Quote

 

Are you offering to create the comp in 2016 Scarlett? Probably a good idea to do this sooner than later.

Let me know & just post the code for everyone to join.

I'm happy to help out in 2016 , weekly wraps, assist setting scoring etc.

20 th March works for me for draft night.

Auto select draft order, 60 seconds between picks. And reverse snake order on selections.

My suggestion For scoring is:

* Kicks, Handballs, Tackles & Marks all = 3

* Hit Outs = 2

* Points Scored = 4

* Scoring Accuracy = 2

* Free Differential = 1

Total of 21........

Thoughts Lads? 

 

 

im happy with that but i've always hated scoring accuracy and putting it to 2 points i think might be a bit heavy on the scoring.

I'd be interested in putting it to 1 and also adding another category. I'll make the league now and then we can discuss it before the draft.

these are the other categories

D	Disposals	Available via Stats PLUS
ED	Effective Disposals	Available via Stats PLUS
IED	Ineffective Disposals	Available via Stats PLUS
CP	Contested Possessions	Available via Stats PLUS
R50	Rebound 50s	Available via Stats PLUS
CL	Clearances	Available via Stats PLUS
SP	Spoils

Good stuff Scarlett.

Both Contested possesions & Clearances sound like interesting additions. Puts a new spin on the ball magnet type player. I'd be up for adding both @ 1 point value.

Maybe then pump up Hit Outs to 3 to keep the odd number. That would really bring the elite hit out ruckman back into play?

as i suggested earlier i really like the spoils, gives the backmen something more rather then just going outside running defenders. i wont add anything until we get a general consensus from everyone involved. i sent a message out to everyone involved with an invite (I think, if you didnt get one just send me a message and i'll send it).

On 4 February 2016 at 8:17 AM, Old Man Rivers said:

What are you talking about JCB?

Fixing up a flawed scoring system in 2015 will make 2016 a better and more even contest for everyone. We are suggesting nothing more than Hit Outs are worth more than 1 point to bring elite ruckman back into play & handballs are worth the same as kicks.

Thats pretty much it?

Wheres the difficult bit?

You can do this Ol Fella?

Stay tuned we are going to have a ripping 2016 season?

 

 

On 4 February 2016 at 8:17 AM, Old Man Rivers said:

What are you talking about JCB?

Fixing up a flawed scoring system in 2015 will make 2016 a better and more even contest for everyone. We are suggesting nothing more than Hit Outs are worth more than 1 point to bring elite ruckman back into play & handballs are worth the same as kicks.

Thats pretty much it?

Wheres the difficult bit?

You can do this Ol Fella?

Stay tuned we are going to have a ripping 2016 season?

 

None  of this old fella stuff , from you...you are the OLD and Wiseblood...Do you want to end up with NO BLOOD - cheeky buggar!

o'hara (Scarlett) thanks for taking us on this year...appreciated ...refer email...

 

only need another 6 coaches wanted....Mel & OMR will go last and second last in picking order and I will go first , based on last years results,right...?

 

3 hours ago, scarlett said:

im happy with that but i've always hated scoring accuracy and putting it to 2 points i think might be a bit heavy on the scoring.

I'd be interested in putting it to 1 and also adding another category. I'll make the league now and then we can discuss it before the draft.

I'm in.

Thanks Scarlett.

I also hate scoring accuracy.

I mean if your team kicks 20 goals 21 to 10 goals 1, to lose that point seems silly to me.

Lads with all the dislike of the "scoring accuracy" surfacing how about we park that entire category in 2016.

That way we can add , Spoils & clearances or contested possesions!! This will give a total fresh feel to the Comp this season?

1 hour ago, Old Man Rivers said:

Lads with all the dislike of the "scoring accuracy" surfacing how about we park that entire category in 2016.

That way we can add , Spoils & clearances or contested possesions!! This will give a total fresh feel to the Comp this season?

I like spoils, I like the idea of making the game as even as possible as often it is heavily midfield based. 

Adding contested and clearances will further increase this, that's said il go with the majority! 

I strongly believe we should leave the scoring as Matt has proposed...to many variables as is...with possibly only 14 teams, this will be enough change.

however, what are we doing re keepers....having two from last year as we agreed last year?

this is the issue we need to sort out....not the scoring...that's been solved by our Manager..

JCB

We can't have keepers in 2016

There is to much churn with teams dropping out & new ones arriving. Matt asked for in put into the scoring so players are just putting there views forward. Things won't change to much & all will be good.

Some good suggestions here folks.

Re scoring, I don't like accuracy either, and it would be good to have hit outs worth more than last year. Other than that I am not really fussed, although would prefer games to be decided on the main stats.

