Just putting it out there

[blue and red in the head 95]

if the dockers continue to be bad and finish bottom of the ladder and end up with pick one and they come hard for Jessie hogan. Would you do pick 1 and Neale and let's say tommy Sheridan in a trade?? 

[Dwight Schrute 16,722]

1 hour ago, blue and red in the head said:

if the dockers continue to be bad and finish bottom of the ladder and end up with pick one and they come hard for Jessie hogan. Would you do pick 1 and Neale and let's say tommy Sheridan in a trade?? 

If Jesse is determined to leave and we have zero hope of keeping him, which I highly doubt will happen, i'd be asking for pick 1 and Neale.

[Roger Mellie 3,485]

3 hours ago, blue and red in the head said:

if the dockers continue to be bad and finish bottom of the ladder and end up with pick one and they come hard for Jessie hogan. Would you do pick 1 and Neale and let's say tommy Sheridan in a trade?? 

Hogan is contracted for this year and next so entertaining any such proposal can be rammed where the sun don't shine.

[praha 10,267]

Freo won't finish last. They'll string some games together and still win 8-10 games imo.

[RalphiusMaximus 5,993]

If it's on the table and he hasn't re-signed, simply ask him.  Would he prefer to go back to Freo or stay with Melbourne and work out a new contract?  If he says he'd like to go to them, put them over a barrel and take what we can off them.

[Cheesy D. Pun 1,762]

I would have thought Hoges would stay put. Freo have been threatening to fall off a cliff for 2 or 3 seasons and it's finally happened. 

[Binmans PA 25,900]

I don't know why anyone thinks Hogan would go to Freo and take years off his career by flying back and forth across the country every second week. It's that idiot Langdon. I think Jesse will sign a big deal with us, but if he doesn't, we're more likely to lose him to another Melbourne-based club.

[DeeSpencer 23,061]

Reads thread title. Thinks, surely not.

Reads OP. Well ok then.

No.

Forget whether it would be a good or bad deal. The number 1 thing Roos has tried to build is culture. Any form of encouraging your star forward to leave is against that. 

And the idea that we need another number 1 pick is good for a giggle. It's the last thing we need.

[What 18,810]

Fyfe possible broken leg and they already looked cooked anyway.  Freo are about to fall off the biggest cliff of all time

[whatwhat say what 18,793]

no, lose hogan and we're back to the drawing board for a target man.

 

he's vital to our future progress.

[PaulRB 5,897]

41 minutes ago, Petraccattack said:

Fyfe possible broken leg and they already looked cooked anyway.  Freo are about to fall off the biggest cliff of all time

"... about to..." 

Round 5 and they are stone motherless last, having just lost to Carlton!!!... Carlton. 

[JV7 2,339]

7 hours ago, blue and red in the head said:

if the dockers continue to be bad and finish bottom of the ladder and end up with pick one and they come hard for Jessie hogan. Would you do pick 1 and Neale and let's say tommy Sheridan in a trade?? 

Didn't you know the dockers are tanking for #1 pick to use on hogan 

[KingDingAling 3,589]

21 hours ago, RalphiusMaximus said:

If it's on the table and he hasn't re-signed, simply ask him.  Would he prefer to go back to Freo or stay with Melbourne and work out a new contract?  If he says he'd like to go to them, put them over a barrel and take what we can off them.

I would agree with that. A committed Jesse Hogan is untouchable, a homesick Jesse Hogan isn't. If he was to leave MFC for Freo, IMO he would have to be extremely homesick - because they are on the slide, whereas MFC are on the rise. It would be have to be bordering on McCarthy homesick, which in that case, I would take pick 1 and Neale.

[steve_f 40]

Hogan is contracted until the end of 2017.

[DistrACTION Jackson 6,398]

I just can't see Hogan leaving. Why would you want to leave an up an coming young side who have the potential to bring a lot of success to join a side who will be dropping over the next 4 season? If he does want to leave then he wouldn't be someone I'd want as the club is more important than anything.

For what it is worth I've said this before but I believe he will sign for an extra 3-4 years at the end of this season.

