End of year wish list

[olisik 4,060]

There seems to be a few threads going around with a lot of them turning into people giving input into what there end of year wish list is so i figure why not make a thread dedicated to it.

If as expected we finish 16th, we will end up with draft picks 3, 4, 12 and a mid 20s pick.

With those picks on hand, free agency, 17yr old draft and players to trade I wanted to see the best scenarios people could suggest for an all-round good package which is realistic and could fulfil the teams needs.

Personally I think we should go for Cloke and pay the coin for him. He is a free agent so we will not need to give Collingwood anything.

I also think Boak would fit in nicely, though due to Cloke our coin will be restricted so I will count him out (unless we can't get Cloke)

My money is that GWS and GC will not take the risk which will benefit all other teams, especially the ones with picks directly after ours. (This is a wish-list so I am being positive on this one)

After reading about the 17yr olds, I think they will be more valuable then people give credit for, remember these are the touted picks 1 and 2 of the 2013 draft, not just that but they will get an extra year of senior development before they begin playing which I think makes them more valuable then a standard pick 1 or 2. Also they say next years draft should almost be as strong as this years.

Overall my wish-list package would be

Cloke

Hogan 17 yr old - (Pick 3 traded to GWS)

Stringer (pick 4)

Wines/Simpson (Pick 12)

Viney (2nd rounder)

Edited June 27, 2012 by olisik

[Wadda We Sing 10,685]

Remind me again who our Free Agents are, and whom we may be in danger of losing?

[Good Times Grimes 2,396]

Remind me again who our Free Agents are, and whom we may be in danger of losing?

Not many free agents that are critical pieces of our team. Bate, Dunn, Green, Moloney and Rivers.

Other out of contract players are: (I'm not 100% sure if this is accurate, but it seems right)

Bail, Bartram, Bennell, Blease, Cook, Davis, Garland, Howe, Jetta, Jones, Jurrah, McDonald, McKenzie, Petterd, Spencer, Strauss, Evans, Nicholson

Of those players, I think it is vital that we re-sign Blease, Garland, Howe, Jones, McDonald, McKenzie, Bartram, Bail, Cook and Nicholson and, pending the outcome of his case, Jurrah.

[Yossarian 1,808]

Mitch Clark good to go.

[Hells Gates 505]

There seems to be a few threads going around with a lot of them turning into people giving input into what there end of year wish list is so i figure why not make a thread dedicated to it.

If as expected we finish 16th, we will end up with draft picks 3, 4, 12 and a mid 20s pick.

With those picks on hand, free agency, 17yr old draft and players to trade I wanted to see the best scenarios people could suggest for an all-round good package which is realistic and could fulfil the teams needs.

Personally I think we should go for Cloke and pay the coin for him. He is a free agent so we will not need to give Collingwood anything.

I also think Boak would fit in nicely, though due to Cloke our coin will be restricted so I will count him out (unless we can't get Cloke)

My money is that GWS and GC will not take the risk which will benefit all other teams, especially the ones with picks directly after ours. (This is a wish-list so I am being positive on this one)

After reading about the 17yr olds, I think they will be more valuable then people give credit for, remember these are the touted picks 1 and 2 of the 2013 draft, not just that but they will get an extra year of senior development before they begin playing which I think makes them more valuable then a standard pick 1 or 2. Also they say next years draft should almost be as strong as this years.

Overall my wish-list package would be

Cloke

Hogan 17 yr old - (Pick 3 traded to GWS)

Stringer (pick 4)

Wines/Simpson (Pick 12)

Viney (2nd rounder)

Even if we got those players without Cloke I'd be very happy.

[Ron Burgundy 8,584]

Viney for a second round pick would be great.

I trust the new regime on which kids to recruit, but getting another very established elite player is needed IMO.

My "Wish List" is:

- (draft period) Cloke, Boak (one of the compo picks), Viney (2nd round pick), a couple of really good future young midfield stars with our other 1st round picks, some Magner types with our rookie picks, and a mature age quick small forward who's coming off a good season in the VFL (or has been delisted by another AFL club) with a lower end national draft pick.

- (injury list) everyone fit and raring to go, especially Mitch Clark.

- (re-signing) the signing of all of the current players we need to keep asap - see Good Times Grimes post above for those players.

- (coaching) Junior McDonald to rejoin the club in the off season as a new assistant coach, and the club to extend Neeld's contract for another year as a further vote of confidence in him.

[old dee 22,807]

Viney for a second round pick would be great.

I trust the new regime on which kids to recruit, but getting another very established elite player is needed IMO.

My "Wish List" is:

- (draft period) Cloke, Boak (one of the compo picks), Viney (2nd round pick), a couple of really good future young midfield stars with our other 1st round picks, some Magner types with our rookie picks, and a mature age quick small forward who's coming off a good season in the VFL (or has been delisted by another AFL club) with a lower end national draft pick.

- (injury list) everyone fit and raring to go, especially Mitch Clark.

- (re-signing) the signing of all of the current players we need to keep asap - see Good Times Grimes post above for those players.

- (coaching) Junior McDonald to rejoin the club in the off season as a new assistant coach, and the club to extend Neeld's contract for another year as a further vote of confidence in him.

No RB we made that mistake with DB.

I have no idea if Neeld is a good coach or not.

Lets not back ourselves into a corner lets at least wait till the start of 2014.

