Post trade week best 22

[Barney Rubble 1,576]

Dunn not good enough anymore Barney?

I did have him in the BP originally then moved him to HB Then tried to fit him in at HF

In the end out he went.

We will see quite a bit of that next season.

Ain't that great.

Edited October 22, 2015 by Barney Rubble

[Je Roos Salem 661]

Only thing we miss is a 200cm forward/ruck that many teams have. I still think being small(ish) inside 50 can work, we'll just have to get the balance right at both ends of the ground. We know how good Hogan and Garlett are but we need a whole forward line.

I think Salem will be our most important player this season. He deserves a full season. A quality ball user off half back makes a huge difference.

Really hoping Frost can hold down a position too. A restructure in defence would help us

[Bobby McKenzie 2,169]

I noticed that several have Harmes in the best 22. Fair enough, but isn't he a rookie and only available when a long term injury occurs?

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

By the way, not having to think who the sub will be is amazing.

[M_9 1,613]

FCS it's Vandenberg

[Nasher 33,047]

FCS it's Vandenberg

vandenBerg.

[Pitchy 196]

Sorry to be the one to include the unknown draft picks..... but if it's Parish and Weideman then it could look like....

Jetta TMac Garland

Melks Dunn Frost

Parish Jones Brayshaw

Petracca Weed Vanden

Watts Hogan Garlett

Gawn Vince Viney

Int: Salem, Tyson, Bugg, Kent

[Gator 16,891]

Only thing we miss is a 200cm forward/ruck that many teams have. I still think being small(ish) inside 50 can work, we'll just have to get the balance right at both ends of the ground. We know how good Hogan and Garlett are but we need a whole forward line.

I think Salem will be our most important player this season. He deserves a full season. A quality ball user off half back makes a huge difference.

Really hoping Frost can hold down a position too. A restructure in defence would help us

I like the look of 200cm Max King. He's a forward/ruck. Played 8 games for Casey this year kicking 13 goals and taking 30 marks (15 contested). In fact, he's a really good mark and has neat kicking skills for a tall.

He's not quite ready. 1-2 years. Plays all of next year as a 20 year old.

Callum Sinclair came from Port, is 26 and has played 29 games. Sydney were very keen to take him off West Coast's hands. Like King, he's not a number one ruck, but more a forward/ruck.

It can take a while, but Max is tracking exceptionally well.

[binman 37,798]

I know you're only human ProDee, but forgetting Brayshaw is near-unforgivable.

Like red heads are callwd bluey maybe tiptoes is brayshaw?

[binman 37,798]

I did have him in the BP originally then moved him to HB Then tried to fit him in at HF

In the end out he went.

We will see quite a bit of that next season.

Ain't that great.

Dunn not in our best 22? Please.

[Gator 16,891]

Like red heads are called bluey maybe tiptoes is brayshaw?

Negative.

[Maldonboy38 5,813]

This is really difficult to do. A lot of players of similar potential output.

B: Jetta Dunn Garland

HB: Lamumba/Bugg TMac Melksham

C: Salem N Jones Vince

HF: Kent Hogan Brayshaw

F: Petracca Dawes/Frost Garlett

R: Gawn Viney Tyson

I: Trengove, VandenBerg, Kennedy, White (if I remember, Mitch White is the left-footer)

I hate putting two players in one position but I cannot separate or decide between Dawes or Frost, Lamumba or Bugg. Whichever one makes it the other will not make it into the 22. I also have a sneaking suspicion that one of Max King or young Smith the tall Rookie may surprise for the 2nd big forward role to help Hogan, and neither Dawes nor Frost will hold their spot.

Disappointed I couldn't fit Harmes, Bugg, Stretch or ANB into the 22.

Edited October 22, 2015 by Maldonboy38

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

Like red heads are callwd bluey maybe tiptoes is brayshaw?

It's clearly Watts.

[Red and Blue realist 2,026]

FB: Jetta Dunn Garland

HB: Salem TMac Melksham

C: Vince Viney Watts

HF: Kent Dawes Petracca

FF: Frost Hogan Garlett

R: Gawn Jones Tyson

Int: Vanders, Brayshaw, Lumumba, Bugg

Depth:

Pure backmen: OMac, White, Terlich

Back/Mid: Grimes

Pure Mid: Trengove, Stetch, M Jones, Mitchie

Fwd/Mid: Newton, ANB, JHK, Kennedy

Pure Fwd: Harmes, Hunt

Ruck/Fwd: Spencer (altough only ruck), King, Pedersen

If we went to the draft searching for positions rather than best available (which we will), I'd say we still want more mids, especially classy in/out mids (we should be right for inside mids), key forwards or fwds who can ruck, another key back and another ruck.

IMO Guys who need a big season to make it to 2017 would be: Pedersen, Spencer, King, Hunt, Harmes, Mitchie, M Jones, Terlich, Grimes and Mitchie. That excludes Trengove who just needs to get on the park and play footy consistently, otherwise if injury hits again he'll probably retire.

