Farewell Jesse Hogan

[Smokey 4,112]

6 minutes ago, Petraccattack said:

The day after an I am feeling very good about this deal.   The reality is we won two finals without Hogan.   We were less predictable, We will still kick mammoth scores without him.

Adding May and Lever into the backline will be huge.   2019 is the year.

Completely agree. We have struck a great balance in the force this trade period. 

[Gator 16,888]

6 hours ago, Pirlo said:

The article in The Age suggests that Hogan has had mental health issues since what happened last year, and it certainly explains his dip in form after Queen's Birthday this season. Will miss him dearly, and feel like we were short changed (giving back pick 55 is a kick in the teeth), but its clear the club was hamstrung by a young man desperate to go home and decided that May was the man to bring in as a replacement tall.

Throwing in pick "65" is a "kick in the teeth" ?

Amusing 

[Ron Burgundy 8,584]

50 minutes ago, Petraccattack said:

The day after an I am feeling very good about this deal.   The reality is we won two finals without Hogan.   We were less predictable, We will still kick mammoth scores without him.

Adding May and Lever into the backline will be huge.   2019 is the year.

Totally agree. We now have an almost perfectly calibrated list.

Injuries permitting, and assuming a good pre-season (no Adelaide-esque hiccups), we should be a lock for the top 4 next year.

I continue to be super impressed with Mahoney, Viney and Taylor. The upgrading of the picks to secure two in the 20s was the icing on this trade period - did not see that coming, but shook my head in stunned satisfaction that they are just not missing a trick these days.

The MFC is oozing competence at the moment.

 

Edited October 17, 2018 by Ron Burgundy

[—coach— 3,466]

11 hours ago, Lucifer's Hero said:

Quite the opposite:  "Jesse Hogan has taken a significant pay cut to get back to his family in Perth and play for Fremantle".

https://www.theage.com.au/sport/afl/hogan-accepts-pay-cut-to-join-fremantle-as-stars-switch-clubs-20181017-p50aa2.html

It makes his decision to go to Freo even more baffling: leaves a team on the brink of success for one at the bottom, takes only a three year deal and a pay cut.  Baffling.

Its no wonder we weren't able to get a better trade deal - much easier to get top picks if player is on a long-term multi $m deal.   Mahoney did a great job getting the deal he did.

What a great article, super proud of our club and the people involved with Jesse, the comments about the support and compassion shown by Goodwin and Mahoney prove that we are onto a winner with these two. I was very comfortable with the deal before reading this and now think we nailed it given the nature of why he wanted to leave putting us at a significant disadvantage at the negotiating table.  Very proud of our team at the moment ???

Best of luck to Jesse also ?

[iv'a worn smith 1,979]

In the light of day, this makes me smile.

 

[Guest]

Whether or not it is an indicator of future on field form (the only thing that matters) is a different matter but something that was very reassuring in Jesse leaving was the response of his manager. 

Matt Bain said that they couldn't commend the MFC highly enough in their support of Jesse and that this wouldn't even be happening if we were based in Perth.

Compare that to the departures of Scully, Junior, Greeny, Frosty Miller, Beamer and Riv (with both Riv and Beamer taking potshots at people in the club after leaving). 

[Wollongong Demon 182]

Sometimes it does feel like this club is a 7/11 for some of the others but the Mfc did the right thing with Watts and the Jesse case had many elements to it.

My disappointment is not just Jesse but losing Kent and Garletts form. 3 big goal kickers missing.

Edited October 17, 2018 by Wollongong Demon

[YesitwasaWin4theAges 5,786]

1 hour ago, iv'a worn smith said:

In the light of day, this makes me smile.

 

This could turn out to be the shrewdest bit of business the MFC have ever made.

[La Dee-vina Comedia 16,381]

11 hours ago, Dr. Gonzo said:

That article mentions mental health issues which had been alluded to but not stated outright. Wouldn't surprise considering his last 2-3 years and you can't blame him for wanting to get back to his mum, siblings and mates. This is a bit different to generic "homesickness" the guys been through more than any 23yo should over the last 2 years.

 

11 hours ago, Moonshadow said:

Maybe there's more to him leaving than we know dc.

Many of the reasons seem to defy logic. The main one for me is why leave a well run club on the way up for a lowly club with limited delivery inside 50?

I dunno either.

How many people at age 23 think the same way as when they were 17? I just wonder whether Hogan has lost the degree of interest in football that he had when we first recruited him. There's no shame in that. I'm pretty sure when I was 23 I would be embarrassed to still love doing the things I loved doing when I was 17. Moving clubs and States may well be what he needs to re-generate enthusiasm for the game. (And if he becomes a dominant player in the competition in 2019 I'll console myself with the thought that it would not have happened if he'd stayed with us.)

[La Dee-vina Comedia 16,381]

12 minutes ago, Wollongong Demon said:

Sometimes it does feel like this club is a 7/11 for some of the others but the Mfc did the right thing with Watts and the Jesse case had many elements to it.

My disappointment is not just Jesse but losing Kent and Garletts form. 3 big goal kickers missing.

I think that's overstating Kent's historical performance. Yes, he kicked an average of 1 goal a game (63 games for 63 goals) but that works out at approx 10 goals per year over his 6 years with us.

