My 3 word player analysis V Who Cares

[Striker475 696]

Trengove - huge captain's heart

Grimes - somehow shut out

Jones - better and better

Bartram - oh so meh

Watts - watching the contests

Bate - played for Brisbane

Frawley - rather bloody average

Clark - not too bad

Mckenzie - still can't kick

Blease - did he play?

Green - surely didn't play?

Garland - was he playing?

Moloney - not on field

Rivers - outsized but okay

Macdonald - not bad really

Martin - did some things

Davey - barely worth VFL

Howe - too many hangers

Jamar - what has happened?

Bail - back into it

Magner- THIS FREAKIN GUY

Tynan - had a crack

[dee-luded 2,959]

Trengove - never stopped trying

Grimes - was terrific early

Jones - always under pressure

Bartram - skill - less as ever

Watts - failed to impress

Bate - limited game time

Frawley - far from reliable

Clark - overpaid and underperformed

Mckenzie - selected too soon

Blease - was rarely sighted

Green - was never sighted

Garland - was he playing?

Moloney - not on field

Rivers - not the worst

Macdonald - possibly the worst

Martin - gave a little

Davey - career possibly over

Howe - spectacular , not effective

Jamar - was comprehensively destroyed

Bail - was rarely sighted

Magner- the only highlight

Trengove - top line kid

Grimes - Un der done

Jones - always under pressure

Bartram - sticks to task

Watts - meaning less possessions

Bate - limited game time

Frawley - mis matched again

Clark - hot and cold

Mckenzie - Un der done

Blease - out of depth

Green - out for sundaydrive

Garland - mis matched again

Moloney - always under pressure

Rivers - over rated - undersized

Macdonald - clumsy Al bundy

Martin - did some tricks

Davey - where were you

Howe - In Con Sistent

Jamar - out of form

Bail - lost in traffic

Magner- breath fresh air

[Norm Smith's Curse 2,602]

Our best player was a VFLer who has been overlooked for a number of years. Says it all.

[Viney Vidi Vici 148]

Some where seriously underestimate the value of some efforts and stamp the title 'awful' on a game far too easily. I was at the game, and actually enjoyed the first half when we had targets up forward, it killed me we couldn't take marks, but still, I could see what Neeld was doing. Clark was a good target, but like a couple have said, was often outnumbered, especially later in the game when Howe seemed to dissapear a bit more. Martin made a good target on the wing and took a couple of decent contested marks too. I think later in the game as the forward half became barer, as numbers went up to stop the leakage, the rot multiplied and our midfielders just didn't have it in them to get it past 3 defenders to often, a lone Clark in the 50.

point being, Don't beat on Clark, he didn't have delivery or support.

No position for Green anymore, Davey only showed flashes of something, Watts needs to relearn how to tackle, put Blease forward and tell him to lock the footy in there, and could someone please win a clearance?

[daisycutter 29,617]

Amassed quite a few hit-outs and took a few contested marks.

Not a lot, but enough to be respected by some.

did one hitout goto a teammate's advantage?

dropping the ball at your feet is ineffective and predictable

very average performance

[old dee 23,797]

Our best player was a VFLer who has been overlooked for a number of years. Says it all.

No truer statement has been made in the last 24 hours

[Pates 9,660]

Only an idiot would accuse Clark of having a bad game. I challenge anyone to try and do well when the ball is being bombed into the forward line in hope, like it was today. Delivery was shocking all day.

It's one thing to have a gameplan that is as predictable as it is boring, it's another thing to be woeful in clearances, the main element that the game plan relies on.

Couldn't agree more. Buddy would've struggled with the disgusting delivery coming in, not to mention the crowded forward 50 how the hell was he ment to get a good run and jump at it?

Not a good game, but overpaid and underperformed? Awful?

[mrtwister 652]

did one hitout goto a teammate's advantage?

dropping the ball at your feet is ineffective and predictable

very average performance

Agreed.

But I don't think he was in our worst 16.

[daisycutter 29,617]

Agreed.

But I don't think he was in our worst 16.

no maybe not worst 16 but a disappointing show nevertheless

[rpfc 28,526]

I'd be happy if Watts became a gun anything. Anything.

Our midfield is so mediocre that you'd take 5 of Collingwood's midfielders before a single 1 of ours. 5!

Swan

Pendlebury

Thomas

Ball

Beams

I don't know why this surprises you...

I would have said the same thing last week.

The best teams would have the same number of mids ahead of ours.