Farewell Jesse Hogan

[samcantstandya 918]

23 minutes ago, SFebes said:

Probably because he was under the impression that Hogan would go this year. He also said we didn't intend to pick May up until next year.

Get next year & keep Hogan

[old55 21,265]

9 minutes ago, Bonkers said:

Yes I believe they haven't used a first round pick in the draft for 3 years. This year will be the first time they have used a first rounder since 2014? They would have applied to use last years first rounder for a trade completed in 2016. Possibly Touhy?

Posted earlier in this thread:

I think the AFL gave Geelong permission last year.  They just want to protect against basket cases and desperate regimes selling their future down the river.  But if the club looks in good shape I think they'll allow it.

Here's a possible link I found but it's behind the paywall

https://www.google.com/amp/s/amp.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/geelong-can-again-trade-its-firstround-draft-pick-in-2018/news-story/82989f88db7d2425be27dae06077fab7

•  

[GCDee 3,006]

I really don't want to have to put up with will he stay or go all bloody year next year. Make a call, leave now or sign a 4 year extension. 

[Willmoy1947 3,769]

....and the truth will set us free.

[old55 21,265]

26 minutes ago, Bonkers said:

We can't trade next years first round pick due to trading first round picks from previous years. Unless we trade out a player (Hogan) we don't have currency to bring in high end talent such as May, Shiel, etc. We would have to apply to the AFL to use next years first round pick. Even if the AFL allowed it and we proposed to offer it up for May, it may not be enough to convince GC to trade May. They are likely to want something now for him rather than wait for next year unless they can on trade it for a player which I think is unlikely. 

That is NOT correct apparently.  See @Lucifer's Hero post from earlier in this thread:

Quote

 

Rule:  Clubs must make at least two first-round selections in each four-year period. If they don't, they will face restrictions from trading any further first-round draft picks.

Geelong may need to play catch up  http://www.geelongcats.com.au/news/2018-07-19/cats-first-round-requirements

With no first round picks in 2016, 2017, 2018 (might change) used, technically we need to trade in a first round pick this year or an extra one next year otherwise we won't have the required two picks (unless we get exemption) but like Geelong it eventually catches up with you. 

 

I can't find any reference to an mfc request to trade our 2019 pick.  I would suggest if we had it would be public knowledge by now as the trade starts in a few days.

 

As an aside, something that is untested with the AFL is the number of 1st round picks taken over a period ie would we get an allowance for traded in an extra pick in 2015? 

 

Edit:  Just re-read the AFL article in the above link and found this line:  "... the rest of the competition has already met its quota and is free to place 2018 and 2019 first-round picks on the table."  So we don't need permission.

 

 

[No10 323]

13 minutes ago, DemonLad5 said:

Lobb decision doesn't bode particularly well for us

What's the Lobb decision? And why not well bode?

[Gator 16,891]

46 minutes ago, dazzledavey36 said:

 

Mitch Cleary

 

@cleary_mitch

 

Josh Mahoney

@melbournefc

has arrived for start of #AFLTrades. Says preference is to keep Aaron vandenBerg, despite an interest to move to Sydney. Will have conversation with STK this morning on Dean Kent. Waiting on answers from Jesse Hogan and Steven May

@AFLcomau

We spent the weekend trying to convince the uncontracted vandenBerg to stay.

We haven't been trying to talk the contracted Hogan into staying.

The difference is palpable.  

We want May and are happy to say goodbye to Hogan.

[DemonLad5 1,637]

Just now, No10 said:

What's the Lobb decision? And why not well bode?

Wants to be at Freo, and as a result makes him Freo's #1 target. Freo's interest in Hogan is decreasing but still there and could force us to accept a worse deal

[buck_nekkid 5,476]

I if Hogan goes as a RFA in a few years and we are on par with this year, then we get about pick 16-20 as compo, but an additional years service.  If we trade him out this year, we can do better than that (1 or more top 10 picks?).  I suggest we were into May as a free agent option, but GCS see the benefit in the trade 1 year early.  GCS could get better compo if they see themselves being a basket case again next year.

it means clubs have to demand the contracts are longer term from this point, or decide if 12 months service is worth the drop in value at the trade table.  Players have to make this call, then the clubs can act in their best interests.

over to you, Jesse.  Either way, sign or go, next move is yours.  The sooner the better, BTW.

