupthink is strong in this one. Garlett will be there round 1 barring some unfortunate injury. Please provide alternative scenarios if you disagree. 

What groupthink re Garlett ?

When did it start ?

And by whom ?

I question his place, but not through any "groupthink".

Please share...

 

[What 18,810]

54 minutes ago, Skuit said:

The groupthink is strong in this one. Garlett will be there round 1 barring some unfortunate injury. Please provide alternative scenarios if you disagree. 

He is not an automatic selection.  His season was terrible.

[Skuit 9,109]

4 hours ago, ProDee said:

What groupthink re Garlett ?

When did it start ?

And by whom ?

I question his place, but not through any "groupthink".

Please share...

 

A few have questioned Jeff and Jetta's position in the team in the long-term planning. Perhaps rightfully so with some decent but debatable arguments. But all of a sudden both boys are starting to slip from favour for round one 2017. I don't believe there's any justification for such thinking except for the negative momentum here on Demonland. I would think both are in the first dozen locks in their positions. I'm mostly curious as to alternative scenarios. Who does Garlett get bumped for? What is the imagined forward set-up without him?

[Skuit 9,109]

3 hours ago, Petraccattack said:

He is not an automatic selection.  His season was terrible.

Terrible? As posted above - he shared almost identical 2016 stats with Watts. And as someone else posted - forward pocket can be a dead zone. If you're not in the game you can be left totally absent. He had some games where he wasn't switched on for sure - but otherwise, I think he was adjusting like many to our new game plan. Of most note for me - his indecision in scoring range - looking to pass off too often rather trusting instinct and taking a shot. Maybe team directions.

[CBDees 3,162]

12 hours ago, Abe said:

Oops forgot billy! Out milkshake

There is an edit function on Demonland you know (ideal for these situations)!

[CBDees 3,162]

Th three that interest me after a pre-season are Garlett, Trenners and JKH, the latter two because Trenners needs to start a pre-season, fully recovered and JKH had a bad run though the season proper. I don't think that we have seen the best from these three as we haven't from either Weideman or Smith, both who should emerge from the pre-season as much more value.

[Gator 16,890]

9 hours ago, Skuit said:

A few have questioned Jeff and Jetta's position in the team in the long-term planning. Perhaps rightfully so with some decent but debatable arguments. But all of a sudden both boys are starting to slip from favour for round one 2017. I don't believe there's any justification for such thinking except for the negative momentum here on Demonland. I would think both are in the first dozen locks in their positions. I'm mostly curious as to alternative scenarios. Who does Garlett get bumped for? What is the imagined forward set-up without him?

You didn't answer my questions.

Be more specific.

[Redleg 37,470]

15 hours ago, Scythe said:

Really don't understand the lack of love for Billy Stretch - he's the only legitimate winger on our list; he's quick, makes good decisions and is clean by foot. 

 

In a team that is crying out for these things, he's a lock for round one (barring injury).

I think the FD would agree with you. 

[Ron Burgundy 8,584]

13 hours ago, Petraccattack said:

He is not an automatic selection.  His season was terrible.

I think he is an automatic selection.

He is a unique player and, unless his form is absolutely horrible, he is on the team sheet every day of the week.

 

[Binmans PA 25,889]

On Friday, November 04, 2016 at 8:59 AM, stevethemanjordan said:

I agree Smithy looks to have huge scope for improvement with some really exciting attributes. (Similar to Hunt before he broke through).

I don't share the view that his foot-skills are that good however and the games I saw were proof of that. He is definitely pretty hit and miss in my eyes.

Smith, Melksham and Hunt share similar strengths.

Wagner, Salem and Hibberd all share similar strengths. 

The running power and line-breaking ability of that first group is important and I reckon Goody knows that in the modern game, that pace is best utilized on the wings. Ala Hawthorn with Smith and Hill.

Thats just how I see it. 

Yeah, see, I reckon the way the modern game is and certainly the way we're looking to play it, half back is where speed is best utilised. 

The momentum and pace of someone like Hunt or Petracca through the centre square, off the back of the stoppage when we win it, is really difficult to defend against if you don't win that initial stoppage and set up extremely defensively yourself.

[FarNorthernD 5,839]

I don't think too many on here would disagree that both Jetta and Garlett are automatic selections when playing at their best.

Jetta came 9th in the B & F, one vote behind Hogan and only the third non mid (to T.Mc and Hogan). There were numerous occasions during games that he held the backline together. Time and time again he puts his body on the line and he is a reliable disposer of the pill. When playing at his best Nev's name can reasonably be mentioned in the same sentence as AA squad selection. 

Garlett's best is very bloody good indeed and I love it when the footy is in his hands. Fun stuff can happen. Unfortunately the gap  between his best and worst is huge. If he can't  find that consistency next season then his spot could be taken by a less talented but more reliable player. 

At their best however I can't see either being replaced. 

[Gator 16,890]

2 hours ago, fndee said:

Garlett's best is very bloody good indeed and I love it when the footy is in his hands. Fun stuff can happen. Unfortunately the gap  between his best and worst is huge. If he can't  find that consistency next season then his spot could be taken by a less talented but more reliable player. 

At their best however I can't see either being replaced. 

Garlett is as soft as butter. 

It will be interesting to see how Goodwin shapes this team. 

I'd concerned if I was Jeffy.

[spirit of norm smith 12,833]

On Friday, August 05, 2016 at 10:34 PM, spirit of norm smith said:

Jetta T.McD Frost

Salem O.McD Hibberd

Hunt Viney Melksham

Petracca Hogan Kent

Garlett Weideman Watts

Gawn Lewis N.Jones

Oliver Brayshaw Vince Tyson

Depth:

fwds - smalls: Kennedy Jkh, Johnstone / talls: Pedersen Hulett Hannan, T.Smith(r)  7

mids - Harmes, Stretch, ANB  Vdhberg Bugg Trengove  6

backs - Dunn Garland Wagner   j.smith(r) M.White(r) Kielty(r)  6 

rucks - Spencer Mitch.King Maynard (r) Filopovic (r) 4

? Lamumba 

that's 46

updates post draft picks

Edited November 28, 2016 by spirit of norm smith
*

[MrReims 289]

1 hour ago, spirit of norm smith said:

updates post draft picks

Not so sure Maynard is a Ruckman

[Ozymandias Greenblerg 12]

Jetta, T. McDonald, O. McDonald

Hibberd, Frost, Melksham

Hunt, Jones, Vince

Petracca, Hogan, Watts,

Garlett, T. Smith, Kent

Gawn, Lewis, Viney

Stretch, Salem, Brayshaw, Tyson

Emergency: Oliver, Bugg, Pedersen

[jackaub 1,402]

I think Hannan will get a go earlier than most think, probably for Kent

Hannan from  his highlight reel works hard both ways and tackles like a demon

A really good pick up in my opinion

[Wunders 385]

1 hour ago, jackaub said:

I think Hannan will get a go earlier than most think, probably for Kent

Hannan from  his highlight reel works hard both ways and tackles like a demon

A really good pick up in my opinion

When i watched games live, it seemed to be kents role to sprint from ball carrier to ball carrier when our forwards were outnumbered (and the opposition was trying to clear the ball out of defence). His speed and pressure was better all season than anyone else in my opinion. So i would think that he is easily safe and someone else (Garlett for example - although i like him even though he drifts).

I like the inclusion of Tim smith in our starting line-up (not sure it will happen but i like it for the Weid - maybe both can rotate throughout the year in the one posiiton). I think we all agree weid won't be ready this year yet.

Exciting times, Go Dees!