Post match discussion

[Demonland 72,176]

Tell us what you think ...

[Robot Devil 1,895]

Is it Umpire Appreciation Round yet?

[olisik 4,060]

Few too many chestie marks dropped i50. If our skills were better we would have won that game

[Chook 15,013]

I think Jack Watts needs to take a long hard look at himself.

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

If you don't run, you don't win.

Melbourne didn't run.

That free kick to Ablett was a disgrace.

[Jarka 767]

I suggest we remove Watts from the banner at the top of the page.

[GIRO 63]

Drop watts !!! No intensity at all need time in the 2's

[Bang Bang Bang 5,826]

Firstly, the umpiring was absolutely abysmal. The free to Ablett is EXACTLY the type of free they HAVEN'T been paying this year, and the type of free that ruins games of footy. Tiggy touchwood and a momentum killer. Ablett is so bloody good though.

8 point defeat, probably flatters a bit but under Neeld this would have been 60+. So that's a small positive.

Nathan Jones is the heart and soul of this footy club, but Jack Viney is catching him quickly. Can build a midfield around these two.

Dawes was extremely wasteful, but he makes us so much better. Frawley likewise.

I like Jack Watts but how can one defend him after that? Career is at the crossroads. If Roos can't turn him into a player, nobody will. Heartless.

[Chook 15,013]

I suggest we remove Watts from the banner at the top of the page.

Replace him with Chris Dawes immediately.

[The Song Formerly Known As 6,479]

Yup, so tired of standing up for Watts. Really am.

[Deecisive 1,709]

We really need to employ a tackling coach. our guys were brushed aside far too easily.

[What 18,810]

Watts is finished

Will never amount to anything in the AFL (or any other contact sport)

[Devil In Disguise 2,278]

Spencer has to go for Jamar or Gawn asap.. He is so ineffective as a ruckman it is not funny & 3 disposals for the game is pathetic.

[Deecisive 1,709]

I would love to see jack spencer punch the ball out of the centre a lot towards our forward line a lot more, dropping at his feet too often results in it going to the opposition.

[whatwhat say what 22,747]

Very curious to see Roos' reaction.

We were pretty poor, but at least in the game.

[P-man 13,366]

Free to Ablett was a complete joke but you take the good with the bad.

Should've won it. Didn't. An improvement.

[jumbo returns 6,741]

We'll be okay.

Dawes is a beast.

Nate Jones is an A GRADE MIDFIELDER!!

[titan_uranus 25,016]

This is now the third game out of four that we've lost when we could easily have won it. The umpiring killed us - too many abysmal decisions went against us at crucial moments, none more so than the Ablett free, which was possibly as bad a decision as there ever has been. Anyone other than Ablett and that wouldn't have been played.

Nonetheless, we were our own worst enemy again today. We had good players down on impact (McDonald got ripped apart, Dunn was shocking, Watts was too quiet, Howe spent half the game again doing nothing) and our substandard players were exposed in the light of a better side's pressure.

Jetta was awful, Terlich is regressing, Spencer got destroyed by a kid in the ruck, Evans added nothing for the second week in a row as sub, Tyson was quiet (shouldn't have been subbed though, Jetta should have).

N Jones again brilliant, Dawes again great, Frawley lifted, Howe lifted in the second half, Vince was good early but disappeared late. Too much left to too little with too many awful skill errors.

We could, and almost should, have won this game, and it sucks that we lost it. But at least we're coming out of games feeling frustrated at losing them, and not despondent over our future.

[Nicho 1]

The same nonsense.

Why does it take us until late in the last quarter to actually start to "MARK AND PLAY ON' its the way you win matches and we are the slowest, most indecisive, worst decision makers. We turn the ball over kicking it 5metres to one on ones. If in doubt just get it 60m forward and move it fast. Our refusal to run was just pathetic... If have that attitude against any of the good sides we will be smashed. Port Adelaide have turned it around by having the right attitude and we were no worse than them 2 years ago.

Watts just need to turn into a man

Vince has gone quiet

Jordie McKenzie gave three free kicks away with lazy slopping tacking and then was stiff with the costly decision

Gold Coast stop running and every other team would have run over the top of them, We had our chance and didn't take. it.

The games now only get harder!

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

Free to Ablett was a complete joke but you take the good with the bad.

Should've won it. Didn't. An improvement.

That's true, after all Frawley's first goal was so clearly touched.

[titan_uranus 25,016]

Firstly, the umpiring was absolutely abysmal. The free to Ablett is EXACTLY the type of free they HAVEN'T been paying this year, and the type of free that ruins games of footy. Tiggy touchwood and a momentum killer. Ablett is so bloody good though.

8 point defeat, probably flatters a bit but under Neeld this would have been 60+. So that's a small positive.

Nathan Jones is the heart and soul of this footy club, but Jack Viney is catching him quickly. Can build a midfield around these two.

Dawes was extremely wasteful, but he makes us so much better. Frawley likewise.

I like Jack Watts but how can one defend him after that? Career is at the crossroads. If Roos can't turn him into a player, nobody will. Heartless.

Agree with all this. Viney's disposal is letting him down a bit but he is already dominating for us in and under.

Some will say the margin flattered us but we won three out of four quarters. That second quarter was Neeld-esque and is where we lost the game, but for 75% of the match we were either equal to the Suns, or better. That's a marked improvement from the Melbourne of 2013, even if it's frustrating.

[SaberFang 7,151]

Think we'll see quite a few changes after that one. So many skill errors and Watts is now exposed for all to see. We'll be a much better side with Kent, Hogan, Salem and Garland playing. Can drop some deadweight.

And I still rate Evans, that was a great goal. He's a sneaky kick that guy. JKH fantastic with a lot of flare, which so much of our team lacks.

Edited April 20, 2014 by Lamashtu

[Demoneyes 562]

Firstly, the umpiring was absolutely abysmal. The free to Ablett is EXACTLY the type of free they HAVEN'T been paying this year, and the type of free that ruins games of footy. Tiggy touchwood and a momentum killer. Ablett is so bloody good though.

8 point defeat, probably flatters a bit but under Neeld this would have been 60+. So that's a small positive.

Nathan Jones is the heart and soul of this footy club, but Jack Viney is catching him quickly. Can build a midfield around these two.

Dawes was extremely wasteful, but he makes us so much better. Frawley likewise.

I like Jack Watts but how can one defend him after that? Career is at the crossroads. If Roos can't turn him into a player, nobody will. Heartless.

2 crucial umpiring decisions in that last quarter certainly made a difference! The Ablett one was poor but just after that Jetta nearly gets his head ripped off, no free but Suns goal! If we didn't go missing in the 2nd qtr could have been a different game!

[olisik 4,060]

Whens Hogan back? its round 5 and he doesnt seem close. They originally said 2-3 weeks.

[The Song Formerly Known As 6,479]

You forgot VINEY- warrior