Demonland Player of the Year

[Jaded No More 67,772]

Nice numbering system

3> Jamar - herculean effort. I've never been resentful of Jolly leaving, but I can't help but smile seeing Jamar pants him twice in one year.

2.5> Moloney - I had great difficulty splitting these two. Massive effort.

2> Garland - Welcome back. Did absolutely everything right today. What a gem.

1.5> Morton - How many times did he get free by half a paddock? Amazing stuff. Not a big accumulator of the ball, but extremely damaging when he gets it.

1> Davey

0.5> Scully

Lots of others considered. I found the top 4 easy to pick, and could've thrown a blanket over another 10 for the next two.

Interesting that you gave Scully votes, since you watched the game on TV (I'm assuming?), because when you're at the ground it's very hard to appreciate the sort of work that this kid does in the packs.

[Jerry Lundergard 420]

I know everyone is entitled to their opinionn, but i can't beleive Davey does not make it in some peoples top 6 players, he was best on for me, along with Jamar and Moloney.

6. Davey

5. Jamar

4. Moloney

3. Morton

2. Garland

1. Jones

Edited June 14, 2010 by Jerry Lundergard

[dee-tox 4,835]

I know everyone is entitled to their opinionn, but i can't beleive Davey does not make it in some peoples top 6 players, he was best on for me, along with Jamar and Moloney.

6. Davey

5. Jamar

4. Moloney

3. Morton

2. Garland

1. Jones

Good point Jerry on Davey. He was superb.

3 Jamar

2.5 davey

2 Moloney

1.5 Garland

1 Jones

.5 Morton

[DirtyDees DDC 176]

3 - Moloney. he was everywhere. 38 possesions - his best game ever for the club. we were looking at a thrashing and he willed us back into the game. Proud of him.

2.5 - the big Russian - took on 2 opponents and beat them both without support.

2. Davey - 28 possessions but missed at least 4 targets coming out of the backline. He DOES get the hard ball.

1.5 - Garland - 24 possessions -and took the initiative to kick a goal in the second.

1. Jones. tireless - always working so hard at the coalface.

.5 Frawley - a rock in defence and good to see him drift down into the forward line.

Morton did well as an outside player. Hopefully next year he can put on some beef and start winning contested possessions.

[Trisul 664]

Garland

Moloney

Jamar

Morton

Bartram

Davey

[Great_little_footy_team 8]

3. Moloney

2.5. Jamar

2. Davey

1.5 Morton

1. Garland

0.5 Dunn

[Inner Demon 1]

3 Jamar

2.5 Moloney

2 Morton

1.5 Jones

1 Davey

0.5 Miller

[Wadda We Sing 10,685]

Jamar

Davey

Maloney

Scully

Morton

Garland

Edited June 14, 2010 by Demon Den

[mikeod 21]

Jamar

Davey

Moloney

Garland

Morton

Frawley

[Demonland 70,312]

Given it was a draw we took half votes from 6 people and had no weighting. This meant we had the same number aggregate number of votes as would be expected.

The Russian is motoring on and grabbed a good lead in Junior's absence:

89.112 Mark Jamar

73.092 Brent Moloney

70.951 James McDonald

65.308 James Frawley

61.653 Jack Grimes

43.553 Brad Green

36.527 Jack Trengove

36.483 Aaron Davey

33.071 Tom Scully

32.347 Colin Sylvia

22.647 Matthew Bate

20.656 Ricky Petterd

19.567 Jordie McKenzie

19.525 Nathan Jones

18.567 Jamie Bennell

17.257 Jordan Gysberts

17.065 Matthew Warnock

14.878 Cameron Bruce

11.680 Clint Bartram

8.500 Cale Morton

8.211 Rohan Bail

8.073 Neville Jetta

7.921 Lynden Dunn

7.064 Brad Miller

4.752 Cale Morton

3.000 Colin Garland

2.812 Joel Macdonald

2.453 Jack Watts

[demonbike 1]

This is my first time posting on this site.Spent the last few years reading the comments . Whilst sometimes I shake my head at some opinions what is obvious to me is the level of commitment and feeling for the MFC --take a bow posters.

Todays game was a mixture mostly good some a work in progress and some Arrgg.

Watching on TV my votes (not sure of the amount ??)

beamer

jamar

davey

morton

dunn

frawley

[Geddy Lee 582]

Thought Jones was great today. I was there and his effort was palpable.

6 - Jamar

5 - Moloney

4 - Jones

3 - Bartram

2 - Bate

1 - Garland

[Tricky 341]

Moloney

Davey

Jamar

Garland

Morton

Frawley

[Red Sox 2]

I prefer the 6 to 1...but ok:

3 - Jamar - Superb by the big Russian, is getting better as the season goes on and his efforts in last qtrs against Port and now the pies have been inspiring, he gets the nod from me for the interview on ten after the game, he was gutted and blamed himself for Jolly getting the mark that went on to Lockyer. He was gutted and showed how much these boys want it.

2.5 - Davey - hard to split Flash & Beamer.. both super in the last as we pushed for the 4 points. Flash gets my 5 simply for his courage in taking players on and finishing it off with his execution by foot

2.0 - Moloney - I, like so many always seem to want to skip a generation and look for the next captains from the young brigade, Beamer - you have just been throwing up the hand so high this last 12-18 mths - a captains effort yesterday!

1.5 - Garland - Super, super game from Col. It astounds me that people wanted him to have a spell, this guy just needed some game time after 12 mths out of it and he and Chip will be the premier defenders in the comp. Stop the forward line calls, Col is a great defender.

1.0 - Morton - he is THE new AFL players isnt he? Can make some bad decisions at times but this drop away, I wish he would use his height and size a little more in marking contests but this can come in time too. A great game by Cal and another stepping stone

0.5 - Dunn - hard to split Bartram or Dunn, both player defensive roles even though Dunn up forward, I give it to Dunn as he kept Shaw quiet and Davis has been in pretty average form anyway, not much of a point but enough for me!

Apologies to Chip and the entire backline.....gee these guys are good. Jones, Scully, Jetta. Green would've got votes had he finished off his work and won us the game.

[titan_uranus 24,631]

6 - Jamar

5 - Moloney

4 - Davey

3 - Garland

2 - Morton

1 - Bartram

Warnock, Frawley, Jones all stiff to miss out.

[Deeoldfart 7,996]

Just got back from Melbourne. My belated votes:

6. Moloney

5. Jamar

4. Davey

3. Frawley

2. Garland

1. Bruce

[Deeoldfart 7,996]

................(I'm not giving Moloney top votes because without Jamar, Moloney would struggle to win so much of the ball)

Agree ... they are developing a great understanding. First time I can recall an on-ball working relationship like this at MFC for a very long time!

[bjDee 1,249]

I'm not into Supercoach, but I was keen to know at least what Jamar & Beamer scored. Couldn't see anything in the papers today. Can anyone give us the scores from yesterday for say our top 6 Supercoach players?

[scully31 0]

3 Moloney

2.5 Jamar

2 Davey

1.5 Morton

1 Garland

0.5 Jones

[Felix 92]

6 Moloney

5 Jamar

4 Davey

3 Morton

2 Garland

1 Bartram

Just watched the game, the first 5-10 minutes cost melbourne the game. Great games for the young kids. Jack Watts was poor for me, a few poor decisions, they will soon disappear from his game with more games under him.