Rejuvenated best 22 after trade and draft

[Dee1987 277]

Ok its been done a million times but i will put forward what Neelds best 22 might be:

B: Tapscott, Frawley, Garland

HB: Rivers, Martin, Grimes

C: Trengove, Moloney, Bail

HF: Green, Sellar, Sylvia

F: Howe, Clark, Jurrah

FOLL: Jamar, Bate, Jones

INTR: Davey, Petterd, Nicholson, Blease

EMRG: Gysberts, Macdonald, Mckenzie.

I know ppl will be saying why Bate. i believe we will see a new Matty Bate. Neeld rates this guy and with some good coaches Bater will rise.

[melbournefc18 4]

um no Green, Jones, Martin, McKenzie or Watts????????

[Dee Dee 1,108]

Gee DF you have Sellar in the team straight away.

The bloke's damaged goods and will need to have an Ingerson like reserection first.

And that team's forward line looks a bit sus untill Clark can prove himself.

Watts and McKenzie in the above two out. And Gys also says hello!

[Range Rover 1,935]

B: Grimes Frawley Garland

HB: Bail Martin Blease

C: Morton Sylvia Trengove

HF: Howe Watts Jurrah

FF: Green Clark Davey

FOLL: Jamar Moloney Jones

INT: Rivers McKenzie Gysberts Petterd (sub)

EMER: Sellar Bennell Tapscott

[hrob 2]

B: Tapscott Frawley Rivers

HB: Grimes Garland Blease

C: Bail Sylvia Jones

HF: Howe Watts Jurrah

FF: Green Clark Davey

FOLL: Jamar Moloney Trengove

INT: Martin McKenzie Gysberts Petterd (sub)

EMG: Bate Bartram Morton

[torpedo 33]

B: Tappy Frawley Rivers

HB: Grimes Garland Blease

C: Jones Sylvia Trengove

HF: Howe Clark Jurrah

F: Green Watts Davey

R: Jamar Moloney McKenzie

INT: S.Martin Gysberts Bail D.Nicholson

[Rollo2 64]

B: Bartram Rivers Garland

HB: Grimes Frawley Blease

C: Green Jones Bail

HF: Sylvia Watts Howe

FF: Jurrah Clark Davey

F: Jamar Moloney Trengove

INT: Martin Morton McKenzie Petterd (sub)

Like how many people have Flash in the forward line. Don't understand everyone assuming Stef can play CHB. Tap and MacDonald are stiff here, both can come in if Bartram misses three sitters again like he did against WC, and Gys for Morton if he still refuses to go hard, but this would be the most exciting lineup for mine.

[Dee1987 277]

OK OK.... Watts in instead of Nicholson. Mark Neeld stated Sellar will come straight in to the team Dee Dee, get your facts right. Watts does not have the physical presence, he is more of a Flanker. Look at the pies and hawks they atleast have 2 big bodied forwards ( Cloke, Dawes, Roughead, Franklin, Hale). We have now got Clark and Sellar to work with our abundance of pocket/ flank forwards. We got absolutley anhilated this year due to our lack of big strong bodied forwards. Im not saying he will be the match winner but now we look much better with 2 big boys in the forward line

[Roost It 1,434]

B: Nicholson Martin Garland

HB: Blease Frawley MacDonald

C: Bail Jones Morton

HF: Sylvia Watts Howe

FF: Petterd Clark Davey

F: Jamar Grimes Trengove

INT: Gysberts Bate McKenzie Jurrah (sub)

Other points.

Sellar won't play unless injuries or talls being rested.

Grimes must play midfield if we're going to get true benefit from him.

Bennell could well replace a number on this list

Jetta is a smoky

Jurrah will need to do a stack of work to remain in the side.

edit

out Tapscott

in MacDonald

Edited November 25, 2011 by Roost It

[rhaz 342]

Mark Neeld stated Sellar will come straight in to the team Dee Dee, get your facts right.

Neeld said he CAN, not WILL, step right into the team. Get your facts right.

[Trisul 664]

Jurrah will need to do a stack of work to remain in the side.

Imagine that. Even on his worst day Jurrah is more than capable of being in the right place at the right time at least a couple of times.

Fast forward to a Jurrah that is desperate to be included in the selected team, and demands everyone know it on the day. Scary.

