2013 Minor Premiership Positions

[Guest Deemand]

I thought it would be not only interesting to see where our one eyed supporters rate our beloved Demons but also the rest of the competition.

I'll kick if off.

1) Hawks

2) Swans

3) Eagles

4) Dockers

5) Pies

6) Tigers

7) Cats

8) Blues

-----------------------

9) Bombers

10) Kangaroos

11) Crows

12) Lions

13) Demons

14) Saints

15) Power

16) Suns

17) Bulldogs

18) Giants

Team to Slide; Adelaide Crows

Team to Rise: Richmond Tigers

[Damo 3,355]

1) Pies

2) Hawks

3) Swans

4) Dockers

5) Eagles

6) Crows

7) Cats

8) Tigers

-----------------------

9) Blues

10) Lions

11) Bombers

12) Saints

13) Demons

14) Kangaroos

15) Power

16) Bulldogs

17) Suns

18) Giants

[old dee 23,788]

I think you are fairly close Deemand with your position for the Dees.

Don't agree with Adelaide out and Tigers in

Interesting to look at this on September 1st.

[rjay 24,919]

I think there will be a lot of anxiety at Tigerland this year, there seems to be a belief that they will take the next step. Can't see it myself, they are getting ahead of themselves again. Apart from that who knows, I wouldn't make a prediction on us until I see the new group on the field, to many changes. Feels good at the moment though.

[DemonWA 3,934]

Hawks

Eagles

Swans

Pies

Blues

Dockers

Tigers

Cats

-----------------------

Crows

Bombers

Lions

Kangaroos

Saints

Bulldogs

Suns

Demons

Giants

Power

[Grandson of a gun 276]

FWIW I reckon the 9-13 range.

But.....

Did you get permission from Range Rover to start this poll?

[Josh 1,420]

Pies

Swans

Bombers

Hawks

Eagles

Freo

Geelong

Blues

Richmond

Adelaide

North

Melbourne

Brisbane

Gold Coast

St Kilda

Footscray

Port

GWS

Adelaide for a slide for me too...

Suns to have a good year.

Essendon and Collingwood GF

Melbourne will improve as a club no more floggings but lader position won't flatter us.

Tigers won't play finals untill they find someone other than Jack to kick goals

[Pennant St Dee 13,173]

This exercise is always difficult and an absolute stab in the dark. Only throwing it out there so I can see how far off I was come September.

Pies - Still have a lot of class IMO and should be hurting from last year

Hawks - Still number 1 on their day. As above but last 2 years will really burn, If Lake stands up releases pressure on Gibson and Schoenmakers

Swans - Because they are the Swans/Bloods always there and we will say come Round 16/17 what about Sydney they are sitting in Top 4 quietly

Dockers - Ross Lyon factor although hearing rumours Mundy & Fyfe are struggling to get out on the track confirmation of this will change my opinion

Blues - 2011 had them 1 step away from being one of the Top 4, now with Malthouse's defensive mindset I see them as the climbers this year

Eagles - Nic Nat struggling extra workload on Dean Cox. Lecras back is a bonus although they are heavily reliant on old heads of Glass & Kerr

Crows - Still Solid, Tippet gone but he was not a big factor, the draw of 2012 was easy but midfield is still classy with Thompson, Sloan & Dangerfield, Walker stepped up in 2012.

Tigers - Still not sold on them but split between them and the ageing Cats, history tells me two changes to the 8 at least most years so go Tigers

-----------------------

Cats - Ageing list will win plenty of games at Kardinia and show glimpses of their past, but Rivers is not Scarlett and the older heads showed signs last year the end is near

North - Will show glimpses of form but I only see them as an average side at best and for me will always be around 7th to 12th. Tougher draw this year

Dees - Expect improvement and a harder edge and may be biaised putting us above Lions & Bombers

Lions - Have rebuilt well since trying to recruit older players to fill holes. Like their coach will be hard to beat and will win their fair share of games

Bombers - The honeymoon is over blow torch to be turned on the golden child with Thomo to take over in 2014

Saints - Just think the time has come for a clean out and they were up for a long time

Power - They have some talent and will provide nuisance value but IMO a fair way off

Suns - I seen them take a few strides forward in the second half of the season and will snare some surprise wins but like Port still a way off

Dogs - Finished the second half of last season terribly and look to be heading were we were in 2007

Giants - Second year will be tougher for them and whilst they have some grunt in the players they targetted the opposition know a bit more about them now

Edited January 22, 2013 by Pennant St Dee

[whatwhat say what 22,746]

Hawks

Swans

Cats

Dockers

Eagles

Pies

Bombers

Crows

-------------

Lions

Tigers

Kangaroos

Blues

Saints

Power

Demons

Suns

Dogs

Giants

[GrandOld 367]

Demons

Demons

Demons

Demons

Demons

Demons

Demons

Demons

--------------

Demons

Demons

Demons

Demons

Demons

Demons

Demons

Demons

Demons

GWS

[hardtack 10,537]

1) Eagles

2) Cats

3) Hawks

4) Swans

5) Pies

6) Blues

7) Crows

8) Dockers

-----------------------

9) Tigers

10) Demons

11) Saints

12) Kangaroos

13) Bombers

14) Lions

15) Bulldogs

16) Suns

17) Power

18) Giants

[Moonshadow 17,676]

Speaking of polls, I just noticed that Rangey is now a member of 'Ology and has requested they put in a poll function! Good work Rangey.