[No10 323]

1 minute ago, DemonLad5 said:

Wants to be at Freo, and as a result makes him Freo's #1 target. Freo's interest in Hogan is decreasing but still there and could force us to accept a worse deal

Oh, I see. I would've thought Hogan would be the much more valuable player?  But I guess I don't know enough about Lobb.

[Dwight Schrute 16,749]

4 minutes ago, DemonLad5 said:

Wants to be at Freo, and as a result makes him Freo's #1 target. Freo's interest in Hogan is decreasing but still there and could force us to accept a worse deal

No. It couldn’t. Because Jesse is contracted and much more talented than lobb. Freo have leaked that to try and panic us into accepting less rather than miss out on May. 

[olisik 4,060]

Hogan needs to make up his [censored] mind opposed to beating around the bush every year. It’s trade period, the longer he wants to think about it the less time we have to trade. I hope we put a 5 year contract in front of him and tell him to sign it or his out. This is now at a point where his indecisiveness is going to start costing the club.

[hells bells 2,022]

There is a lot of posturing going on.  

[layzie 28,692]

No decision or announcement by now is pretty nerving. We will need every bit of time to get a decent deal done.

[Ugottobekidding 915]

5 minutes ago, layzie said:

No decision or announcement by now is pretty nerving. We will need every bit of time to get a decent deal done.

Is he even leaving???

[Lord Travis 10,158]

9 minutes ago, No10 said:

Oh, I see. I would've thought Hogan would be the much more valuable player?  But I guess I don't know enough about Lobb.

Hogan is more valuable, as he’s obviously a more talented player. I think he means Lobb has actually committed to them so he is now their primary concern, as opposed to a player who can’t make up his mind and is constantly stuffing everyone around. The fact he’s touring their facilities etc shows he’s got one foot out the door already and isn’t properly committed to us anymore.

Edited October 7, 2018 by Lord Travis

[ManDee 7,076]

Chill.

Rome wasn't built in a day. The Gaff decision may also put the wind up Freo, (do they offer more) Hogan may choose to stay, either way I imagine the club has asked Hogan for his response by a certain time or we will move on believing he will stay and not entertain a trade this year. The May deal is separate and I think we can still land him (with AFL permission) 

[Gawn's Beard 334]

18 minutes ago, olisik said:

Hogan needs to make up his [censored] mind opposed to beating around the bush every year. It’s trade period, the longer he wants to think about it the less time we have to trade. I hope we put a 5 year contract in front of him and tell him to sign it or his out. This is now at a point where his indecisiveness is going to start costing the club.

Is it entirely plausible that Hogan has told the club, but the club are brokering a deal prior to Hogan going public? If he comes out and say I want to go home to Fremantle, it weakens our hand somewhat 

[Matt Demon 1,385]

Don't believe anything you read, lying is the number one language in football. 

[ManDee 7,076]

Just now, Matt Demon said:

Don't believe anything you read, lying is the number one language in football. 

Who lies the most, the media, sporting clubs or politicians? Would any of us trust any of them with our lives? 

[jnrmac 18,947]

Why the panic here? The club knows what it is doing these days.

Nothing we write here will change anything and yet here we are at 190 pages...

[drysdale demon 4,146]

1 minute ago, jnrmac said:

Why the panic here? The club knows what it is doing these days.

Nothing we write here will change anything and yet here we are at 190 pages...

Yeah, an awful lot of panicking going on with this thread.

[Graeme Yeats' Mullet 6,277]

My read in the situation is that there won't be a decision from Jesse until there is a deal done (in the background). There is no way we'd want a situation where he decides to go and a deal can't be done, or we get screwed down after his preference becomes public and there's no going back.

So what's happening then:

 - Jesse happy to go

 - Freo waiting for some reason, good situation is just until Neale deal finalised and confirm the picks they'll give us. Bad situation is they've taken a step back due to posturing, or worse preference for Lobb, or catastrophically Jesse's foot

 - Melbourne powerless to do anything until Freo sorts out it's shyte

We'll be waiting for a few days yet I reckon...

[layzie 28,692]

8 minutes ago, Gawn's Beard said:

Is it entirely plausible that Hogan has told the club, but the club are brokering a deal prior to Hogan going public? If he comes out and say I want to go home to Fremantle, it weakens our hand somewhat 

Its possible. Would put some pressure on us to get the deal done if he did make an announcement I guess and then in the event that it doesn't get done we get a nice media circus. 

[Ethan Tremblay 28,358]

9 minutes ago, Matt Demon said:

Don't believe anything you read, lying is the number one language in football. 

I don’t know if I can believe this.