Narrowing in on either Grimes or Trengove for Captain

[Lutz 76]

Yeah, not sure if that will happen either. But that's your opinion.

It is.

We'll have to wait and see.

[Demonator 93]

It is.

We'll have to wait and see.

and if i knew you - id gladly have $500 on it!

[Sir Why You Little 37,034]

i say bugger successful clubs - what the hell would they know.

Best person for the gig irrespective of position

Fair call, but i don't think a defenders position is the best place. But after last year i am certainly not against the best person. All things need to be weighed up.

[Lutz 76]

I think being in backline provides you with an advantage as captain, in terms of organising your "troops" and seeing the play develop.

You can see where your attack is breaking down and/or where the opposition may be getting on top in the midfield, aiding in making real-time adjustments.

[Sir Why You Little 37,034]

I think being in backline provides you with an advantage as captain, in terms of organising your "troops" and seeing the play develop.

You can see where your attack is breaking down and/or where the opposition may be getting on top in the midfield, aiding in making real-time adjustments.

Talk to Neita about it. He found it often very frustrating because he could not always be involved.

From ground level late in the game it would be hard to see the whole ground unless you watch the scoreboard.

Points to take into account before the final decision.

[Damo 3,355]

I think thats right. If jamar hates Fiji, he doesnt deserve the captaincy.

[Lutz 76]

Talk to Neita about it. He found it often very frustrating because he could not always be involved.

From ground level late in the game it would be hard to see the whole ground unless you watch the scoreboard.

Points to take into account before the final decision.

Deep in defence is very different to deep in attack.

[DemonWA 3,934]

I think being in backline provides you with an advantage as captain, in terms of organising your "troops" and seeing the play develop.

You can see where your attack is breaking down and/or where the opposition may be getting on top in the midfield, aiding in making real-time adjustments.

fair point, but tbh i think the on field role of a captain is basically just to play well and lead by example.

An even better spot than the backline to view the play is from the coaches box, and runners make real time adjustments...

[rhaz 342]

Frawley from what i can tell... is not the sharpest tool in the shed. Great player, but off field im not sure hes right. Even his cousin Danny has said numerous times that hes got a bit of air in his noggin.

I'd rather just let him play and do the hell of a job he has been doing these parts few years.

I cant pick yet, from an outsiders view its tough. I know i want Trengove in 2013/14 but i feel he is just not quite ready yet.

[Sir Why You Little 37,034]

Deep in defence is very different to deep in attack.

Yes but that can depend on midfield pressure.

[Pates 9,660]

According to recent tweet from Clark at herald sun "Gut feel is dees race down to youngsters Trengove and Grimes. Green's days as skipper prob over. Frawley a smokey. Either way new era."

Bring it on I say!

Of those, I would go for Chip. He's a proven performer, young and goes 100% out on the field. The only thing about him is does he have the "presence" of a captain?

I don't think either of Trenners or Grimes should have the captaincy next year, JT is still a year or two off IMO and Grimes should start by just trying to get through the year. Both are guns and in a year or two will probably face off for the role, but not yet.

Edited January 12, 2012 by Pates

[Gippy Dee 48]

Would not be surprised to see JT get the nod. Is he too young ? Probably. From all reports he has shown leadership qualities from day one and looking at him onfield, he never drops the head, always chases and does the team things.

It would be a brave move and quite un-Melbourne like. If we were to be brave my feeling is that JT would not be the wrong choice to be brave about.

If Grimes wasnt so fragile ( to date) he would have been a monty.

Wayne Carey became captain of North when he was 21. There is no doubt that he grew into the role, and was one of the best captains (Excluding his sleeping with other team mates misseses) and one of the best in field.

There is no doubt that it can happen, and with such a young and inexperienced list that we have I can't see why we couldn't give JT the captaincy.

I for mine hope he gets it and remains a captain for the red and blue for the next 10 years...

Gippy

[Gippy Dee 48]

Would not be surprised to see JT get the nod. Is he too young ? Probably. From all reports he has shown leadership qualities from day one and looking at him onfield, he never drops the head, always chases and does the team things.

It would be a brave move and quite un-Melbourne like. If we were to be brave my feeling is that JT would not be the wrong choice to be brave about.

If Grimes wasnt so fragile ( to date) he would have been a monty.