Happy to drop to 14 teams, certainly better than 16.

Hey Scarlett

So how are the numbers looking.

Do we have a full comp yet?

OK..... Currently only 9 teams listed in comp.  It's hard to identify who is who from your list. There is 10 teams listed, I think Mad MELBOURNE might be the missing team? Lads if possible can you change your team names to match your Demonland Name until we have a full comp, 14 Teams.

looks like there is no other returning teams from 2015.

So we now need to recruit 4 fresh teams. Scarlett does the above sound about right before we open this comp up?

sorry i've been living away with work, so far 9 teams. good idea with the names, until we have a full team. I'm about to upgrade the comp so we can have all the extra options, also has an option for extra managers, I'd be interested in giving someone else access while I'm doing living away work, will be away for another 2 weeks.

OK this is what catorgories I have ticked at the moment, if we all agree on these then we can choose how much they will be worth
 

Stat	Description	Value
SCOR	Scoreboard Impact	5
KI	Kicks	4
HB	Handballs	3
MA	Marks	3
HO	Hitouts	2
TA	Tackles	2
SP	Spoils	2
FD	Free Kick Differential	1

 

 

These are all the ones that are available
 

Stat	Description	Use?	Weight
SCOR	Scoreboard Impact
%	Goal Kicking Accuracy
KI	Kicks
HB	Handballs
MA	Marks
HO	Hitouts
TA	Tackles
FF	Free Kicks For
FA	Free Kicks Against
FD	Free Kick Differential
D	Disposals
ED	Effective Disposals
IED	Ineffective Disposals
D%	Disposal Efficiency
CP	Contested Possessions
R50	Rebound 50s
CL	Clearances
SP	Spoils

 

Gary I added you as a league manager just to help out in case someone tries to join while I'm away during the week. if anyone wants to join from last year, just send them the link that you all received to join.

1 hour ago, scarlett said:

Gary I added you as a league manager just to help out in case someone tries to join while I'm away during the week. if anyone wants to join from last year, just send them the link that you all received to join.

Hey Matt

No problem, I will keep an eye on things. I like your suggested categories. I have  listed my thoughts on category value.

1 hour ago, scarlett said:

OK this is what catorgories I have ticked at the moment, if we all agree on these then we can choose how much they will be worth
 

Stat	Description	Value
SCOR	Scoreboard Impact	5
KI	Kicks	4
HB	Handballs	3
MA	Marks	3
HO	Hitouts	2
TA	Tackles	2
SP	Spoils	2
FD	Free Kick Differential	1

 

 

These are all the ones that are available
 

Stat	Description	Use?	Weight
SCOR	Scoreboard Impact
%	Goal Kicking Accuracy
KI	Kicks
HB	Handballs
MA	Marks
HO	Hitouts
TA	Tackles
FF	Free Kicks For
FA	Free Kicks Against
FD	Free Kick Differential
D	Disposals
ED	Effective Disposals
IED	Ineffective Disposals
D%	Disposal Efficiency
CP	Contested Possessions
R50	Rebound 50s
CL	Clearances
SP	Spoils

 

4 for Score

3 for kicks, HB, Marks, Hit Outs & Tackles.

1 for spoils & Free Kick Diff

Total = 21

Thoughts Lads?

4 team spots up for grabs?

20 minutes ago, Old Man Rivers said:

4 team spots up for grabs?

on the ultimate footy page it only has 9 people listed so far, if you go to join a league you can find last years league but i am unable to click through to the link to get the names of everyone from last year so we can message them, or perhaps we can start a thread on the main board to alert them to this one

Officially out in 2016

* Robbo 24

* Jacko 13

* I Luv Tingay

* Marc R - the team Melissa took over last season.

Mad MELBOURNE has confirmed however not sure if registered in comp yet.

The following teams I am just not sure about

PC Demons

Matts Cunning Stunts

Vineys Vagineys? Is that Snomed? - please confirm

Wreckers

The Goodvibes

RPFC

If listed above please confirm if your in & join or let us know you are not playing in 2016......

 

im cunning stunts

peter is pc demons

38 minutes ago, scarlett said:

im cunning stunts

peter is pc demons

OK sweet. Sorry mate I was thinking "Scarlett" for you. 

So that's you 2 off the list.

I will follow up the others.

If not returning we can open comp up next week.

We will cap at 14. That should make for an awesome draft.?

7 hours ago, Old Man Rivers said:

Vineys Vagineys? Is that Snomed? - please confirm

 

Confirmed!

Sorry guys will do it this arvo. Been flat out all weekend. Thought I had, but will amend the issue