[daisycutter 29,613]

I just hope

Carlton miss top 4

Essendon miss finals

West Coast miss top 4

Richmond finish 9th

Collingwood don't win the flag

and the dees finish 12 or higher

[Tatu 416]

1. Hawthorne

2. Fremantle

3. West Coast

4. Sydney

5. Essendon

6. Richmond

7. Collingwood

8. North Melbourne

9. Adelaide

10. Geelong

11. Brisbane

12. Carlton

13. Melbourne

14. Gold Coast

15. Footscray

16. St kilda

17. Port Adelaide

18. Western Sydney

[Gippsland Dee 367]

1st - Hawks

2nd - Pies

3rd - Freo

4th - Swans

5th - Eagles

6th - Blues

7th - Essendon

8th - Crows

-----------------

9th - Kangaroos

10th - Cats

11th - Richmond

12th - Brisbane

13th - Melbourne

14th - St kilda

15th - bulldogs

16th - GCS

17th - Port

18th - GWS

obviously i really wanted to put melbourne higher than i did, but as much as i think we will improve next season i don't think it will be enough to leap frog a lot of teams around us next year as a few are also on the up. If we can win the majority of the close games next year then we should move up 1 possibly 2 spots, either way we should easily be a better and more competitive team this season.

Edited January 22, 2013 by young dee enthusiast

[gOLLy 401]

1. Freo

2. Hawks

3. Syd

4. West Coast

5. Cats

6. Blues

7. Melbourne

8. North

9. Filth

10. Richmond

11. Adelaide

12. Bears

13. Gold Coast

14. Essendon

15. Port

16. Dogs

17. Saints

18. West Sydney

[binman 42,912]

I could care less about other sides. But for the dees i'm going out on a limb here. Melbourne are currently $10 to make the 8. Great value i reckon and well worth a nibble. We play GWS, PA, GC and the bullies all twice. It possible we could get say 7 wins from those games. We also play 15 games at the G which is huge for us. 12 games might get us in.

With our draw i believe $10 is overs and as such is value. The true odds in my opinion is about $8.

[Good Times Grimes 2,396]

1) Hawthorn

2) Sydney

3) Collingwood

4) West Coast

5) Fremantle

6) Adelaide

7) North Melbourne

8) Geelong

-------------------

9) Richmond

10) Carlton

11) Essendon

12) Melbourne

13) Brisbane

14) St. Kilda

15) Gold Coast

16) Western Bulldogs

17) Greater Western Sydney

18) Port Adelaide

[jackaub 1,402]

1) Eagles

2)Crows

3)Swans

4)Pies

5)Hawks

6)Dockers

7)Essendon

8)Cats

Melbourne 12th

Tigers 9TH again

[CBDees 3,167]

1. Freo
2. Sydney
3. Geelong
4. West Coast
5. Adelaide
6. Hawthorn
7. North Melbourne
8. Melbourne
9. Carlton
10. Collingwood
11. Richmond
12. Brisbane
13. Essendon
14. St Kilda
15. Bulldogs
16. Port Adelaide
17. Gold Coast
18. GWS

Collingwood, Essendon and Carlton to finish out of the top 8, Hawthorn to slide (Main rationale is because I hate them all!)

Melbourne to make the eight (because I predict this every year), Freo to improve.

[Jonesbag 487]

Sydney

West Coast

Fremantle

Hawthorn

Collingwood

Geelong

Essendonn

Richmond

Carlton

Brisbane

Melbourne

North

GC

Adelaide

Saints

Port

Gws

Bulldogs

Edited January 22, 2013 by Jonesbag

[ThreeOneSix 954]

1. Collingwood.

2. West Coast.

3. Hawthorn.

4. Sydney.

5. Geelong.

6. Essendon.

7. Carlton.

8. Adelaide.

I have Melbourne at 10.

[GawnWithTheWind 604]

Hawks

WCE

Sydney

Geelong

Crows

Blues

Pies

Fremantle

Tigers

Bombers

Melbourne

North

St Kilda

Dogs

GC

Port

GWS

[CBDees 3,167]

I cannot beleive that every single person has put Collingwood high up in the top eight. Back in my day, no self-respecting Demon supporter would dream of admitting to predicting that!

[Ted Lasso 19,513]

1.Hawthorn

2.West coast

3.Collingwood

4.Sydney

5.Fremantle

6.Geelong

7.Carlton

8.Richmond

9. Adelaide

10.North Melbourne

11.Essendon

12. Melbourne

13. Brisbane

14.Stkilda

15.Gold coast

16.Port adelaide

17. Western Bulldogs

18.GWS

can't see there being a huge gap in wins from about 7-15 wouldn't be surprised to see MFC's draw being enough to have people feeling they might be a chance at sneaking into the 8 for the first half of the year then perhaps falling away in the second half through just being a young team and tiring abit, hoping for some good signs though!