My 3 word player analysis v Carlton

[joeboy 2,772]

Jones - courageous and inspiring

Viney - troublesome decision making

Hogan - an important presence

Salem - prolific and composed

Watts - last quarter heroics

Petracca - not his best

Lewis - slow and indecisive 

Brayshaw - some handy cameos

Gawn - probably broke even

Tyson - prolific but wasteful

Oliver - genius at large

Stretch - determined and effective

Melksham - tentative but handy

Hannan - was almost good

T.McDonald - quiet but reliable

O.McDonald - no glaring errors

Weideman - some important touches

Hunt - exciting but limited

Neal- Bullen - was rarely noticed

Garlett - most dangerous forward

Jetta - solid all game

Harmes - disposal was problematic

[Akum 2,660]

Thought T-Mac was very good.

The reason that Weitering had so little influence was that he concentrated almost entirely on keeping T-Mac out of marking contests.

[martin 727]

Well spoken. Thought T Mac was better than that.Hannan a brief last quarter cameo. Could be back at Casey next week.

[rufus 916]

What's the go with Jetta. Is it a low 'football iq' or is he under instruction to do differently to everyone else by making sure he walks back from the mark as slowly as possible and ensure he slows down the play as much as he possibly can when he gets the ball through a mark or free. Needs to show some urgency when he has the ball...at least to make the opposition players have to be more active.

[praha 10,270]

Jones - Great captain's game.

Viney - Bad captain's game.

Hogan - Found ways to influence

Salem - Game saving performance

Watts - Inconsistent yet driving

Petracca - Typical learning game

Lewis - Bettered by Youth

Brayshaw - Might Lack Confidence

Gawn - Standard Ruck Performance

Tyson - Grossly Understated Influence

Oliver - Brownlow Medal Leader

Stretch - Becoming Increasingly Reliable

Melksham - Great In Air

Hannan - Worked To Influence

T.McDonald - Good Defensive Game

O.McDonald - Solid Physical Performance

Weideman - Powerful Last Quarter

Hunt - Disposal Hurt Influence

Neal- Bullen - Some Handy Touches

Garlett - Game's Best Forward

Jetta - Rock Solid Defender

Harmes - Satisfactory Game Back

[dimmy 1,114]

Jetta: worth his weight in gold

Salem : Ripper game, getting accustomed to pace of play-> excellent disposal

Oscar & Tom ,Nev: Basis of solid/VG backline

Jack W : the brains in the place

Jack V struggles to make decisions in space (good in close though)

[DeeSpencer 23,103]

41 minutes ago, rufus said:

What's the go with Jetta. Is it a low 'football iq' or is he under instruction to do differently to everyone else by making sure he walks back from the mark as slowly as possible and ensure he slows down the play as much as he possibly can when he gets the ball through a mark or free. Needs to show some urgency when he has the ball...at least to make the opposition players have to be more active.

Personally I'd accept some slow plays over the headless chook stuff the rest of the defenders go with. He's got a lovely step and hits his targets when moving. Doesn't rack up the ball or spread quickly but a few others could be far more patient.

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

45 minutes ago, rufus said:

What's the go with Jetta. Is it a low 'football iq' or is he under instruction to do differently to everyone else by making sure he walks back from the mark as slowly as possible and ensure he slows down the play as much as he possibly can when he gets the ball through a mark or free. Needs to show some urgency when he has the ball...at least to make the opposition players have to be more active.

There was one particularly bad instance where Jetta did this and it resulted in a Carlton shot on goal.

However, he is by no means the worst as this is something that I have been banging on about for years with the whole team.  I'm amazed that with so many coaches that it still a regular occurrence.

[CityDee 738]

Lewis was very important and stood up when it counted , it aint always pretty. 

[Deemented Are Go! 3,602]

MFC - Out Of Jail

[picket fence 15,097]

O MAC Much better performance

T Mac Much better again

Petracca  Improving with confidence

Viney Take first OPTION

[spirit of norm smith 12,886]

10 minutes ago, picket fence said:

O MAC Much better performance

T Mac Much better again

Petracca  Improving with confidence

Viney Take first OPTION

agree with all these comments.

 Captain Jack was poor. Needs a class in decision making. 100% guts. 100% heart. 100% grunt. 25% footy smarts. 5% right foot disposal. 

[Bring-Back-Powell 13,125]

27 minutes ago, Deemented Are Go! said:

MFC - Out Of Jail

I thought we tried to break into jail but Carlton are so bad they didn't let us.

