Buddy Franklin to GWS

[Deano74 156]

On the afl website - GREATER Western Sydney has not ruled out using the No.1 pick in this year's NAB AFL Draft to snare superstar Hawthorn free agent Lance Franklin.

And who will Hawks take with no 1 - Tom Boyd.

Free up the salery cap and the next big thing. It just sux. I hate em.

[Dwight Schrute 16,749]

What happens if we get pick one as a result of the PP potentially?

But i agree, can't see anyone saying no to 10 mil or whatever they are supposed to be offering him

[Deano74 156]

Surely he would take the cash. Hawks would be nearly be pushing him out, how can they lose if they get no 1 pick.

GWS dont need another young foward. They need experience, a star and a marketing tool.

Edited July 11, 2013 by Deano74

[TheoX 1,218]

I know SOS is pretty dumb, but why would he trade the no 1. pick for Buddy when he can get him for nothing via Free Agency?

The Hawks should get compensation in the same way that other clubs have, and ~pick 20 is what that means. We got basically SFA for Rivers and Moloney.

[TheoX 1,218]

Our perfomances show we wont get a PP.

Surely he would take the cash. Hawks would be nearly be pushing him out, how can they lose if they get no 1 pick.

GWS dont need another young foward. They need experience, a star and a marketing tool.

Remind me again how many games have we won in the last 7 years.

[biggestred 4,273]

My mail is that he is 100% gone.

I heard it from a friend via a friend who read it on the internet.

[Robot Devil 1,895]

My mail is that he is 100% gone.

I heard it from a friend via a friend who read it on the internet.

Still a better source than Damien "possibly/maybe/could be/allegedly/" Barrett.

[Deano74 156]

Surely he would take the cash. Hawks would be nearly be pushing him out, how can they lose if they get no 1 pick.

GWS dont need another young foward. They need experience, a star and a marketing tool.

There you go back on the topic.

[Wolfmother 182]

Worst article I have ever seen... A anything is possible comment from SOS and they would trade for him.... BS at that price they get him as a free agent and still have pick one

[Deano74 156]

Will a trade rule out buddy taking another offer of similar size from another club?

What if the Gold Coast make a bid for him ? Even if it was slightly less.

Living on the Gold Coast, playing in a side further developed.

Id choose the Gold Coast over GWS.

[dee-luded 2,958]

On the afl website - GREATER Western Sydney has not ruled out using the No.1 pick in this year's NAB AFL Draft to snare superstar Hawthorn free agent Lance Franklin.

And who will Hawks take with no 1 - Tom Boyd.

Free up the salery cap and the next big thing. It just sux. I hate em.

I'm not sure?

the hawks would like Boyd no doubt,,, but I wonder if they need Mids more. they're topline mids are all nearly over the Hill...

it'll be interesting. thats for sure...

I want the GWS's mid 1st Rnd Compensatory Pick??? but for who? Who have We available, they would want from Us? maybe 2 players? Jamar +? I can't find anyone we can afford, that would help win us the mid 1st Rnd Compo' pick.

[Bombay Airconditioning 5,875]

I know SOS is pretty dumb, but why would he trade the no 1. pick for Buddy when he can get him for nothing via Free Agency?

The Hawks should get compensation in the same way that other clubs have, and ~pick 20 is what that means. We got basically SFA for Rivers and Moloney.

Exactly, if Buddy goes its large because off the AFL's money, that seems to be the major difference between the two offers. Regardless of free agency status , pick 1 should be heading to the hawks.

[Lord Travis 10,158]

why would he trade the no 1. pick for Buddy when he can get him for nothing via Free Agency?

The Hawks should get compensation in the same way that other clubs have, and ~pick 20 is what that means. We got basically SFA for Rivers and Moloney.

Agreed. I don't understand why they'd trade Pick 1 for him either? Why not get him for free via Free Agency and use pick 1 to trade further?

[Redleg 37,555]

Agreed. I don't understand why they'd trade Pick 1 for him either? Why not get him for free via Free Agency and use pick 1 to trade further?

Exactly what they will do. It is Buddy trying to make the Hawks fans not hate him.

GWS will not fall for it. They will say $12 million, take it or leave it, but no strings attached.

[Moonshadow 16,157]

Agreed. I don't understand why they'd trade Pick 1 for him either? Why not get him for free via Free Agency and use pick 1 to trade further?

I was under the impression that the hawks would have to match GWSs RFA offer to Buddy (assuming there will be an offer) and then trade him once he was recontracted to them. Is that right? Doesn't that kinda manipulate the purpose of the FA system and dilute its integrity? It's not far off draft tampering, I'd have thought. Or will Buddy re-sign for the hawks before the draft period, then be traded to GWS. I smell a rat.

[Swampfox 190]

GWS have already got a list manager who is only there because of his deeds as a footballer even if they were overated

Not the sharpest tool in the shed is SOS

Have GWS ever considered that Boyd will be better than what they have and Buddy ?

With Sheedy involved i think they are just testing the waters and see what bites

One wonders who Melbourne could offer for Pick 1

Frawley ? maybe McDonald

[Redleg 37,555]

I was under the impression that the hawks would have to match GWSs RFA offer to Buddy (assuming there will be an offer) and then trade him once he was recontracted to them. Is that right? Doesn't that kinda manipulate the purpose of the FA system and dilute its integrity? It's not far off draft tampering, I'd have thought. Or will Buddy re-sign for the hawks before the draft period, then be traded to GWS. I smell a rat.

I think there is a rule about clearing a newly contracted player.

The Hawks will not match a $12 million offer. They can't and everyone knows it.

[Whispering_Jack 27,959]

My mail is that GWS despatched their # 1 recruiter to secure Buddy and that he's been giving him some heavy treatment.

[pilgrim 120]

I would love so very much for Buddy to just flat out turn them down.

[s-t-i-n-g-a 439]

I still don't understand why GWS would part with pick 1 for him when they can get him for free as a free agent. What is in it for them?

[CBDees 3,162]

I still don't understand why GWS would part with pick 1 for him when they can get him for free as a free agent. What is in it for them?

The last chance for them to win a Coleman (before Hogan hits his straps)!

[bluey 889]

My mail is that GWS despatched their # 1 recruiter to secure Buddy and that he's been giving him some heavy treatment.

Bet GWS store their recruiting data on a pie chart.

[Ron Burgundy 8,584]

I still don't understand why GWS would part with pick 1 for him when they can get him for free as a free agent. What is in it for them?

Certainty.

[praha 10,270]

I still don't understand why GWS would part with pick 1 for him when they can get him for free as a free agent. What is in it for them?

I'd imagine any pick involved in the transfer would be a cushion to lighten the blow of anti-expansion club sentiment that will surely follow

Franklin AND 1st-round pick?

Only an expansion club could afford to do that. And the Hawks should be able to get a pick. GWS has a distinctive advantage in its first few years because it has the flexibility to pay so much, something an equally poor-performing, established club like Melbourne couldn't fit within the cap. If GWS had been around for 10 years, it wouldn't have this money to throw at Franklin.

[TheoX 1,218]

I'd imagine any pick involved in the transfer would be a cushion to lighten the blow of anti-expansion club sentiment that will surely follow

Franklin AND 1st-round pick?

Only an expansion club could afford to do that. And the Hawks should be able to get a pick. GWS has a distinctive advantage in its first few years because it has the flexibility to pay so much, something an equally poor-performing, established club like Melbourne couldn't fit within the cap. If GWS had been around for 10 years, it wouldn't have this money to throw at Franklin.

I think it would be only Hawks fans against him leaving for pick 20, I'd have a laugh, hell, they tanked to get him in the first place.