Why rush this decision?

[Fork 'em 6,506]

Get Clarkes foot right.

Hit jackpot in the draft.

[DEELIRIOUS 156]

Viney for a second round pick would be great.

I trust the new regime on which kids to recruit, but getting another very established elite player is needed IMO.

My "Wish List" is:

- (draft period) ..... a mature age quick small forward who's coming off a good season in the VFL (or has been delisted by another AFL club) with a lower end national draft pick.

He goes by the name of Adam Cockie!

[BIG JIM 508]

Pick 3 Toumpas

Pick 4 Stringer

Pick 13 port Adelaide Boak to MFC

Pick 23 SOG Jack viney

This is how i see it playing out with GWS just not willing to risk the viney bid.

Cloke will end up at the bulldogs.

[DemonWA 3,426]

Mitch Clark ready to go a the start of preseason

Liam Jurrah fit and charges against him thrown out

Pick up a good player from another club (think Boak, Wellingham, Goldsack etc)

Honour our commitment to Jack Viney and take him with pick 3 if requried

[Dee*ceiving 860]

Dayne Beams is the one to go after for mine. Cloke won't leave Collingwood, they know their premiership window will essentially close if he walks as such they'll give him what he wants to stay. That will likely lead to squeezing out 1 or 2 of Beams, Wellingham, Goldsack & OBrien. Of that lot Beams is the most enticing. Even more so than Boak for mine.

[mauriesy 6,783]

I want Mitch Clark to get back to playing and leading the forward line.

I want the beginning of a core of 8-10 "A" and "B" Grade midfielders who can take it up to the juggernauts of the AFL. That would mean:

• Jones keeping on keeping on
  
• Trengove getting better
  
• Grimes building his midfield role
  
• Gysberts playing AFL consistently
  
• Howe working as a midfielder
  
• Midfielder X (the one we trade for, like Boak or Beams or whoever)
  
• Viney as a recruit
  
• Draft pick #4 (as good as Viney)
  
• Maybe any others in the mix: Blease, Nicholson, Magner, Sylvia, Tynan, Taggert, Couch etc.
  

That is all.

[olisik 4,060]

I would take Wellingham over Boak or Beams to be honest. He would be slightly cheaper and I think he offers a different dimension or style of play to what our crop currently have.

Would mix it up a bit more I think

[Red N Blue Society 165]

Viney listed

Get pick 3 & 4.

MItch Clarke fit

Recruit a star from left field for the Mid field!

Unsure about Boak..Would be handy but not for big coin..

Dodge Cloke & his identicle $erial money hungry club switching old man..

[satyricon 267]

Posters on this board to actually form their own opinions and not parrot from commentators/opinion makers/Grant Thomas

Mitch Clark be ready for preseason

Nev Jetta and Max Gawn to avoid another injury

Col Sylvia to get through the pre season without finding yet another new way to hurt himself

The Club drafting who Neeld wants

[old dee 22,807]

Posters on this board to actually form their own opinions and not parrot from commentators/opinion makers/Grant Thomas

Mitch Clark be ready for preseason

Nev Jetta and Max Gawn to avoid another injury

Col Sylvia to get through the pre season without finding yet another new way to hurt himself

The Club drafting who Neeld wants

That one is a certainity

[rhaz 342]

Don't care what picks we get, just get them right. No more Morton's.

I want more wins before years end.

Edited June 28, 2012 by rhaz

[dpositive 1,547]

Don't care what picks we get, just get them right. No more Morton's.

I want more wins before years end.

Been waiting for the appearance of the Morton

The Sam Stosur of MFC

would be happy if he developed into a useful part of the Melbourne jugernaut now that we have tasted a win

some of us know he can only improve

[Dr. Mubutu 692]

Wish list?

3 'Melbourne supporters' signed with the club they apparently supported growing up:

C. Judd

S. Pendlebury

L. Franklin

Not asking too much, surely?

[Hells Gates 505]

Pick 3 Toumpas

Pick 4 Stringer

Pick 13 port Adelaide Boak to MFC

Pick 23 SOG Jack viney

This is how i see it playing out with GWS just not willing to risk the viney bid.

Cloke will end up at the bulldogs.

Nice work. I'd have maybe Wines over Toumpas.

[Bay Riffin 1,413]

recruitment of players who have strong bodies. not just to win contested footy, but so they don't get injured as often.

given last years draft was influenced by Neeld, i am positive that this will happen.

[BIG JIM 508]

Nice work. I'd have maybe Wines over Toumpas.

I dont know to much about Wines what type of player is he?

My North Melbourne mate has been going on about this kid.

Must be a nice player because i have heard alot of good things about toumpas.

We seem to be building a bit of a South Australian team. Trengove,Tapscott and now maybe Toumpas.

Can you tell me a bit about the kid Wines?

Cheers

Edited June 28, 2012 by BIG JIM

[olisik 4,060]

any chance of wines slipping to our mid first rounder?

[Hells Gates 505]

I dont know to much about Wines what type of player is he?

My North Melbourne mate has been going on about this kid.

Must be a nice player because i have heard alot of good things about toumpas.

We seem to be building a bit of a South Australian team. Trengove,Tapscott and now maybe Toumpas.

Can you tell me a bit about the kid Wines?

Cheers

Sounds like a goer

http://www.afl.com.au/tabid/208/default.aspx?newsid=139314