[binman 37,798]

It's clearly Watts.

As I might have said in primary school - der fred.

I'm surprised wattsy even got in pro dees depth list

Edited October 22, 2015 by binman

[binman 37,798]

By the by pro dee I'm with you on king. Going forward I reckon he will be crucial player. I remember thinking when he kicked a goal in his one and only nab game in 2014 that he had something. Quite agile for a big fella

Edited October 22, 2015 by binman

[Roger Mellie 3,485]

Do you ever walk out of the house and have that feeling you've forgotten something ? That's the feeling I had.

In this case your keys, just as the door slams behind you.

[Gator 16,891]

In this case your keys, just as the door slams behind you.

I don't lock any doors when I go out.

Have you seen my dogs ?

[watchtheeyes 1,210]

I noticed that several have Harmes in the best 22. Fair enough, but isn't he a rookie and only available when a long term injury occurs?

I would upgrade him in a heartbeat... I reckon he could really be something.

[w00dy 146]

B: Jetta, Dunn, Garland

HB: Lumumba, T. McDonald, Melksham

C: Vince, Tyson, Salem

HF: Kent, Dawes, Vandenberg

F: Garlett, Hogan, Pedersen

R: Gawn, Jones, Viney

I :Bugg, Brayshaw, Watts, Kennedy

E: Stretch, Neal-Bullen, Frost

Trengove and Petracca could work their way into the best 22, but will need some VFL games to start I'd think. Lumumba very lucky to make the starting 18, as I'd prefer Salem on HB.

[M_9 1,613]

vandenBerg.

anyone can edit wikipedia Nasher, so don't believe everything you see there.

The MFC site has the correct spelling (you'd expect). Then again, you may just be trying to get a ride out of me?

[daisycutter 28,459]

anyone can edit wikipedia Nasher, so don't believe everything you see there.

The MFC site has the correct spelling (you'd expect). Then again, you may just be trying to get a ride out of me?

seems like the melbourne web site can't make its mind up m_9

Aaron Vandenberg - melbournefc.com.au

Profile

... Vandenberg a mint investment. Aaron Vandenberg looms as a bargain

recruit for the Demons. ... Inside access: Aaron vandenBerg. ...

Player profile | Monday, April 13, 2015 3:14PM

Freshly minted vandenBerg a hit

... 4:46pm Oct 15, 2015. Freshly minted vandenBerg a hit. ... Aaron vandenBerg.

AARON vandenBerg can hardly believe his luck. ...

News Article | Friday, June 05, 2015 4:37PM

Garland has surgery, vandenBerg hamstrung

... Jake Melksham highlights. 4:46pm Oct 15, 2015. Garland has surgery,

vandenBerg hamstrung. Peter Ryan June 11, 2015 9:26 AM. ...

News Article | Thursday, June 11, 2015 9:26AM

vandenBerg could miss rest of season - melbournefc.com.au

... vandenBerg could miss rest of season. ... He'll (vandenBerg) miss at least a couple

of weeks, but we'll just monitor that over the next few days ...

[3Dee 1,153]

... Pedersen played 2 games this year from my counting that absolutely got him picked for the next week, otherwise he was average to somewhat useful. That he is so beloved on here has me baffled,...

it's quite simple, he can consistently take an overhead mark and is a better ruck option

[Chris 2,892]

FB: Jetta Dunn Garland

HB: Salem McDonald Melksham

C: Stretch Viney Brayshaw

HF: Kent Hogan Vanders

FF: Garlett Pedersen Petracca

Foll: Gawn Vince Jones

Int: Tyson Kennedy Bugg Watts

Backs; Lumumba Grimes Frost OMac White Terlich

Mids: ANB Harmes Trengove Michie Newton M Jones

Fwds: JKH Dawes King Hunt

Ruck: Spencer

Included the new boys as Roos has a track record of playing the guys he recruits.

Not a whole lot of structural change in the talls but there should be competition for spots especially down back. The main thing I'm hoping for is increased speed and endurance and hopefully more goal kicking power.

I have had a look at the games played of the team you listed, which I think will be close, and compared it to the top four from 2015 as they played in the prelim finals. Results show just how lacking we are in experience, but that points to good times ahead if we can keep the group together. Also says west Coast are looking like the most likely of this bunch to have sustained success for the next 5 years or so with a big bunch of 100-150 gamers coming through, that may well be us in another 4 years or so (hopefully sooner).

Games MFC HFC FFC WCE NM

0-50 14 1 1 4 4

51-100 2 4 7 4 3

101-150 4 6 9 10 6

151-200 2 3 0 4 4

200+ 0 8 5 0 5

[M_9 1,613]

I'm hopeful that Hunt can have a full pre-season. I know the family and the word was that Roos was grooming him for a HBF prior to a recurrence on his back problem. Has been given a 12 month contract. One issue may be a lack of height across that line unless Lumumba plays.