[Earl Hood 5,788]

39 minutes ago, CityDee said:

Lewis was very important and stood up when it counted , it aint always pretty. 

Yes I will pay that but at times he looked slow and again produced some un Hawthorn like turnovers by foot but yes he fought well in the clinches. My wife is a Hawks supporter and reports that Gibson looks to be cooked after two games. Amazing how a well oiled machine like the Hawks when it is flying as a unit can cover the individual weaknesses of aging players, until last year of course when they went out in straight sets. Not sure how JL is going to travel throughout this year. Fingers crossed 

[Demon Disciple 10,921]

47 minutes ago, Deemented Are Go! said:

MFC - Out Of Jail

MFC - 2 and 0

[Ron Burgundy 8,584]

50 minutes ago, Earl Hood said:

Yes I will pay that but at times he looked slow and again produced some un Hawthorn like turnovers by foot but yes he fought well in the clinches. My wife is a Hawks supporter and reports that Gibson looks to be cooked after two games. Amazing how a well oiled machine like the Hawks when it is flying as a unit can cover the individual weaknesses of aging players, until last year of course when they went out in straight sets. Not sure how JL is going to travel throughout this year. Fingers crossed 

He'll travel very well.

 

[Dees2014 2,377]

7 hours ago, CityDee said:

Lewis was very important and stood up when it counted , it aint always pretty. 

Yes, and hitting targets consistently is not his greatest strength. Frustratingly so actually. Having said that though he does provide invaluable on field leadership for such a young group, and I suspect has been very influential in the last two games in getting us across the lines, when in past years we may not have.

it will be interesting to see how his role evolves over the next three years as our young guns mature...

[Canplay 573]

With Lewis it was good coaching from Bolton. He put an offensive tagger in Curnow (aerobic beast) with the instruction to run Lewis off his feet -  I think that made him look slow as he was absolutely spent. 

I watched him in packs and he's got a great knack at hurting blokes, excellent at positioning team mates with instructions and when hunt blazed at goal from boundary instead of centreing ball Lewis gave him a great spray  - all priceless attributes.

[Farmer 683]

Watching the replay last night, I realised just how important was T McD. And, on the face of it, Hogan has had a poor game, but he actually played well.

i thought Harmes was tough at it, marked well, and I hope he retains his place.

 

 

[ArtificialWisdom 3,847]

3 hours ago, Farmer said:

Watching the replay last night, I realised just how important was T McD. And, on the face of it, Hogan has had a poor game, but he actually played well.

i thought Harmes was tough at it, marked well, and I hope he retains his place.

 

 

Hogans efforts off the ball in the first 2 games have been fantastic. Hope he keeps it up, he isnt gonna score heavily each week, If he had slotted his chance in the 3rd then it would have been a good game for him.

[Akum 2,660]

16 hours ago, Earl Hood said:

Yes I will pay that but at times he looked slow and again produced some un Hawthorn like turnovers by foot but yes he fought well in the clinches. My wife is a Hawks supporter and reports that Gibson looks to be cooked after two games. Amazing how a well oiled machine like the Hawks when it is flying as a unit can cover the individual weaknesses of aging players, until last year of course when they went out in straight sets. Not sure how JL is going to travel throughout this year. Fingers crossed 

He had to play out of position in defence to cover for Vince, and I wonder if he just feels more at home in the middle or forward of centre. When he realised he was going to be tagged by someone as capable as Curnow, he realised the best thing was to change his game to keep Curnow away from the ball as much as possible, and around stoppages he just tried to block for the likes of Clarry & Tyson. That would be something completely new to our mids, who rarely if ever seem to block for each other, like every other team's mids do.

[Akum 2,660]

5 hours ago, Farmer said:

Watching the replay last night, I realised just how important was T McD. And, on the face of it, Hogan has had a poor game, but he actually played well.

i thought Harmes was tough at it, marked well, and I hope he retains his place.

 

 

Bolded part well put. Hogan's work inside 50 was putrid, but everywhere else he was very good indeed.

22 possies & 10 marks, but only one of those marks was inside 50 (must have been the one he missed from about 30m), and he must have dropped 3 or 4 relative sitters that he got both hands to.

[Satyriconhome 9,982]

18 hours ago, rufus said:

What's the go with Jetta. Is it a low 'football iq' or is he under instruction to do differently to everyone else by making sure he walks back from the mark as slowly as possible and ensure he slows down the play as much as he possibly can when he gets the ball through a mark or free. