Black Caviar

[Biffen 12,943]

My point exactly Duder .

It's like watching Ali in his prime belting up me when I'm [censored] on a Friday night .Or the Cats against the Rising Sun Pub 18 .

Highly amusing for the spectator but not challenging for Ali or the cats.

Sepoy and Black Caviar WILL happen-and there will be less than a couple of lengths in it at least .

Moody is trying to keep her unbeaten for breeding value-which will be huge .

Sepoy is a pretty classy horse.

Like to see HT put his house on BC against him .

[Tim 3,418]

Sepoy lost to Smart Missile who then went on to beat Hay List .

When was that?

[H_T 3,043]

My point exactly Duder .

It's like watching Ali in his prime belting up me when I'm [censored] on a Friday night .Or the Cats against the Rising Sun Pub 18 .

Highly amusing for the spectator but not challenging for Ali or the cats.

Sepoy and Black Caviar WILL happen-and there will be less than a couple of lengths in it at least .

Moody is trying to keep her unbeaten for breeding value-which will be huge .

Sepoy is a pretty classy horse.

Like to see HT put his house on BC against him .

Good article by Ron Reed on Luke Nolen:

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/superracing/humble-luke-nolen-privileged-to-be-part-of-something-wonderful/story-fn67siys-1226273205616

[Biffen 12,943]

Good article-but the journo said it's Australias greatest horse .

Wonder if he he meant now or ever?

Certainly a big statement .

Vain is in her blood on both sides .

[H_T 3,043]

Nineteenth win over a very good Hay List and excellent field to boot, who had its finest run to date, unfortunately it met an equine freak ! There isn't enough adjectives to describe Black Caviar. To have come back down in distance from 1400m and produce that run on Saturday was enormous. Now has equalled the record for most consecutive wins in Australiasia of all time. That is, dare I say it again, .... Great !

Black Caviars 19 wins: -

Group 1 wins: 9

Group 2 wins: 7

1000m (5), 1200m (13), 1400m (1)

Saturdays win was Black Caviar's fifth Group 1 win at Flemington, which is a record. She surpassed Phar Lap and Makybe Diva, Mahogany and Comic Court who all boasted four Group 1 wins each.

She currently sits with Desert Gold and Gloaming who were outright champions, all on 19 consecutive wins in Australiasia. And Black Caviar is the only one to have accomplished this without tasting defeat. The last one to do so on the international scene was the great Zayetta, whose run of wins ended on 19.

[Biffen 12,943]

She really is a great sprinter HT -probably the best ever in Australia (sprinter).

Instead of her beating Hay List for the umpteenth time ,I look forward to her run in Dubai where she make take on the worlds best (including Sepoy) .

There really isn't anything here that can challenge her under six furlongs .

Like Makybe Diva ,as a mare she doesn't get weighted fairly ,for archaic handicapping reasons .

Would like to see her weighted at 60 or above ( she should be carrying 65) .

Would like to see her go the mile too .

Low hanging fruit at the moment is great for the record but ultimately unchallenging for the horse .

[mauriesy 7,287]

She really is a great sprinter HT -probably the best ever in Australia (sprinter).

Instead of her beating Hay List for the umpteenth time ,I look forward to her run in Dubai where she make take on the worlds best (including Sepoy) .

Would like to see her weighted at 60 or above ( she should be carrying 65) .

Would like to see her go the mile too .

Sepoy is a wonderful horse and will only get better. BC is now one of the greats of the turf.

I don't understand this chip on your shoulder you seem to have about her.

Why does BC have to do anything? Asking her to 'go a mile' or 'carry 65kg' just because "you'd like to see it" and it suits your bias is just ridiculous.

[H_T 3,043]

Moody after initially going cold on starting BC in the Futurity straight after her win on Saturday has now said that BC pulled up ok and may still run at Caulfield. Then off to Dubai for what will be a very big race.

He also referred to her as one that always needed maintenance in between races with soft tissue concerns. But now that she's matured somewhat, her recovery powers seem to have improved.

Pinker Pinker (last years cox plate winner) I think resumes this week in the same race. IIRC also has a good fresh record over 1400m. Will be a good test again, I would imagine for BC.

[Biffen 12,943]

Sepoy is a wonderful horse and will only get better. BC is now one of the greats of the turf.

