Time to call a Spade a Spade or state the Bleeding Obvious

[fired up 77]

Mark Neeld: has failed on all accounts,needs to be replaced.

Brian Royal: been there to long,take long service and retire.

Administrative Roles: Pay decent money and hire best person for job, not necessary a Melbourne person, the best available with a proven track record.

President: An high profile person that has a voice and is respected in the community,must attract attention to club, with a positive spin.

Jumper: tell the AFL to get stuffed and we are only wearing our traditional strip.

Players to leave at years end: Jamar, Frawley,Silvia,Davey. Whether by free agency or delisted.

Captaincy: take off Grimes and Trengove and let them concentrate on their game, give the job to Nathan Jones, he has all the attributes and will stand tall.

Jack Watts: give him a position prefably in forward line and set him goals and KPI he must meet each game.

Back line: players must be taught to take game on, do not play from behind all the time, keep eye on ball and stay goal side of opponent.

Recruiting: draft players with a footy brain and bodies that are ready to play,we don't have the luxury of waiting a few years. Too many times I think vertical leap, beep test and height takes preference over guys that can actually play or have the mental toughness to suceed.

Game day: if a player is not fit or is poorly out of form do not play them.

Coaching appointment: never again should Melbourne hire a fresh unproven Coach, only he best no matter what the cost.

I could go on forever,that's it for now.

[stuie 7,374]

[demon3165 2,718]

Is there anything new someone can say, sorry new thread same spiel now we can have another 10 pages of the same thing.

[praha 11,240]

Far too few Jack Watts references.

[Harrisonrules 273]

I suggest you pick one point and think it through. As an overall plan the irrelevant points cloud anything good you want to say. It's not as simple as you want it to be.

[Harrisonrules 273]

I suggest you pick one point and think it through. As an overall plan the irrelevant points cloud anything good you want to say. It's not as simple as you want it to be.

[Return to Glory 8,436]

And the bugler? Should we replace him with James Morrison?

[thaipantsman 180]

David King was right then. He's right now!

On a personal level a few apologies would be nice directed at myself and Tona? B (19)and RR very quiet.

[Norm Smith's Curse 2,602]

Lol. When you watch those foity flashbacks of the daniher and northey days and even the early bailey days we have crumbled....

[The Red Fox 216]

Coaching appointment: never again should Melbourne hire a fresh unproven Coach, only he best no matter what the cost.

I could go on forever,that's it for now.

Apart from Malthouse in 2010 I think you have to go back until 2003 (Matthews/Brisbane) to find a premiership coach who didn't start at that club fresh and unproven.

FWIW I don't disagree with you... just giving that argument some perspective.

[thaipantsman 180]

Mark Neeld: has failed on all accounts,needs to be replaced.

Brian Royal: been there to long,take long service and retire.

Administrative Roles: Pay decent money and hire best person for job, not necessary a Melbourne person, the best available with a proven track record.

President: An high profile person that has a voice and is respected in the community,must attract attention to club, with a positive spin.

Jumper: tell the AFL to get stuffed and we are only wearing our traditional strip.

Players to leave at years end: Jamar, Frawley,Silvia,Davey. Whether by free agency or delisted.

Captaincy: take off Grimes and Trengove and let them concentrate on their game, give the job to Nathan Jones, he has all the attributes and will stand tall.

Jack Watts: give him a position prefably in forward line and set him goals and KPI he must meet each game.

Back line: players must be taught to take game on, do not play from behind all the time, keep eye on ball and stay goal side of opponent.

Recruiting: draft players with a footy brain and bodies that are ready to play,we don't have the luxury of waiting a few years. Too many times I think vertical leap, beep test and height takes preference over guys that can actually play or have the mental toughness to suceed.

Game day: if a player is not fit or is poorly out of form do not play them.

Coaching appointment: never again should Melbourne hire a fresh unproven Coach, only he best no matter what the cost.

I could go on forever,that's it for now.

Sylvia? Frawley? Matey...relax a little bit

[thaipantsman 180]

President: An high profile person that has a voice and is respected in the community,must attract attention to club, with a positive spin.

How bout Johnny Farnham for Pres

[Forest Demon 4,681]

So since James Frawley is under contract and not available for FA, are you suggesting we give him some sort of pay out and delist him. If Frawley leaves, and I don't want him too, it has to be for very decent compensation.

[Bring-Back-Powell 14,817]

I honestly stopped reading after the jumper point.

Who gives a rats clacker what jumper we wear.

I think some people see a correlation between our horrible form and the white clash strip.

[Cards13 9,117]

What?! Where are the beards and blazers?!

[Bring-Back-Powell 14,817]

If Frawley wants to leave this year, I'd only accept a top 10 draft pick for him. We simply cannot afford to let a valuable full back go for nothing. And he can go and get stuffed if he's going to hold the club for ransom.

And at the end of next year, we simply match the highest offer under free agency. Sick of quality players leaving the joint.

[pitmaster 3,549]

I honestly stopped reading after the jumper point.

Who gives a rats clacker what jumper we wear.

I think some people see a correlation between our horrible form and the white clash strip.

Very generous of you BBP to credit this thread with that much thought.

[Dee Dee 1,108]

And the bugler? Should we replace him with James Morrison?

He plays a trumpet NOT a bugle - big difference.

A reincarnated Miles Davis would boost crowd numbers!

[Craig Drinker 179]

And the bugler? Should we replace him with James Morrison?

If only Miles Davis was still alive today! You wouldn't care about the scoreline, just keep him playing!

[Craig Drinker 179]

I

He plays a trumpet NOT a bugle - big difference.
A reincarnated Miles Davis would boost crowd numbers!

I should have read further down the page. Great minds......

[Dee Dee 1,108]

Who gives a rats clacker what jumper we wear.

I do and with a passion! Red and blue, nothing else!

[Johnny Karate 559]

David King was right then. He's right now!

On a personal level a few apologies would be nice directed at myself and Tona? B (19)and RR very quiet.

No. Neeld needs to go for a multitude of reasons now but it was completely stupid to call for a first year coach's head 6 games into his contract - some peanuts may claim some sort of divine foresight now but most of them wanted MN sacked because it didnt look likely he would win a flag in 2012.

President: An high profile person that has a voice and is respected in the community,must attract attention to club, with a positive spin.

How bout Johnny Farnham for Pres

An infinitely more sensible option than Kevin Sheedy as CEO.