Wayne Carey became captain of North when he was 21. There is no doubt that he grew into the role, and was one of the best captains (Excluding his sleeping with other team mates misseses) and one of the best in field.

There is no doubt that it can happen, and with such a young and inexperienced list that we have I can't see why we couldn't give JT the captaincy.

I for mine hope he gets it and remains a captain for the red and blue for the next 10 years...

Gippy

[darkhorse72 1,916]

Having a young captain is not new as people have mention Carey was captain at 21. Also on memory Kernahan (Spelling) from Carlton was made captain very young and lead the blues for around decade.

IF any of the young blokes can do it, like JT give it to him now. I prefer to have a long term captain than a change every few years, this is no disrespect to Green, but it should be given to the next generation.

[Bossdog 2,002]

Having a young captain is not new as people have mention Carey was captain at 21. Also on memory Kernahan (Spelling) from Carlton was made captain very young and lead the blues for around decade.

IF any of the young blokes can do it, like JT give it to him now. I prefer to have a long term captain than a change every few years, this is no disrespect to Green, but it should be given to the next generation.

Thats crap. The game is very different to when Carey was appointed captain JT is still very young and has not stamped his authority on a game yet. Let hin concentrate on being an elite footy player first. Captancy at this stage may well stiffle his growth

[Biffen 12,943]

Those who think it's Jack Grimes are dreaming .You got the first name right though .

[Sir Why You Little 37,034]

Thats crap. The game is very different to when Carey was appointed captain JT is still very young and has not stamped his authority on a game yet. Let hin concentrate on being an elite footy player first. Captancy at this stage may well stiffle his growth

That is my concern. We need JT to burn on the field this year, really burn. Would Captaincy stifle this at all?

[Guest Jackie]

Wayne Carey became captain of North when he was 21. There is no doubt that he grew into the role, and was one of the best captains (Excluding his sleeping with other team mates misseses) and one of the best in field.

There is no doubt that it can happen, and with such a young and inexperienced list that we have I can't see why we couldn't give JT the captaincy.

I for mine hope he gets it and remains a captain for the red and blue for the next 10 years...

Gippy

I totally agree. Legends are not made they make themselves.

[Guest Jackie]

That is my concern. We need JT to burn on the field this year, really burn. Would Captaincy stifle this at all?

If he is captain material then why hold him back? If he is then he will deliver. On field leadership is a cornerstone for success. Why give it to some crack filler?

Edited January 12, 2012 by Jackie

[jabberwocky 2,301]

My gut feel is Trengove will get it.

[Sir Why You Little 37,034]

If he is captain material then why hold him back? If he is then he will deliver. On field leadership is the cornerstone of success. Why give it to some crack filler?

If JT gets the ©. fine. But as long as it doesn't detract from some BOG performances this year because i think they are more important. If he can pull off both...sweet as.

[Guest Jackie]

If JT gets the ©. fine. But as long as it doesn't detract from some BOG performances this year because i think they are more important. If he can pull off both...sweet as.

If he can provide true leadership then BOG's or lack of would become irrelevant because it will likely indicate that we are a better team and winning more games.

[Biffen 12,943]

It's funny how we all view what happens on a footy field quite differently. I don't overly rate Moloney as a footballer and reckon we've been beset with his type for decades, which is one of the reasons that real success has escaped us. Like others, I feel that he's found wanting when pitted against elite midfielders, but holds his own against lesser lights. Imo, he would have hardly got a game at Geelong over the last 5 years. In other words, I don't want him to captain our club as I feel the station to be above him. For this same reason I don't want Jones.

Btw, I know people will point to his top 10 finish in the Brownlow this year as well as a win in the B&F, etc, but these accolades aren't nearly as meritorious when you're the best and one of the most most senior of a pretty ordinary lot. As mentioned, we all have differing opinions of players that represent this club.

You contradicted yourself quite a bit there .Bull would be a triple flag Cat if he stayed injury free, and a Cat .

He is pure class.

[Sir Why You Little 37,034]

If he can provide true leadership then BOG's or lack of would become irrelevant because it will likely indicate that we are a better team and winning more games.

JT BOG's will lift the team...& all of us in the stands!! If he also tosses the coin then it is a bonus...

[Biffen 12,943]

He's the Saviour ,

The light and the

resurrection .

Look out Judd .