I don't understand this chip on your shoulder you seem to have about her.

Why does BC have to do anything? Asking her to 'go a mile' or 'carry 65kg' just because "you'd like to see it" and it suits your bias is just ridiculous.

She isn't the greatest till she races the greatest .-It's not a chip.

I'm not biased either-Just don't tell me shes the greatest .

Not saying she couldn't be but she's wasting time racing chumps .

[H_T 3,043]

Did Phar Lap race against the greatest ?

Btw, again no one has said BC is the greatest ....

[Biffen 12,943]

Phar Lap raced in the states for the greatest prizemoney ever put up at the time and won in record time so er...... yes .

[H_T 3,043]

Btw, again no one has said BC is the greatest ....

So I don't know why you're carrying on Biffen.

[Biffen 12,943]

Phar Lap also beat his half brother ,Night March ,who was pretty handy ,winning a Cox Plate ,an Epsom and one of those Melbourne Cup thingies , to name a few .

BTW- I think BC is a top horse and could be the greatest sprinter from Australia ever produced .

I'm not carrying on -and shes not carrying much ,so don't believe all the hype about her .

[H_T 3,043]

Your dismissiveness is astounding. She lugged 58 kg last year to beat a crack Newmarket field down the straight. She pretty much equalled the record of Special on Saturday. So if it's time anyone wants to compare against, she more than measures up.

[H_T 3,043]

Tale of Greatness :

* Australasian record holder with Desert Gold and Gloaming for consecutive wins (19).

* Matched American champion Zenyatta's record of winning first 19 starts.

* FIRST Australian horse with 10 starts to win every race.

* Equalled Ajax's record for successive Stakes race wins (18).

* Sits alone as worlds top mare.

* Highest ever ranked Australian horse in World Thorougbred Rankings (Now 132)

* Rated worlds top sprinter.

* Owns Flemington 1000m record.

* Only mare in more than 100 years to carry 58kg to win Newmarket Handicap.

- Herald sun

[Biffen 12,943]

58 isn't that much to carry HT .

As far as the record at Flem goes she missed it by .03 for the 1000 .

Yes she is good .

I maintain she hasn't beaten much yet .

Carbine beat a field of 39 whilst carrying 65.5 in a Melbourne Cup .(to give you an indication of the greatness)

Good luck to her in Dubai .

We've seen Makybe Diva and now BC never carry more than 58 due to silly handicap rules for mares- they should change the rule .

PS-the Herald Sun is a remedial paper .

[H_T 3,043]

Agree on H-Sun.

There was something mentioned on weekend in coverage regarding the recorded times back then, about rounding them. Can't recall exactly, it doesn't matter anyway. 0.03 .... That's one poof-teenth of a hair on the nose.

Remarkable.

Chief handicapper Greg Carpenter recommends that Hay List (rated 122) going into the Lightning is undervalued internationally and he should rate around 125. BC has beaten quality. Numerous times.

[H_T 3,043]

Regarding old Melbourne Cups etc and staying races. It's different measure to that of sprinters. If she can get to a mile (which I reckon she can having brained them at 1400m), that will give her the exclamation marks.

[Biffen 12,943]

True-hard to match a sprinter to these old champs .

Shes certainly up there with Vain ,probably better .

Takeover Target struggled at the mile also .

[Biffen 12,943]

Greg Carpenter has made it his business to involve himself in the debate ,and purposefully underweights good things to draw in crowds .That's the issue .

As far as Hay List/BC ratings go- we need some international racing ,or Sepoy to really be able to tell how good they are .

[H_T 3,043]

Frankel is the only racehorse in the world with a higher rating than Black Caviar. If they meet at Ascot in the middle of our winter, I just wonder how big it will be for racing. And if they are both unbeaten on meeting, there will be massive interest.

[Tim 3,418]

Yes she is good .

I maintain she hasn't beaten much yet .

Yeah, and Jesus was a dud because it took him 3 days to rise from the dead.

[Biffen 12,943]

Yeah, and Jesus was a dud because it took him 3 days to rise from the dead.

True-and gullible twits the world over took it all in without question .

[Biffen 12,943]

True-and gullible twits the world over took it all in without question .

Sorry , I seem to have run over your dogma.

[Sir Why You Little 37,034]

Sorry , I seem to have run over your dogma.

Religion is such a solid base isn't it!