WELCOME TO THE MELBOURNE FOOTBALL CLUB - STEVEN MAY

[Binmans PA 25,867]

I'd rather play me at full back. The bloke is so overrated. Big bloke but soft.

[Lord Travis 10,129]

He’s dropped off big time in the past 1-2 years. Whether that’s the poor environment he’s stuck in or him as player losing struggling I’m not sure. 

Not sure he’s the best target for us now, despite our inexperienced key defensive depth.

[spirit of norm smith 12,828]

Absolutely take May for Tyson and JKH 

[Demon Disciple 10,882]

1 hour ago, spirit of norm smith said:

Absolutely take May for Tyson and JKH 

no way the suns would do that deal SONS.

[deelete my account 1,194]

1 hour ago, Demon Disciple said:

no way the suns would do that deal SONS.

Would have to be Tyson, Frost and a 2nd or 3rd round pick i'd imagine? But maybe we're still raffling duds in their eyes. I think we'd then go in with MAY on the best forwards, OMAC on 2nd best and Lever on the third man like with Adelaides defence in 2017. And play Oscar in the VFL if no matchup. Lewis retires and makes way for Salem or sticks it out on rotation. Jetta on crumber. Hibberd and Hunt off half back. I like it.

Edited July 4, 2018 by John Demonic

[DeleteUser 638]

6 hours ago, John Demonic said:

Would have to be Tyson, Frost and a 2nd or 3rd round pick i'd imagine? But maybe we're still raffling duds in their eyes. I think we'd then go in with MAY on the best forwards, OMAC on 2nd best and Lever on the third man like with Adelaides defence in 2017. And play Oscar in the VFL if no matchup. Lewis retires and makes way for Salem or sticks it out on rotation. Jetta on crumber. Hibberd and Hunt off half back. I like it.

Would it be fair to say that a final decision needs to be made on Frosty once and for all before that happens? And by that I mean, play him for the rest of the year. Give him a chance.

[stevethemanjordan 6,952]

1 hour ago, timbo said:

Would it be fair to say that a final decision needs to be made on Frosty once and for all before that happens? And by that I mean, play him for the rest of the year. Give him a chance.

Give Frost a chance? 

He's been given a chance in almost every position possible on the football field. 

Unfortunately for him, (and fortunately for us watching) his weaknesses won't allow him to be a consistent AFL player. 

[DeleteUser 638]

5 minutes ago, stevethemanjordan said:

Give Frost a chance? 

He's been given a chance in almost every position possible on the football field. 

Unfortunately for him, (and fortunately for us watching) his weaknesses won't allow him to be a consistent AFL player. 

Sure, but he has by some accounts acquitting himself reliably in the 2s.

So...do we take the view he may have improved.

In any case, what's the other option....

[Deemania since 56 6,118]

On 5/22/2017 at 12:07 PM, Dr. Gonzo said:

Didn't Hurley recommit to the Bombers last year? Pretty sure he's tied up 

There is something interesting in that discussion on Hurley. Very interesting. Almost a left-wing conversation.

[KingDingAling 3,589]

Now we have Lever, I think May would be a good get. GC would want too much though. They cannot afford to lose May. Their franchise hinges on being competitive at some point (soon). They need to sign Lynch and keep May.

[Dr. Gonzo 22,384]

22 hours ago, spirit of norm smith said:

Absolutely take May for Tyson and JKH 

Can we give them Wagner too?

[Watts Jurrah Dunn? 735]

May is a contracted captain of another club. We just overpaid for Lever as though it would fix all our defensive issues and now can't burn a 3rd first rounder on May. Our midfield is terribly unbalanced and we can't spend another 1st rounder on the backline.

Jordan Roughead as a free agent would provide a 200cm 105kg key defensive option and genuine ruck depth if Gawn went down. I appreciate he's not quite a full back and not quite a ruckman, but we desperately need some mature bodies and extra height back there. Oscar is always 2 years away from having the necessary strength, and it seems there is no competition for his spot given the club has banished Frost. Roughead would be a much better free hit for us than coughing up a first rounder for May.

 

Edited July 5, 2018 by Watts Jurrah Dunn?

[Wiseblood 24,636]

22 minutes ago, Watts Jurrah Dunn? said:

We just overpaid for Lever

 

No, we didn't.  Seriously, we didn't.  

[WERRIDEE 5,198]

Does this mean the end of Oscar? He's had a couple of ordinary weeks but overall he has had a good year. Persist with Oscar and hope Lever can comeback somewhere near his best we need a running half back or 2 any out there?

[DV8 2,271]

3 hours ago, KingDingAling said:

Now we have Lever, I think May would be a good get. GC would want too much though. They cannot afford to lose May. Their franchise hinges on being competitive at some point (soon). They need to sign Lynch and keep May.

I think they're in a position to have to trade unhappy players,,,, for some 'mature leaders', and other mature GOF's...

They need leaders, like we need pace.

What they'd give for a Nathan Jones up there.

They need leaders...  quality.

 

[puntkick 325]

1 hour ago, WERRIDEE said:

Does this mean the end of Oscar? He's had a couple of ordinary weeks but overall he has had a good year. Persist with Oscar and hope Lever can comeback somewhere near his best we need a running half back or 2 any out there?