[deefan12 3]

Bartram (runs hard and is tough) Frawley (tough and hard at the ball) Garland (hard at the ball and contests all the time)

MacDonald (tough and hard at the ball) Sellar (big body and hopefully will contest hard) Tapscott (strong and hard at the ball)

Grimes (brave as hell and attacks the ball) Moloney (big body and attacks the ball) Bail ( runs hard and attacks the ball)

Sylvia (tough and hard when fit) Clark (big strong and aggressive) Trengove (fearless and attacks the ball)

Howe (getting fitter, stronger and attacks the ball) Martin (big and strong and jumps and runs hard) Jetta (works hard and attacks the ball)

Jamar (big body and jumps hard) McKenzie (tackles hard and attacks the ball) Jones (strong and relentless at the ball)

Bate ( stronger and fitter and attacks the ball) T Mcdonald (real big and strong and attacks everything) Nicholson (runs hard and getting stronger) Taggert (will be strong and will attack the ball)

Its all about strong bodies and work rate

Edited November 25, 2011 by deefan12

[Barney Rubble 1,576]

B: Nicholson Martin Garland

HB: Blease Frawley MacDonald

C: Bail Jones Morton

HF: Sylvia Watts Howe

FF: Petterd Clark Davey

F: Jamar Grimes Trengove

INT: Gysberts Bate McKenzie Jurrah (sub)

Other points.

Sellar won't play unless injuries or talls being rested.

Grimes must play midfield if we're going to get true benefit from him.

Bennell could well replace a number on this list

Jetta is a smoky

Jurrah will need to do a stack of work to remain in the side.

edit

out Tapscott

in MacDonald

Am I missing something? No Green, No Moloney No Bartram

Yet you throw in Morton, MacDonald & Jurrah

[rolly 149]

FB: Tapscott Frawley Garland

HB: Grimes Mcdonald Nicholson

C: Jones Maloney Bail

HF: Sylvia Watts Petterd

FF: Howe Clark Jurrah

Foll: Jamar Trengove Mckenzie

Int: Martin Gysberts Rivers Green (Sub(lol))

Will be interested to see how Cook looks after a solid pre-season and whether he can force his way in at the expense of a Petterd or Howe or even Watts

[old dee 23,788]

FB: Tapscott Frawley Garland

HB: Grimes Mcdonald Nicholson

C: Jones Maloney Bail

HF: Sylvia Watts Petterd

FF: Howe Clark Jurrah

Foll: Jamar Trengove Mckenzie

Int: Martin Gysberts Rivers Green (Sub(lol))

Will be interested to see how Cook looks after a solid pre-season and whether he can force his way in at the expense of a Petterd or Howe or even Watts

Not in 2012, I doubt he will play anywhere before May with his injury.

[Maldonboy38 6,402]

B : Nicholson Frawley Garland

HB : Blease T. McDonald Grimes

C : Bail Moloney Jones

HF : Howe Watts Sylvia

F : Green Clark Jurrah

R : Jamar Trengove Bate

INT : Martin Petterd McKenzie Davey (sub)

I am a huge Jared Rivers fan but I reckon Tom McDonald will take his place this year.

I hate leaving Tappy out but it is unlikely he will be fully match fit by round 1

We lack a small crumbing forward - Jetta may sneak into the side in this role

I had Gysberts in but Petterd is more consistent and has better skills so far in his career, so had to swap them.

I reckon Bate, Gysberts, McKenzie, Blease and Nicholson may spend a lot of the year battling each other for a spot.

Max Gawn is a huge chnace to play if they settle Martin in a spot.

.

Edited November 25, 2011 by Maldonboy38

[dworship 3,342]

Now I've been wrong before, but doesn't Dan Nicholson need to be elevated off the rookie list before he can be in anyones best 22.

Edited November 25, 2011 by dworship

[Mono 455]

FB: Tapscott Frawley Garland

HB: Grimes Mcdonald Bartram

C: Watts Nicholson Maloney Bail

HF: Sylvia Clark Petterd

FF: Watts Howe Green

Foll: Jamar Trengove Mckenzie

Int: Martin/MacDonald Bate Rivers Gysberts

No spots for new draftees; or Jarrah and Davey until they prove themselves. Morton is gone. I rate Clarke more as a CHF than a FF. Howe has played plenty as a FF (in Tas).

Ed: rookies excluded

Ed 2: replaced Watts the 2nd with Nicholson, presuming he will be elevated

Edited November 26, 2011 by Mono

[BAMF 4,351]

Now I've been wrong before, but doesn't Dan Nicholson need to be elevated off the rookie list before he can be in anyones best 22.

We only have one veteren. (Green) Therfore we can upgrade a rookie prior to round 1 without having to put someone on the long term injury list. Judging from interviews and training reports then Nicholson is firmly in the lead for the upgrade.

