2015 apparent out of contract players merged with targets at seasons end

[DistrACTION Jackson 6,395]

Ruckmen can be over-rated:

2014 Hawks: Hale/McEvoy

2013 Hawks: Bailey/Hale

2012 Swans: Mumford/Pyke

2011 Cats: Ottens/West

2010 Pies: Jolly/L.Brown

all of those are better than what we have.

[Soidee 1,496]

The biggest worry is our clear lack of depth when we have injuries. We still have to recruit mids and a ruck combination, however, the club must continue to de-dud our list cloggers who are still on the payroll

[Binmans PA 25,897]

Which will look ridiculous if he has an average year, decides to leave anyway and gets less money. If he was so emphatic about knocking back the deal then I'm shocked that he hasn't re-signed with us yet.

It's possible that we haven't offered him a deal.

[Binmans PA 25,897]

The biggest worry is our clear lack of depth when we have injuries. We still have to recruit mids and a ruck combination, however, the club must continue to de-dud our list cloggers who are still on the payroll

It takes time I'm afraid. In two years time, if we're still in the same position I'll be very worried. Given the list Roos inherited, I think he's done very well so far to turn the list over and bring in some B graders.

[dee-luded 2,958]

I don't get why everyone wants to move Salem. He is the perfect half back runner with speed and skill. Yes definitely throw him into the middle for a few centre clearances but he is very valuable currently running off half back.

eventually, i think he'll be a waste off half back, I think he'll be more creative than just a half back.

after he learn's the halfback role and he gets stronger, he may move to around the middle more?

I think it was Howe for pick 7. I would have jumped at it, myself.

EDIT. Sorry, a little late on that reply.

may have been late because GWS are interested in Howe, but didn't want to take the risk of losing Shiel last year. they will anyway I think. but they're at least given themselves the chance to keep him.

I think the Hawks cats blues & pies will be circling close by. as will Sheedy, be buzzing about.

I reckon we have to lucre that GWS want, but does Shiel want here, or elsewhere?

I dont know that all top level rucks have "mongrel" some do some dont

Stef m had 20 possessions vs carlton (?) but doesnt have mongrel

Id like a ruck who is an extra midfielder over a straight tap plodder with mongrel

yes, but as I said earlier give me 'Clark Keating' over all our past rucks. crashes packs, players, & the ball, & marks around the ground on Que. a true BIG game player, & premiership winner. turned games

Edited May 15, 2015 by dee-luded

[What 18,810]

The biggest worry is our clear lack of depth when we have injuries. We still have to recruit mids and a ruck combination, however, the club must continue to de-dud our list cloggers who are still on the payroll

Not really a worry, besides for the rest this season

The depth is much better than last year and after this seasons trade and draft period it will be fixed completely.

[spirit of norm smith 12,840]

Offer Leuenberger a 4-yr $1.2m contract and see what happens.

[rjay 23,867]

Not really a worry, besides for the rest this season

The depth is much better than last year and after this seasons trade and draft period it will be fixed completely.

It's never completely fixed 'hogan', always a work in progress...but yes the list should have better balance. A couple of A graders in the middle would be good though.

[Binmans PA 25,897]

Not really a worry, besides for the rest this season

The depth is much better than last year and after this seasons trade and draft period it will be fixed completely.

Disagree. We're another two years off having solid depth.

Offer Leuenberger a 4-yr $1.2m contract and see what happens.

I know what will have happened. We'll have spent $700,000 more than we should have.

Edited May 15, 2015 by AdamFarr

[What 18,810]

Disagree. We're another two years off having solid depth.

Disagree with that, I think we will have solid depth after this draft/trade period and really good depth after that going forward (assuming the club is fixed and Goodwin and co know what they are doing)

[Binmans PA 25,897]

Disagree with that, I think we will have solid depth after this draft/trade period and really good depth after that going forward (assuming the club is fixed and Goodwin and co know what they are doing)

We'll agree to disagree there then. I think Kent and Jetta's injuries have shown our severe lack of depth, along with the fact that we've had to bring in Matt Jones, Grimes and Bail. Their inclusions speak volumes. We've gone from a D grade midfield last year to a C grade midfield this year. It's ultimately a very young midfield too.