A few people have difficulty with Oscar and Oskar !

[stevethemanjordan 6,952]

6 hours ago, WERRIDEE said:

Does this mean the end of Oscar? He's had a couple of ordinary weeks but overall he has had a good year. Persist with Oscar and hope Lever can comeback somewhere near his best we need a running half back or 2 any out there?

No, obviously not. He is a young and developing player. 

However, it's the only line we have that lacks depth, quality and experience. And it's remained that way since Dunn left. 

Frost, Keilty and Petty are not depth yet as we saw with Petty. Two of them are untried and Frost is a mistake ridden athlete who is the furthest thing from the word 'consistency' one could think of. 

The fact we don't have a mature body with either experience at AFL level or the level under is a serious oversight by Goodwin and the recruiting team. 

You look at Weideman VS Oscar McDonald and compare the way in which they've been handled over their careers. One has been made to play out of necessity rather than form. The other one is in his third year and has been dropped again after one poor game due to depth and talent. Weideman was a top end pick. Oscar a pick in the 50's.

It doesn't make sense to me. It should be our priority over the off season along with diversifying our midfield mix. 

You get rid of Frost, Tyson and Bugg over the off season and bring in May, Gaff and a half forward who is quick, skilled and pressures and watch our team transform. 

 

 

 

[Watts Jurrah Dunn? 735]

9 hours ago, Wiseblood said:

No, we didn't.  Seriously, we didn't.  

We gave up two first rounders for him and they say this years top 20 is exceptional.

We have gaping holes in the midfield, which is where games are won and lost.

Lever nominated the Dees so we held the power.

We massively overpaid for a guy that does not fix our problems.  He is a 'nice to have'.  Midfielders that can run and kick are a 'need'.

[chook fowler 18,159]

Last time I watched him play he looked lost and lazy - and very slow

[SFebes 4,692]

4 minutes ago, chook fowler said:

Last time I watched him play he looked lost and lazy - and very slow

The whole side does, they don't want to be there.

[Wiseblood 24,636]

1 hour ago, Watts Jurrah Dunn? said:

We gave up two first rounders for him and they say this years top 20 is exceptional.

We have gaping holes in the midfield, which is where games are won and lost.

Lever nominated the Dees so we held the power.

We massively overpaid for a guy that does not fix our problems.  He is a 'nice to have'.  Midfielders that can run and kick are a 'need'.

He does fix our problems.  Our backline was on fire before he went down, and that was due in large part to his leadership, footy IQ and footy skills.  You are selling the bloke short.

As for this years top 20 being 'exceptional' - we've all heard that before.  Our first rounder this year still has every chance of being around about the 11-12 mark, which isn't superb by any stretch.  The last 'super draft' that everyone refers to from 2001 had far more misses than hits.

If you take out Judd, Ball and Hodge as the Top 3, an area we wouldn't have been picking in anyway, from picks 4 through to 30 only Bartel (#8), Dal Santo (#13), James Kelly (#17) and Steve Johnson (#24) could be considered gun picks.  There are a heap of no name players who did nothing with their careers.  After pick 30 you had guys like Sam Mitchell, Leigh Montagna, Dane Swan (pick #58!), Jarrad Waite andBrian Lake (#71) all taken in the second round and beyond.  They can talk it all up all you like, but I think having what is considered a strong Top 20 works in our favour.  Jason Taylor has a proven track record of securing talent later in the draft and I'd back him in to do so again.

We didn't overpay at all for Lever.  We paid market value for a bloke with 50 games under his belt and almost AA selection in his first few seasons in the game.

[CatFishPig 434]

17 minutes ago, Wiseblood said:

He does fix our problems.  Our backline was on fire before he went down, and that was due in large part to his leadership, footy IQ and footy skills.  You are selling the bloke short.

As for this years top 20 being 'exceptional' - we've all heard that before.  Our first rounder this year still has every chance of being around about the 11-12 mark, which isn't superb by any stretch.  The last 'super draft' that everyone refers to from 2001 had far more misses than hits.

If you take out Judd, Ball and Hodge as the Top 3, an area we wouldn't have been picking in anyway, from picks 4 through to 30 only Bartel (#8), Dal Santo (#13), James Kelly (#17) and Steve Johnson (#24) could be considered gun picks.  There are a heap of no name players who did nothing with their careers.  After pick 30 you had guys like Sam Mitchell, Leigh Montagna, Dane Swan (pick #58!), Jarrad Waite andBrian Lake (#71) all taken in the second round and beyond.  They can talk it all up all you like, but I think having what is considered a strong Top 20 works in our favour.  Jason Taylor has a proven track record of securing talent later in the draft and I'd back him in to do so again.

We didn't overpay at all for Lever.  We paid market value for a bloke with 50 games under his belt and almost AA selection in his first few seasons in the game.

Spot on

[CatFishPig 434]

So would this bloke be on our radar? 

[Ethan Tremblay 28,276]

Pass. Poor attitude, overrated and doesn’t pass the no DH test. 

Edited July 30, 2018 by Ethan Tremblay

[old dee 22,799]

On 7/5/2018 at 11:17 PM, Wiseblood said:

No, we didn't.  Seriously, we didn't.  

Right now we did Wiseblood he cannot play till mid next year.