[sylvinator 96]

Garland Frawley Grimes

Bail Rivers Tapscott

Davey Moloney Sylvia

Howe Watts Petterd

Green Clarke Jurrah

Jamar Trengove McKenzie

Int: Martin, Jones, Gysberts, Morton, Blease, Bennel, Strauss (inj till mid-year)

Depth: Bate, Dunn, Bartram, Jetta, Macdonald, Spenser, James Seller

Developing players: Cook (KPF), Gawn (Ruck), Davis (KPD), Fizpatrick (KPF/Ruck), McDonald (KPD/KPF), Taggert (mid/forward), Tynan (HBF)

Rookies: Evans, Nicholson, Lawrence + 4 rookiesGarland Frawley Grimes

[Grapeviney 9,718]

FB: Tapscott Frawley Garland

HB: Grimes Mcdonald Bartram

C: Watts Maloney Bail

HF: Sylvia Clark Petterd

FF: Watts Howe Green

Foll: Jamar Trengove Mckenzie

Int: Martin/MacDonald Bate Rivers Gysberts

No spots for new draftees; or Jarrah and Davey until they prove themselves. Morton is gone. I rate Clarke more as a CHF than a FF. Howe has played plenty as a FF (in Tas).

Ed: rookies excluded

i agree watts will be in the best 22 but i think you're asking a lot of him to play both wing and forward pocket at the same time mono

[Harrisonrules 273]

Bartram (runs hard and is tough) Frawley (tough and hard at the ball) Garland (hard at the ball and contests all the time)

MacDonald (tough and hard at the ball) Sellar (big body and hopefully will contest hard) Tapscott (strong and hard at the ball)

Grimes (brave as hell and attacks the ball) Moloney (big body and attacks the ball) Bail ( runs hard and attacks the ball)

Sylvia (tough and hard when fit) Clark (big strong and aggressive) Trengove (fearless and attacks the ball)

Howe (getting fitter, stronger and attacks the ball) Martin (big and strong and jumps and runs hard) Jetta (works hard and attacks the ball)

Jamar (big body and jumps hard) McKenzie (tackles hard and attacks the ball) Jones (strong and relentless at the ball)

Bate ( stronger and fitter and attacks the ball) T Mcdonald (real big and strong and attacks everything) Nicholson (runs hard and getting stronger) Taggert (will be strong and will attack the ball)

Its all about strong bodies and work rate

you forgot the ability to get the ball

[Harrisonrules 273]

B : Nicholson Frawley Garland

HB : Blease T. McDonald Grimes

C : Bail Moloney Jones

HF : Howe Watts Sylvia

F : Green Clark Jurrah

R : Jamar Trengove Bate

INT : Martin Petterd McKenzie Davey (sub)

I am a huge Jared Rivers fan but I reckon Tom McDonald will take his place this year.

I hate leaving Tappy out but it is unlikely he will be fully match fit by round 1

We lack a small crumbing forward - Jetta may sneak into the side in this role

I had Gysberts in but Petterd is more consistent and has better skills so far in his career, so had to swap them.

I reckon Bate, Gysberts, McKenzie, Blease and Nicholson may spend a lot of the year battling each other for a spot.

Max Gawn is a huge chnace to play if they settle Martin in a spot.

.

I agree on Tom McDonald.I amjust waiting for him to push up ahead of some others like Rivers. Of the mids I wouldn't overlook a fit Evans

[Jordie_tackles 354]

Ok its been done a million times but i will put forward what Neelds best 22 might be:

B: Tapscott, Frawley, Garland

HB: Rivers, Martin, Grimes

C: Trengove, Moloney, Bail

HF: Green, Sellar, Sylvia

F: Howe, Clark, Jurrah

FOLL: Jamar, Bate, Jones

INTR: Davey, Petterd, Nicholson, Blease

EMRG: Gysberts, Macdonald, Mckenzie.

I know ppl will be saying why Bate. i believe we will see a new Matty Bate. Neeld rates this guy and with some good coaches Bater will rise.

People will say the draft was 30 hours ago.......

lets actually get a grip

[Akum 2,660]

In 2012 there may not be a "best 22" at all. It may depend to a large extent on who we're playing.

Against a tall forward line, our "best 22" could include Sellar, with he and Martin in defence.

To avoid being outmuscled in the midfield again, we'll load up with muscle, and our "best 22" could include Bate, Tapscott, even MacDonald or Bartram in the midfield.

If we need speed, we load up with speed - Blease, Bennell, Jetta.

And whatever games Gys & Bennell manage to get, I bet they won't play against Hawks or Pies for the next 2 or 3 years.

I bet we'll be much more strategic. More players will have specific roles, we'll put a lot more effort into countering opponents' strengths & exploiting their weaknesses and select accordingly.