Changes vs Saints

[YesitwasaWin4theAges 5,788]

3 hours ago, WERRIDEE said:

GO THE MIGHTY DEES BACK ON TRACK

IN: PETRACCA

OUT: ANB

couldn't agree more?? 

[Moonshadow 16,109]

Weid halved at least every contest that I saw. The two big marks he took in the last were as good as any in the match. That made me take note immediately. His kicking lacks power and accuracy, but as his confidence builds, so too will his game. I'd definitely keep him in the seniors and am excited to see his progress over the year.

Harmes frustrates me more than most in the team. He gets a fair bit of the ball but his use is often poor. I love his agression at the opposition, but he gives away a lot of 50/50 balls as well as numerous free kicks. I'm aware he's only played 50 games and has potential, so is also worth persisting with.

I think ANB is on thin ice, particularly if Trac is ready to return. Bernie might also need a spell soon.

Match ups and balance vs the Saints will be a determining factor as well

Edited April 29, 2018 by Moonshadow

[Demons11 6,404]

2 hours ago, Leoncelli_36 said:

Petracca has posted today from hospital. Video of him in a hospital bed. There may be a chance he misses another match.

He’ll play. They said he would be in hospital getting monitored over the weekend, that’s why he didn’t play 

[In Harmes Way 7,477]

All the talk around Weidemann is exactly the same talk around OMac 12 months ago. We need to get games into him now. 

Nobody would drop OMac now. Get Weids to the same level and we’re another step closer to top 4.

[martin 727]

Hogan could be rested. Looked sore and weary. Not ideal but Petracca comes in. Is Viney any chance at all?

[SFebes 4,692]

5 minutes ago, martin said:

Hogan could be rested. Looked sore and weary. Not ideal but Petracca comes in. Is Viney any chance at all?

No chance mate, still a couple of weeks away according to presser FYI 

[Demons11 6,404]

22 minutes ago, small but forward said:

All the talk around Weidemann is exactly the same talk around OMac 12 months ago. We need to get games into him now. 

Nobody would drop OMac now. Get Weids to the same level and we’re another step closer to top 4.

100% correct. 

Supporters will always try and pick someone out to have a go at. 

[Demons11 6,404]

7 minutes ago, martin said:

Hogan could be rested. Looked sore and weary. Not ideal but Petracca comes in. Is Viney any chance at all?

Got a knock to the knee.  It happened against the Tigers and got fit again. 

If he recovered in 5 days, then he’ll be right   By next Sunday. 

He loves kicking bags against the Saints. 

[jacey 333]

I thought Hogan tmac n weid trio worked.

Too big to play all three in fwd 50 but Hogan, tmac take turns in the midfield n tmac  n weid to take turns in ruck.

Like the balance 

 

[martin 727]

17 minutes ago, SFebey said:

No chance mate, still a couple of weeks away according to presser FYI 

Thanks

[DemonLad5 1,637]

28 minutes ago, SFebey said:

No chance mate, still a couple of weeks away according to presser FYI 

Viney hopefully round 8

[Chook 14,388]

It'll be good when Trac comes back in too. One more to switch through mid and up front.

[Demon Dynasty 15,186]

2 hours ago, juzzk1d said:

Out: Weideman, ANB

In: Pedo, Petracca.

You have my vote Juzz although i would play whoever is in best form out of Pedders & T Smith.  With Smith having 31 possessions on the weekend he would get the nod there.

Pedders bringing a stack more experience and size.

Having said that Weids will go round again as it appears almost certain the FD have stamped both  Smith's & Pedder's papers (unless Weids goes down with an injury or suspension).  They could kick 5 goals in 3 successive matches and still not get a call up me thinks.

Hunt probably gets another go at redemption rather than chopping / changing but would want to show some big improvement in form against the Saints.  Had an ugly day along with Weids (his two clunkers about the only exception).  Was Hunt injured early or something?

[Damo 2,969]

It would be brave to keep blooding Weid when we desperately need to win the next 3. But we have a policy of giving at least 2-3 games to young players. Id love to see Bull Smith and Tracc in for Weids and Tyson. Tyson must have used his credits but maybe they are waiting for Jack Viney. IMO ANB and Harmes still have a life or two left as well, to play into form. If Hogan is out rested, then Smith is a real chance. Im still keen on Pedo but understand those that say he isnt the future.

