POST MATCH DISCUSSION - Round 10

[P-man 13,366]

Watts had one of his better games for the season, and in terms of his work in close, one of his best to date. If he can show more of the physicality he showed yesterday, a lot of the noise will die down. It's not a high bar, but it will do.

His pace over 20 metres is a weapon he needs to exploit a lot more often. It surprises me everytime he hits the jets just how quick he is for his size.

Re Newton, if a a player of his ilk replaces the likes of M Jones on the list as depth, we're moving in the right direction.

[P-man 13,366]

Then don't say we were stiff we were not.

We made a number of bad errors and lost the game nothing stiff about it.

We would have been stiff if we had a decison go against us in the last couple of minutes and lost by less than a goal.

Why do you want to deign the facts ?

I think jumbo's point was that we were stiff to have Cloke kicking as straight as he has in a couple of years, not that we were stiff to lose the game. Cloke was in rare form. On another day he would've likely sprayed a few.

[old dee 23,801]

I think jumbo's point was that we were stiff to have Cloke kicking as straight as he has in a couple of years, not that we were stiff to lose the game. Cloke was in rare form. On another day he would've likely sprayed a few.

Agree with that p-man I know that is not jr,s form.

It just annoys me how many Dees supporters alway have an excuse for not winning.

[Elwood 3184 1,314]

WELL GET THEM NEXT TIME by Whispering Jack

...

There was also a lot made of the fact that Collingwoods Adam Oxley was allowed to roam the back half unattended and Melbourne seemed to constantly kick in his direction where the numbers dictated that he was going to win the ball more often than not. I simply didnt get that Paul Roos was unable to change things with the simple move necessary to cover that situation but I for one, got sick of seeing number 43 mark it on his own time and again. It was almost as if our one avenue to goal was through Oxley and if you are going to have a go at a player for tunnel balling the pill through goals and giving away six points, then the coach who allows an unattended opposition player to save several times more through his inaction has a lot to answer for (as do I for ending a sentence with a preposition).

Awesome.

[beelzebub 23,380]

I think you have slayed that one bb.

All haters have disappeared.

i feel odd

[grazman 7,436]

It was pretty technical. If the ball stayed on the ground it was not free but because he lifted it slightly ...boom...free kick. The ump could just have easily let it slide.

Maybe I'm just getting old, but the rule hasn't changed since I was playing, you were taught to close your fist and punch the ball and you can never be called for a throw.

[old dee 23,801]

Maybe I'm just getting old, but the rule hasn't changed since I was playing, you were taught to close your fist and punch the ball and you can never be called for a throw.

You maybe grazman but it is still correct

[Deestroy All 14,266]

I'm not happy with Newton at this point. Whilst he looks like a nice enough player when he (too rarely) has the ball in space, I'd go as far as to say he appears to be the physically weakest player on our list. He gets bumped off the ball, out of contests so damn easily, no resistance at all.

He needs to go away and build strength and a tank. I think he'll be a nice icing player but at the moment he has no influence in a battling side.

[jumbo returns 6,741]

No we weren't jr.

over the 120 minutes they played better and kicked a higher score.

That means they deserved the win we did not.

We were stiff he kicked straight, od.

Like my putting, he's had the yips for a couple of years now....

[P-man 13,366]

Agree with that p-man I know that is not jr,s form.

It just annoys me how many Dees supporters alway have an excuse for not winning.

I know you do mate, but the post match discussions would be pretty brief if they were reduced to "we lost". Looking at why we lost, areas for improvement, and areas we excelled is all on the path towards becoming a better side.

[old dee 23,801]

We were stiff he kicked straight, od.

Like my putting, he's had the yips for a couple of years now....

Yes jr That i agree with.

How many times has he kicked seven straight

The answer is probably never.

[old dee 23,801]

I know you do mate, but the post match discussions would be pretty brief if they were reduced to "we lost". Looking at why we lost, areas for improvement, and areas we excelled is all on the path towards becoming a better side.

