Riewoldt Frawley

[Bitter but optimistic 22,241]

Who cares about Riewoldt/Richmond. I hate Richmond, hope they dont win again- ever.

[#MYHEARTBEATSTRUE 27]

Alba by a freaking mile,

frawley!!!

[Cards13 9,117]

Portman... The scene in V for Vendetta when she is dressed as a young girl... Wow

Edited June 4, 2010 by Cards13

[Gorgoroth 12,967]

Portman when she shaves her head in V.....giddy up!

I also think she is awesome in Garden State.

Got Sin City, but Alba whilst very attractive, just blends in with all the other blonde girls and does not stand out amongst them.

Now Scarlett Johansson is a different story

[DeeSpencer 25,719]

I'd love Riewoldt but our backline would be terrible without Frawley. Both guns and better than Gumbleton, Hansen, Brown *2, Reid, Thorp and other talls at this stage from the first round of that super draft, but it is a long way to the finish line.

Looking at Riewoldt I think we can see how quickly forwards can improve when they get some size and confidence in their bodies. Last year Riewoldt just casually led and barely chased, we even played Bartram on him. This year he has confidence to demand the footy and is kicking goals. Hopefully Watts can start to do this over time.

[Disco Demons 92]

Um...Geelong?

Compare their forward line to their backline.

good point...but geelong has mids...steve j...kicked most goals for cats last year and played less games than cam m...geelong are a fantastic 'team' they know how each other play together. bomber has been quoted as saying mooney is one of his most important players...because if he doesn't fire it puts a lot of pressure on the team to kick a winning score.

doesn't matter if your a defender...you are kicking the ball forward...so everyeone is really a forward.

in melbournes instance...we have a young side.. bails talks about getting games into these young players...put 50-100 games into our young players then it doesn't really matter where they play...because thats experience. experience is something the cats have a lot of....they have a week forward line compared to previous super sides like the hawks in the 80s having dunstall. imagine if Lloydd played in the cats side for the past 5 years...he could have been one of the greatest full forwards of all time.

my inital argument was i didn't agree with defense wins premerships...that's all..

[Jaded No More 68,965]

serious...?

most goals/points win i say...football is a simple game stuffed up by footballers...learn that.

I've seen average forward lines in premiership teams. When was the last time a premiership side had an average backline?

[bandicoot 1,395]

Portman by a freaking mile!!!!!!

How funny is the Natalie portman snl rap...

[GOLF 13]

I've seen average forward lines in premiership teams. When was the last time a premiership side had an average backline?

Damn straight.

[Guest The Boss]

I love these draft threads. They are both great picks in my opinion, and I am sure most supporters would be happy to have either one in their team.

Personally, I think Riewoldt is the more talented player but I think Chip ended up being a better pick. Chip is one of the best young defenders in the competition, and its great that he is showing loyalty to the team that selected him by signing the dotted line for 4 year instead of chasing money from GC17/GWS. (I do not know Riewoldt's contract situation, so have NFI if he has re-signed)

With the impending free agency, loyal players will be a factor for all clubs. With all the money and time spent developing young players, it would be a real kick in the guts to see them walk out for more lucrative contracts and for the club to get zero return.

[beelzebub 23,380]

Frawley... we took what we needed..and he is still getting better...maybe too Jack.. but its Chpper for me.

( on a side note...consider how average Jack wasuntil now... ...makes you think of another young Jack playing as a forward !!! No?? )

p.s

aLBA

[jacey 333]

I would still go with chip but jack is a gun!!!

Same. Both look very good at their respective ends of the ground but Frawley looks to be a leader and stable influence while Riewodlt looks to be a Richo style personality. A flawed superstar.

[titan_uranus 25,020]

Frawley > Riewoldt

Only because Frawley is down to earth and isn't a show-off.

[RalphiusMaximus 6,054]

Reiwoldt is another Robbo. NOw, I have never had a problem with Robbo, but many here did so I wonder how they look at this. He is the only forward they have at the moment, hence his big hauls. However, the team would be far better off with a couple of real key forwards for him to work off.

[Rogue 585]

If Riewoldt could kick straight I'd be more interested in this discussion

As for Frawley getting beaten by him, wasn't there a rumour he might be a late withdrawl due to sickness?