[dees189227 10,700]

Can we blame Mark Neeld for this. He got us Jesse, got us all excited about the nest big superstar forward. 

Look at least next year we won't have to put up with will he or won't he re-sign. He would have gone home, so at least we got the deal done now. 

Also after Melbourne games no longer will we have to read about his bad body language and him sooking on this site. 

But I wish Jesse all the best. He has been through more at the age of 23 then most of us have in a lifetime. He has lost his Dad and had a cancer scare and had injuries on the way. 

But good look under Ross Lyon. He has gone from being under a calm coach to Ross who seems to be demanding, gets angry and expects a lot from his players. 

 

[Frank Grimes 121]

Very sad to see him leave from a sentimental standpoint, but getting May is huge and I think gets us closer to a premiership in the next few years. 

 

Can't blame Jesse for wanting to move home after what he's been through and hope he doesn't get booed for it. Who knows after his 3 year contract he might decide he wants some success and try to come back as a free agent?

 

https://www.sen.com.au/news/2018/10/17/the-message-hogan-delivered-to-goodwin-before-trade/

[In Harmes Way 7,477]

I think Melbourne have looked after Jesse admirably. I think Jesse respected that honourably.

He will be missed. He was my boy's favourite player. 

But for the sake of his wellbeing, I hope he finds balance in his life home in Perth and a happy career at Freo. I'll still cheer for you when you next front up at the G to receive a bath from the 2019 premiers. All the best.

[Demon trucker 1,722]

4 hours ago, Frank Grimes said:

Very sad to see him leave from a sentimental standpoint, but getting May is huge and I think gets us closer to a premiership in the next few years. 

 

Can't blame Jesse for wanting to move home after what he's been through and hope he doesn't get booed for it. Who knows after his 3 year contract he might decide he wants some success and try to come back as a free agent?

 

https://www.sen.com.au/news/2018/10/17/the-message-hogan-delivered-to-goodwin-before-trade/

Full [censored] hogan does not love our club I wish him no goodwill, hope he never taste success, Lyon kills forwards, hope he loves 30 inside 50's a game

[old dee 22,799]

2 minutes ago, don't make me angry said:

Full sh@t hogan does not love our club I wish him no goodwill, hope he never taste success, Lyon kills forwards, hope he loves 30 inside 50's a game

That is a tough attitude. Live and let live. It is only a football game.

[beelzebub 22,225]

What a fascinating thread to read and participate in

[Demon trucker 1,722]

12 minutes ago, old dee said:

That is a tough attitude. Live and let live. It is only a football game.

Not really anyone that dies not play for the Dee's are  enemies he'll be just like Jeff farmer who deeply regretted leaving us for that God awful Club

[pitmaster 3,048]

Like many others here I am OK with this trade, although 12 months ago I would have been appalled.

Hoges has much more to offer but clearly we were faced with a player who was determined to go home. Weideman showed enough for us to take a punt on him and TMac supported by Jake M and maybe Frisch to go back to attack as our forward structure so that we could let Hoges go.

We at least got a monster defender for our trouble and if KadeK comes up trumps it's been a pretty reasonable return. Well done to the footy department in difficult circumstances.

Hoges farewell message showed some class too.

On another note, I don't actually think Hoges has done himself any onfield favours. Ross Lyon is not a coach that fosters much loyalty or confidence. Has all the warmth and charisma of a tiger snake.

Edited October 18, 2018 by pitmaster

[jumbo returns 6,484]

Like Watts and Scully and others, this discussion has to have an end point and with this thread, I hope it's soon....

[Sir Why You Little 34,405]

I have the feeling Jesse will play for the Demons again....

just a hunch after reading ? his farewell message

[daisycutter 28,427]

3 minutes ago, Sir Why You Little said:

I have the feeling Jesse will play for the Demons again....

just a hunch after reading ? his farewell message

not like you to be the romantic, wyl ?

[Sir Why You Little 34,405]

Just now, daisycutter said:

not like you to be the romantic, wyl ?

Well not on here dc!!!

[chook fowler 18,160]

2 minutes ago, Sir Why You Little said:

I have the feeling Jesse will play for the Demons again....

just a hunch after reading ? his farewell message

he may be hit by the Ross Lyon reality bus. Why anyone would want to play under him God only knows. It will be interesting to see how it plays out given that there is a story behind Neale wanting out and i believe Fyffe isn't a popular captain.

[Sir Why You Little 34,405]

Just now, chook fowler said:

he may be hit by the Ross Lyon reality bus. Why anyone would want to play under him God only knows. It will be interesting to see how it plays out given that there is a story behind Neale wanting out and i believe Fyffe isn't a popular captain.

If the MFC remains a Premiership contender for years to come, it wouldn’t suprise me one bit if Hogan returned for another stint. 

That message tells me he is still a Demon deep down, but right now he has to get home...

[chook fowler 18,160]

3 minutes ago, Sir Why You Little said:

If the MFC remains a Premiership contender for years to come, it wouldn’t suprise me one bit if Hogan returned for another stint. 

That message tells me he is still a Demon deep down, but right now he has to get home...

interesting his contract is only for 3 years. Mind you i reckon Ross Lyon is on borrowed time.