WELCOME TO THE MELBOURNE FOOTBALL CLUB - CHRIS DAWES

[Deez 298]

If need thinks dawes is our best bang for buck, then sure.

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

The good thing is that becuase we didn't get him last year we were able to get Clark, potentially we could then have both players.

Edited October 2, 2012 by Clint Bizkit

[Deez 298]

Also, i think if eddy can have any effect on how his players trades work out, then he will try to avoid us from benefiting.

[RalphiusMaximus 6,049]

I just don't rate the guy. Yes he fits in the age bracket we like, but he's not overly large by today's standards, he isn't mobile and his record is mediocre at best. I much prefer the mooted Butcher trade or making a move on Gumbleton (I'm sure I've mentioned this before).

[Deez 298]

I just don't rate the guy. Yes he fits in the age bracket we like, but he's not overly large by today's standards, he isn't mobile and his record is mediocre at best. I much prefer the mooted Butcher trade or making a move on Gumbleton (I'm sure I've mentioned this before).

Butcher is certainly a better prospect, much more exciting.

[45HG 1,539]

I'd take Dawes over any of the previous names I've heard mentioned (i.e. the likes of Rodan, Byrnes, Knights etc.).

Would be a good get, perfect for what we're trying to create up forward.

Completely disagree that Martin is a better player.

[pitmaster 3,549]

THIS FROM KDA

But Cloke at least had some talent to begin with, he was always going to come good at some stage.

Dawes on the other hand, different story for the big lumbering spud.

• 
  

I get the feeling that any argument will not change your mind about Dawes so I won't pursue one.

Have a nice day.

Maybe this will change KingDingAling's mind and as much as I hate to pander to a stereotype Dawes does have Brighton Grammar/Sandringham in his pedigree...sounds like a natural for us.

Edited October 2, 2012 by pitmaster

[45HG 1,539]

Unbelievable hatred towards Dawes on this thread, and simultaneous unfounded comparisons with Martin, where Martin comes out on top.

There simply isn't any basis for claiming Martin is better than Dawes. I'm sorry to all Martin fans, but he's achieved very, very little in his career so far, and Dawes has done more.

If the price is right, he should definitely be on our radar, as he'll help Clark immensely and that helps the team.

Spot on.

[Toorak 108]

The one bright light of the year was watching Dawes stuff up for The pies.

I watched most of the games Dawes played in and I was astounded how poor he was, just not up to AFL standard.

I can't think of a worse player currently playing in the AFL.

[H_T 3,043]

I would have thought Dawes would be a required player at Collingwood. The feeding frenzy on availability of Tippett which Collingwood has denied interest in, is no doubt related. I doubt very much they'd say goodbye to Dawes (re-signed him last year)now that they have Lynch. Three talls.

[Its Miller time 6]

Richmond delisted Miller this year, also supposedly an elite trainer would rather get him back than give up more than a 4th rounder for Dawes.

[DemonWA 3,934]

A year is a long time isn't it?

Last year lots wanted us to sign him up, or used his late development / on field results in 2011 to support the 'jack watts is going to be good' theory.

A year later he's a spud?!

Fwiw I do agree that he's a spud, but it's just funny how quickly he's gone from flavor of the month to a whipping boy.

[Demon_spurs 1,852]

I watched Dawes in the first final and was surprised by his agility and attack on the ball, I think he might be OK, would certainly never get the best backman if Clark plays so worth a shot, I had a lot of time for Stef but in the cool clear light, maybe he's not that good

[Guest KingDingAling]

I watched Dawes in the first final and was surprised by his agility and attack on the ball, I think he might be OK, would certainly never get the best backman if Clark plays so worth a shot, I had a lot of time for Stef but in the cool clear light, maybe he's not that good

He never got the best backman this year and barely got a kick.

As mentioned earlier Butcher and even Gumby would be far better options, especially Butcher.

[bing181 9,220]

Neeld and Brown would have detailed knowledge of Dawes's strengths and weaknesses, and what he can bring to the club. If they sign off on it, good enough for me.

[Toorak 108]

Why not bring back Nathan Carroll? It would make as much sense!

[bing181 9,220]

As mentioned earlier Butcher and even Gumby would be far better options, especially Butcher.

Butcher is completely untried on the big stage, comes from a club which is travelling as badly as we are (worse?), and is injury prone. Not saying he's not worth looking at, but you wouldn't have thought he'd be the first considered if we're trying to turn the ship around.

[beelzebub 23,364]

Neeld and Brown would have detailed knowledge of Dawes's strengths and weaknesses, and what he can bring to the club. If they sign off on it, good enough for me.

Im not sufficiently in any one camp or the other, but I agree.

if they see something.. Ill back them ( for now )

[Rocknroll 1,003]

Maybe the see a great step ladder for Howe! Pretty solid launching pad

Edited October 2, 2012 by Rocknroll

[ILLDieADemon 804]

Two words GET HIM

[Akum 2,660]

A year is a long time isn't it?

Last year lots wanted us to sign him up, or used his late development / on field results in 2011 to support the 'jack watts is going to be good' theory.

A year later he's a spud?!

Fwiw I do agree that he's a spud, but it's just funny how quickly he's gone from flavor of the month to a whipping boy.

Pies fans on BF uncertain whether Dawes or Simon Buckley is their biggest spud.

Let's get him!

[Dee Fan 3,247]

I'm not sure about Dawes I didn't want him when we talked about him last time and I'm not sure if I want him now.

I've seen him play some ordinary football this year but from time to time I've seen him do something good which indicates he can play. He's got a few goals by being left by himself in the goal square where the ball has fallen in to his hands and I'm not sure if that's luck or smart play. Sometimes he looks as if he's been given a rocket and he really puts in other times he looks as if he's coasting.

[45HG 1,539]

I'm not sure about Dawes I didn't want him when we talked about him last time and I'm not sure if I want him now.

I've seen him play some ordinary football this year but from time to time I've seen him do something good which indicates he can play. He's got a few goals by being left by himself in the goal square where the ball has fallen in to his hands and I'm not sure if that's luck or smart play. Sometimes he looks as if he's been given a rocket and he really puts in other times he looks as if he's coasting.

I'm not convinced he has very good self belief. In the right environment I think he could flourish very well.

[Philthy 284]

It's simple!!! We offer 3rd round pick for Dawes and if Collingwood say no, good luck trying to get Tippett.

[Cards13 9,117]

Dawes has a contract right?