You are right I am just tied of a decade of losing and having excuses made every week.

Edited June 9, 2015 by old dee

[Curry & Beer 5,444]

Then don't say we were stiff we were not.

We made a number of bad errors and lost the game nothing stiff about it.

We would have been stiff if we had a decison go against us in the last couple of minutes and lost by less than a goal.

Why do you want to deign the facts ?

I'm not 'deigning' anything

We have read that you were disappointed with the loss, as you have expressed yourself thusly in about 15,000 posts in the last 28 hours

We get it

[jumbo returns 6,741]

Yes jr That i agree with.

How many times has he kicked seven straight

The answer is probably never.

I know one thing, od...i have NEVER been 7 under in my golf.

One day....

[beelzebub 23,380]

We were stiff he kicked straight, od.

Like my putting, he's had the yips for a couple of years now....

even my fiilth mate said we were unfortunate lol

[old dee 23,801]

even my fiilth mate said we were unfortunate lol

Even allowing for his straight kicking we could have won this game if we did not make all those bloody poor mistakes.

Without Two terrible passes in front of goal and the tunnel ball and there is then a goal in it.

Anything is possible but sadly we played poorly on those occasions and there goes the game.

[beelzebub 23,380]

I mean...if only someone had run through Oxley....

[old dee 23,801]

I mean...if only someone had run through Oxley....

Hawthorn would have bb

[G-max 154]

Nice work team. Analysed the bejesus out of that Watts' mark attempt.

[P-man 13,366]

You are right I am just tied of a decade of losing and having excuses made every week.

You've seen more decades of waiting than most, so I get where you're coming from. But there are excuses and there are realities.

The margin was at risk of blowing out not once but twice, and both times it was clawed back through honest work rate. I make no apologies for being pleasantly surprised by that. Fighting tooth and nail to stay in the contest has been a rarity for Melbourne sides in tthe past five years or more.

We rid ourselves of the stupid errors, which will come with development and fundamentally more skillful players wearing the jumper, we'll be winning that game and alot more like it.

Stopping a kid from taking 14 marks floating free as a bird in the backline wouldn't hurt either,

[Deecisive 1,709]

watts attempted mark was unfortunate, if he dived and did not take it cleanly then the Collingwood player would have run away with it. diving usually works best when you are diving forward that way you can block the ball going past you.

fitzy's throw was not a lot different from what you see players do around the ground when they 'paddle' it to the boundary, if he had had his fist closed he would have been fine.

Lots of errors, but also lots of improvement, the team looks to be playing a better grade of footy and still has a lot of upside. This year is about making progress, yesterdays game was good progress.

[beelzebub 23,380]

Nice work team. Analysed the bejesus out of that Watts' mark attempt.

some of our better collaborative work for sure.

[M C 221]

Even allowing for his straight kicking we could have won this game if we did not make all those bloody poor mistakes.

Without Two terrible passes in front of goal and the tunnel ball and there is then a goal in it.

Anything is possible but sadly we played poorly on those occasions and there goes the game.

Real insightful OD. "Don't make mistakes". Perfect.

[beelzebub 23,380]

Real insightful OD. "Don't make mistakes". Perfect.

if you're not joking...I wouldn't be. It actually goes to the root of our malaise. A lot of things CAN be nullified . A. Lot of effort can go into scoring and those little brain fades can bring effort undone.

Not making mistakes helps big time.

[monoccular 17,434]

It was pretty technical. If the ball stayed on the ground it was not free but because he lifted it slightly ...boom...free kick. The ump could just have easily let it slide.

How many golas have we given up in the last 4 weeks on the gial line because our defenders can't kill the pill when it is dribbling around the goal line. I'd suggest at least 5.

FMD its frustrating.

PSD is correct it was a throw and a free kick.

It was there and the ump saw it.

If he had fisted it and not used open hands (x2) would probably have been okay