[Pennant St Dee 11,241]

Hogan will be managed carefully. Big guy doing a power of work and this will be our 3rd game in 11 days.

We will have a couple of changes based on that one would think

[SFebes 4,692]

Got to keep playing Weid now, get games into him now that he’s starting to clunk some marks, any week now he’ll have a breakout game based on those marks today. A good block of games coming up for him to build confidence. 

[puntkick 325]

Omac was everybodeys chopping block on here not so long ago

I'll back the Weid to go the same way given half the chance

[jumbo returns 6,484]

9 hours ago, jacey said:

I thought Hogan tmac n weid trio worked.

Too big to play all three in fwd 50 but Hogan, tmac take turns in the midfield n tmac  n weid to take turns in ruck.

Like the balance 

 

Had to read your post several times to decipher it

Got it now

And, I agree

[rjay 23,849]

9 hours ago, Rusty Nails said:

Pedders bringing a stack more experience and size.

Having said that Weids will go round again as it appears almost certain the FD have stamped both  Smith's & Pedder's papers (unless Weids goes down with an injury or suspension).  They could kick 5 goals in 3 successive matches and still not get a call up me thinks.

Beating a dead horse there 'Rusty'.

My opinion after he was dropped was that we wouldn't see Pedders again barring major injury. He is not an AFL level forward & his trump card as a mobile ruck had taken a turn for the worse, he'd lost his mojo.

Don't agree with you on Smith either, his papers are not stamped. They've moved him to a different role and it looks to be working. I think we could see him at AFL level maybe as early as next week depending on how Trac & hogan pull up.

[spirit of norm smith 12,833]

In. Petracca

out. Vince (rested)

[monoccular 16,009]

10 hours ago, jacey said:

I thought Hogan tmac n weid trio worked.

Too big to play all three in fwd 50 but Hogan, tmac take turns in the midfield n tmac  n weid to take turns in ruck.

Like the balance 

 

I too was concerned that playing all three forward (and Max going down deep at times too) would mean that they would get in each other’s way, but it was rare to find more than two in F50.

Seemed to work well, and Weed certainly gained in confidence as the match went on.

[shorty 233]

TMac the new Jim Stynes✔

Weeds ✔

Spargo ✔

Fritz ✔

Lever✔

Jetta ✔

Harmes grab ball handball to anyone ✔ KISS

In :Petracca

Out: ANB 

 

 

 

 

Edited April 29, 2018 by shorty

[Guest]

The Bear, as much as he got the absolute best out of himself, is probably done.

I'm not sure if Jesse needs the protection that he (or Chris Dawes) provided anymore. He has well and truly established himself. 

I have been his biggest fan but I reckon he stays in the Magoos. Give Weed a decent stretch as his current body shape doesn't have me petrified of him playing in the ruck or in bursts at CHF.

If ANB is covering all the ground they say he is covering, he must be running around like a headless chook. He goes out for Tracc.

I also hope that Tracc has given one of his bloody dogs away.

Edited April 29, 2018 by Colin B. Flaubert

[chook fowler 18,170]

I’d play Tracs dog

[Demon Dynasty 15,186]

1 hour ago, rjay said:

Beating a dead horse there 'Rusty'.

My opinion after he was dropped was that we wouldn't see Pedders again barring major injury. He is not an AFL level forward & his trump card as a mobile ruck had taken a turn for the worse, he'd lost his mojo.

Don't agree with you on Smith either, his papers are not stamped. They've moved him to a different role and it looks to be working. I think we could see him at AFL level maybe as early as next week depending on how Trac & hogan pull up.

Probably Rjay.  I agree the FD has apparently gone all in on Weids.

I don't care who they pick from the 3 as long as they're in form and performing their role effectively.

It might come down to the fact that none of them are up to it.

If we want to play finals we can hardly afford  to carry any players on the premise they are a likely prospect if we just get enough games into them.

The Hawks haven't had the success they've had by folowing that line.  One or two of their debutants against the Saints the other night have been waiting / developing in the McGoos since 2014

 

Edited April 29, 2018 by Rusty Nails