[Frosty Demon 153]

David Armitage.

Would be great! but he plays with such spirit for the Saints I doubt if he would ever leave. He's totally bought in. Your on the right track tho and an enquiry should be sent. We need players to commit to the Dees like he has to the Saints.

[dazzledavey36 48,646]

Would be great! but he plays with such spirit for the Saints I doubt if he would ever leave. He's totally bought in. Your on the right track tho and an enquiry should be sent. We need players to commit to the Dees like he has to the Saints.

Jones, Salem, JKH, Brayshaw, Viney, Hogan and now Petracca have all signed extensions to commit to this club?

Just remember they have had their fair share of loss in experience players.. Goddard, Dal Santo, McEvoy just to name a few..

[Dwight Schrute 16,722]

7 mil for 7 years to Shiel?

[DistrACTION Jackson 6,395]

7 mil for 7 years to Shiel?

That is way too much money. He's good but not that good.

I'd say 5 mill over 7 would be about right

[Frosty Demon 153]

That is way too much money. He's good but not that good.

I'd say 5 mill over 7 would be about right

lets not quibble over a couple of million dollars here

[Binmans PA 25,897]

That is way too much money. He's good but not that good.

I'd say 5 mill over 7 would be about right

He's totally worth that and sometimes you have a to pay a bit more to get what you desperately need.

[Machsy 2,856]

Agreed, and as I have put about 5 times, Howie gave it one second of thought and said NO

Do you REALLY expect Howe to tell you "yeah, I sat down and thought hard about it for days, gave it a lot of thought... but thought that in the end I had a better chance of hiding my deficiencies at Melbourne and getting a fat payday in the long run"

You amaze me sometimes with your stubborn ignorance of reality.

They are not going to tell you what they really think.

[Dwight Schrute 16,722]

Look at shiels stats and games this year, he's that good..

[Binmans PA 25,897]

Look at shiels stats and games this year, he's that good..

Would have loved Shiel today.

[What 18,810]

Agreed, and as I have put about 5 times, Howie gave it one second of thought and said NO

Damn shame

To think we could have gotten pick 7 for that spud makes me so angry

[dee-luded 2,958]

Do you REALLY expect Howe to tell you "yeah, I sat down and thought hard about it for days, gave it a lot of thought... but thought that in the end I had a better chance of hiding my deficiencies at Melbourne and getting a fat payday in the long run"

You amaze me sometimes with your stubborn ignorance of reality.

They are not going to tell you what they really think.

Silvagni, now away from the Giants, & recruiting I believe for Carlton may be interested still???

if they are interested in a Howe, it shouldn't be too big a move for the fella. after all, he grew up I think, next door to Carlton?

[dee-luded 2,958]

Would have loved Shiel today.

would have loved him 2 years back. why by at the top of the market?

would have loved Boak 5 yrs back, when I wanted us to chase him. 2009ish

would have loved Dangerfield 5 yrs back, when I wanted us to chase him. 2009-2010ish

& vickery as well, is it too late? a good prospect for power forward/2ndruck. the boy is starting to mature.

Edited May 17, 2015 by dee-luded

[WhyAlwaysMe 237]

lets give Roos & Dawes another 20%

[Binmans PA 25,897]

would have loved him 2 years back. why by at the top of the market?

would have loved Boak 5 yrs back, when I wanted us to chase him. 2009ish

would have loved Dangerfield 5 yrs back, when I wanted us to chase him. 2009-2010ish

& vickery as well, is it too late? a good prospect for power forward/2ndruck. the boy is starting to mature.

I agree with the others, but not Vickery. Not to mention, a bloody ordinary player and a bloody ordinary bloke.

Edited May 18, 2015 by AdamFarr