POST MATCH DISCUSSION - ROUND 1, 2015

[mauriesy 6,787]

it was after the Prince goal and we led by 18 when that fumble happened. 8:15 remaining

Correct. When Ablett fumbled it was 95-77 with about 8 minutes left. Melbourne took it down the length of the ground, Hogan marked and made it 101-77.

[Akum 2,660]

To be honest, seeing him crash that pack and get up quicker than the GC players brought me as much joy as his goals. Reminded me of Neitz and Schwartz in their day.

...

He will put in a game this year that will have the rest of the competition shaking in their boots.

And it wasn't as if the two defenders were slouches either. Malceski & Broughton.

And to me the most pleasing thing about Hogan's game on Sat was that it was "just a game". He really just did the good things well. He didn't star, he didn't extend himself, he didn't do anything amazing, he wasn't BOG.

That's all yet to come!!

[Gator 16,891]

And it wasn't as if the two defenders were slouches either. Malceski & Broughton.

And to me the most pleasing thing about Hogan's game on Sat was that it was "just a game". He really just did the good things well. He didn't star, he didn't extend himself, he didn't do anything amazing, he wasn't BOG.

That's all yet to come!!

He didn't star, but I thought he was terrific.

15 possessions, 7 marks - 4 contested, splitting packs, goals ... all on their best defender in his first game as a key forward is exceptional.

In fact, he took the second most contested marks for the entire round along with Nick Riewoldt (just one behind the leader on 5).

It wasn't "just a game".

[What 18,810]

He didn't star, but I thought he was terrific.

15 possessions, 7 marks - 4 contested, splitting packs, goals ... all on their best defender in his first game as a key forward is exceptional.

In fact, he took the second most contested marks for the entire round along with Nick Riewoldt (just one behind the leader on 5).

It wasn't "just a game".

Was a fantastic debut

I think there were some supporters who literally expected him to kick 8 and wouldn't accept anything less

[Dees2014 2,377]

Yes, you can't help drawing the comparison with David Neitz. His interview on Open Mike I watched recently (from July 2014) and he talked briefly about when he started. I think Hogan will be the closest thing we will see to Neitz, and I for one can think of no greater praise.

Now all we need to do is to turn Chris Dawes into the footballer David Schwartz....mmm - don't think so somehow!

Edited April 7, 2015 by Dees2014

[The Song Formerly Known As 6,479]

Yes, you can't help drawing the comparison with David Neitz. His interview on Open Mike I watched recently (from July 2014) and he talked briefly about when he started. I think Hogan will be the closest thing we will see to Neitz, and I for one can think of no greater praise.

Now all we need to do is to turn Chris Dawes into the footballer David Schwartz....mmm - don't think so somehow!

[binman 37,956]

He didn't star, but I thought he was terrific.

15 possessions, 7 marks - 4 contested, splitting packs, goals ... all on their best defender in his first game as a key forward is exceptional.

In fact, he took the second most contested marks for the entire round along with Nick Riewoldt (just one behind the leader on 5).

It wasn't "just a game".

It was for jesse

[Curry & Beer 5,444]

Was a fantastic debut

I think there were some supporters who literally expected him to kick 8 and wouldn't accept anything less

It was about the best debut I could have possibly hoped for

Had he played half as well, I still would have been happy

[Chook 14,467]

Thanks for posting this. It was a great watch.

[Trisul 636]

Schwartz Schwarz.

[Undeeterred 2,839]

Finally got to watch the replay....

I'm going to have an early crack at our B&F top 5...

1. Dom Tyson - absolutely all class. Will be our next AA.

2. Nathan Jones - Obvs.

3. Tom McDonald - looks so much more assured when the ball isn't coming in a thousand times a game, and he has some runners to give it to in space

4. Lynden Dunn - I was a big hater for many, many years, but gee has he turned it around.

5. Jack Watts - this year's the year. So, so damaging, all over the ground.

And I can't even fit in Jesse Hogan. He was spectacular on the weekend. What a debut. When he is 24-27, he is going to be a complete and utter monster.

[hardtack 10,126]

Finally got to watch the replay....

I'm going to have an early crack at our B&F top 5...

1. Dom Tyson - absolutely all class. Will be our next AA.

2. Nathan Jones - Obvs.

3. Tom McDonald - looks so much more assured when the ball isn't coming in a thousand times a game, and he has some runners to give it to in space

4. Lynden Dunn - I was a big hater for many, many years, but gee has he turned it around.

5. Jack Watts - this year's the year. So, so damaging, all over the ground.

And I can't even fit in Jesse Hogan. He was spectacular on the weekend. What a debut. When he is 24-27, he is going to be a complete and utter monster.

Despite being a big fan, I would probably have Lamumba in there ahead of Dunn... and I would not be in the least bit surprised if Nathan Jones makes AA this year (providing he has a another season like last year).

[Dwight Schrute 16,749]

I reckon lamumba, and Garlett will both push top 5 pretty hard

[Cards13 9,117]

HL was really good on the weekend, when teams try to tag him out of the match will be interesting to see how we adapt and what drive fwd we lose if he is contained.

[jnrmac 18,947]

I reckon lamumba, and Garlett will both push top 5 pretty hard

We've all forgotten Bernie.,...

[jnrmac 18,947]

HL was really good on the weekend, when teams try to tag him out of the match will be interesting to see how we adapt and what drive fwd we lose if he is contained.

His running and off the ball stuff is fantastic. Not huge stats but his influence is big,,

[Moneider96 1,045]

To all those doubters. Both Viney and Jamar made the team of the week.

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2015-04-08/team-of-the-week-round-one

[Macca 16,173]

To all those doubters. Both Viney and Jamar made the team of the week.

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2015-04-08/team-of-the-week-round-one

We do tend to under rate ruckmen sometimes ...

If a team doesn't have a good one, that team can get towelled up (e.g Richmond against us last year when Maric was out) Jamar smashed Hampson which subsequently created a decent advantage our way in the clearances.

Mark is another player who has responded to Roos' coaching.

[beelzebub 22,225]

We've all forgotten Bernie.,...

if Bernie is good to go , he comes in.

Edited April 7, 2015 by beelzebub

[Moneider96 1,045]

if Bernie is good to go , he comes in.

Guess he's coming in....

http://www.melbournefc.com.au/news/2015-04-07/vince-ready-to-push-for-senior-claims

[jnrmac 18,947]

if Bernie is good to go , he comes in.

This was in response to the posts above calling the top 5 in the B&F after rd 1!

[Sir Why You Little 34,430]

Incorrect. My memory lied to me also, but when I checked the replay it was after the Prince goal and we led by 18 when that fumble happened. 8:15 remaining check it yourself

You are right

Apologies

[Lucifers Hero 36,991]

Tommy gets 5 out of 5 from both coaches on Saturday. All coach votes from the game:

Melbourne vs Gold Coast
10 Tom McDonald (Melb)
6 Jack Watts (Melb)
4 Jeff Garlett (Melb)
4 Jeremy Howe (Melb)
2 Nathan Jones (Melb)
2 Jack Viney (Melb)
1 Dion Prestia (GC)
1 Michael Rischitelli (GC)

Great endorsement for Tommy. Great example for the team especially little bro!

Edited April 7, 2015 by Lucifer's Hero

[SaberFang 7,141]

Wonder who gave the GC players votes?

[Jesse Christ 2,884]

Was a fantastic debut

I think there were some supporters who literally expected him to kick 8 and wouldn't accept anything less

Well it was no one from demonland.