[ILLDieADemon 804]

I think a lot of his decision to stay had to do with our performance this season, considering we are winning now with out him being the center of our forward line means the pressure of off him to preform well every week and he can just enjoy playing football.

Plus if he really wanted to go  it would be in the media a lot more because those reports know everything going on before if happens most of the time. 

Edited April 24, 2016 by ILLDieADemon

[goodwindees 2,117]

It is a very logical question because besides homesickness this diamond has some flaws. Would love him to stay and be the player that everyone predicts but on his form this year I am a lot more relaxed about the "go home" factor. 

TBH after a few weak efforts last night I did actually wonder whether Freos 1st & 2nd plus Neale was worth floating. 

As I say, want to keep him but very relaxed if he doesn't want to be a part of it. 

[Ethan Tremblay 28,299]

12 hours ago, praha said:

Freo won't finish last. They'll string some games together and still win 8-10 games imo.

Did you watch yesterday's game? They were that bad. Fyfe might miss a few due to injury as well. 

[dazzledavey36 48,655]

You'd be seriously crazy to consider leaving a club thats really on the up to a club that on the downfall with alot of ageing players who are crippled.

Up to you Hoges..

[Little Goffy 12,513]

10 hours ago, DemonAndrew said:

no, lose hogan and we're back to the drawing board for a target man.

 

he's vital to our future progress.

Unless Weidmann and Hulett and the Kings come along well.

I'd be upset if we lost Hogan, I think he's a genuine big deal, but he isn't club-defining.

Anyway, speculating about off-loading him for the best price is a bit like thinking about breaking up with someone you love, just because you feel anxious about losing them.

[Mazer Rackham 14,968]

We're doing exactly what we need to do. Winning games, playing exciting footy, buzz, crowds ... regardless of what Freo are doing, we're making it very hard for ANY player to want to jump ship.

[praha 10,267]

1 hour ago, Little Goffy said:

Unless Weidmann and Hulett and the Kings come along well.

I'd be upset if we lost Hogan, I think he's a genuine big deal, but he isn't club-defining.

Anyway, speculating about off-loading him for the best price is a bit like thinking about breaking up with someone you love, just because you feel anxious about losing them.

Definitely understating Hogan's importance. 

[Redleg 37,480]

1 hour ago, dazzledavey36 said:

You'd be seriously crazy to consider leaving a club thats really on the up to a club that on the downfall with alot of ageing players who are crippled.

Up to you Hoges..

These are the facts.

We are on the rise, Freo appear to be on the slide.

Jesse loves Melbourne the city and the club.

He will get similar money from us to any other offer.

We were supportive of him when he was out for the season.

He is not dominating the game this year and yet we are playing well.

He is great mates with Harmes , JKH and appears to get on with the rest of the boys.

He gets to play at the G at least 10 times a year.

If he goes to Freo he flies each second week across Australia and he has had back problems.

Freo want McCarthy and Hooker and won't have a first round pick to offer us and with the older players going, won't want to lose any young stars. As Hogan is contracted in 2017 any offer would have to be massive and I am not sure they would see it as worthwhile, putting all their eggs in one basket. They need to get several young players into their club.

He probably does miss his family and mates in Perth.

That is what he needs to balance. I don't believe that footballers are totally motivated by missing family and mates. Yes it plays a part in any decision, but so do the other factors.

FWIW,  I think he will stay for a few more years at least.

Edited April 25, 2016 by Redleg

[Adzman 2,085]

Hogan can reach superstar status if he stays at Melbourne. Only gws and the Bulldogs can offer such a promising young engine room to feed him for the next 5 years.

If he goes to Freo he will be waiving his arms with dissatisfaction every week. They are on the slide and look headed for a 3-5 year rebuild. He won't reach superstar status at Freo.

[Deecisive 1,651]

A more successful melbourne with an up and coming list will also be a major reason to stay. If we do not progress from last year then he would certainly think about other options. everyone wants success. some of our long suffering players have stuck with us through some horribly lean times. Now I prey they all get a real taste of success and that Hogan is part of that success.