What would it take?

[mrtwister 652]

I read on Demonland somewhere (sorry cannot remember where) that Carlton mentioned Watts in a hypothetical with MFC and we said he is absolutely untouchable. It did however get me wondering as to what my Demonland brethren would be willing to trade him for.

btw I am expecting responses ranging from the HF line of the All Australian team to a new bugle for the bugle boy but what the hey.

[spirit of norm smith 16,450]

In the words of Star Wars from Obi Wan Kenobi ..." you were the chosen one".

Jack Watts was our messiah. A key fwd with the blone movie star looks. We imagined a Nick Riewoldt type with class, and kicking goals as a premier forward. Jack is now a drifting half back, pushed aside in a contest by Swan, Petrenko and Deledio in one on ones.

Jack has that word POTENTIAL so if we get for a 1st round draft pick, say 12-18 pick would be sufficient.

[Beetle 4,655]

Patrick Dangerfield and our pick 13 (if we had it)

to Adelaide.

[brey9186 102]

From Carlton? Chris yarren

[Grimseyisgod 378]

From Carlton? Chris yarren

Firstly that's not funny, Yarran is crap.

Watts is a gun... he played some real Goddard like football this year.

Would not want to trade him!

I would honestly trade pick 4 and Watts for Cotchin.. thats it

[Range Rover 1,935]

Firstly that's not funny, Yarran is crap.

Watts is a gun... he played some real Goddard like football this year.

Would not want to trade him!

I would honestly trade pick 4 and Watts for Cotchin.. thats it

Yarran is very far from crap. Absolute silk coming out of the Carlton backline and probably their most talented player. I'd do that trade.

But back to the hypothetical question in the OP ... I'm on record as saying I'd trade Watts for a package Carlton's pick 11 AND Mitch Robinson.

[Johnny Karate 559]

A cold pie. It's harder & can throw its weight around.

[DeeM 42]

He will be a seriously good player, so theres not much you can offer to be honest.

Cotchin, Dangerfield thats about it

[binman 42,922]

But back to the hypothetical question in the OP ... I'm on record as saying I'd trade Watts for a package Carlton's pick 11 AND Mitch Robinson.

This must be an example of a Lance Armstrong suspension.

[Jordie_tackles 354]

Yarran is very far from crap. Absolute silk coming out of the Carlton backline and probably their most talented player. I'd do that trade.

But back to the hypothetical question in the OP ... I'm on record as saying I'd trade Watts for a package Carlton's pick 11 AND Mitch Robinson.

So over rated

Only thing i would consider from carlton would be Murphy and even then i would have to think long and hard.

Edited October 12, 2012 by Jordie_tackles

[rjay 24,919]

Yarran is very far from crap. Absolute silk coming out of the Carlton backline and probably their most talented player. I'd do that trade.

But back to the hypothetical question in the OP ... I'm on record as saying I'd trade Watts for a package Carlton's pick 11 AND Mitch Robinson.

So we trade our most talented player for theirs?

Mitch "choose the contest" Robinson, you have to be joking.

[Demon Forever 219]

Worst thread ever. Period!

[Range Rover 1,935]

So we trade our most talented player for theirs?

Mitch "choose the contest" Robinson, you have to be joking.

What part of "AND pick 11" didn't you understand?

Robinson is as tough as they come and while not A-grade, is a definite step for us and would walk straight into our side. Who are you kidding?

[Mad_Melbourne 877]

Robinson is as tough as they come and while not A-grade, is a definite step for us and would walk straight into our side. Who are you kidding?

Currently I agree, but not sure for how long, J.Viney, N. Jones, J. Grimes, J. Mckenzie and even J. trengove, I could see him slowly being pushed out of our midfield! Optimism, or a few beers, either way I am starting to like the look of our list.

Having said that watts is going to be a star, and is easily our best user of the ball, so give me Murphy from Carlton and they can have watts. Other than that no dice.

Watts is going to be a gun, no matter where he plays, we have no doubt a 200-250 gamer no worries

[Range Rover 1,935]

Currently I agree, but not sure for how long, J.Viney, N. Jones, J. Grimes, J. Mckenzie and even J. trengove, I could see him slowly being pushed out of our midfield! Optimism, or a few beers, either way I am starting to like the look of our list.

Having said that watts is going to be a star, and is easily our best user of the ball, so give me Murphy from Carlton and they can have watts. Other than that no dice.

Watts is going to be a gun, no matter where he plays, we have no doubt a 200-250 gamer no worries

I just don't see the justification for the words 'gun' and 'star' for Watts given what he's dished up so far. You're seeing something I'm not MM.

[Mad_Melbourne 877]

I just don't see the justification for the words 'gun' and 'star' for Watts given what he's dished up so far. You're seeing something I'm not MM.

Hard to see how you couldn't see the potential in him this year, and I think he definitely benefited from the stint in the back line. I could probably slot potential in front of gun or star but I'm just going all out haha! I guess we just see different things, considering he is a fourth year key position player, his progress has been on the up, I see big things for him and I definitely see him having great potential. Like I said I can see him being a 200-250 gamer no worries, all Australian and if I'm really hopeful a premiership player

[cowboy_from_hell 2,390]

Watts is one of the only players we have who can kick the footy. I know he is no pack marking machine who eats metal and drinks diesel but he is our version of Matt suckling

[Hannibal 5,814]

Watts is one of the only players we have who can kick the footy. I know he is no pack marking machine who eats metal and drinks diesel but he is our version of Matt suckling

Suckling was a rookie and Watts was a pick one investment, which is the footballing tragedy.

The rose coloured glasses that many supporters use to view Watts is one of life's great mysteries. We all know he has talent and skill, but some us also know that he has no appetite for finals type contested footy.

[daisycutter 29,613]

who's the happy-looking kid on the left of the photo?

[Biffen 12,943]

who's the happy-looking kid on the left of the photo?

Thats some guy who was Max Gawns Dietary assistant at the club .

He has left us for a role as Chinese Ambassador for Rooty Hill.

Edited October 13, 2012 by Biffen

[dee-luded 2,959]

I read on Demonland somewhere (sorry cannot remember where) that Carlton mentioned Watts in a hypothetical with MFC and we said he is absolutely untouchable. It did however get me wondering as to what my Demonland brethren would be willing to trade him for.

btw I am expecting responses ranging from the HF line of the All Australian team to a new bugle for the bugle boy but what the hey.

Two 1st Rnd Picks for next year, one a top 10 pick, & the other top 20.

[daisycutter 29,613]

Thats some guy who was Max Gawns Dietary assistant at the club .

He has left us for a role as Chinese Ambassador for Rooty Hill.

Thanks Biffo. I thought it might be the club's social director. He looked so happy

[Jaded No More 68,914]

If Mitch Robinson ever stepped foot inside the MFC, I would vomit and immidiately stop supporting us.

Biggest. [censored]. Ever!

[cat attack 26]

I just don't see the justification for the words 'gun' and 'star' for Watts given what he's dished up so far. You're seeing something I'm not MM.

I'm not seeing the word sensible or credible for Range Rover for the crap he has dished up thus far

[rjay 24,919]

What part of "AND pick 11" didn't you understand?

Robinson is as tough as they come and while not A-grade, is a definite step for us and would walk straight into our side. Who are you kidding?

Robinson would get a game for us agreed, but the tough hard at it reputation he has is not always the case. He does pick and choose in a marking contest, he's not Jonathan Brown or big Mitch who probably for their own and everyone else's safety should back off at times.

I re read it by the way and you were talking about Yarran as a swap not Yarran and pick 11, so my point stands, their classiest player for ours. I certainly wouldn't put Robinson in that field.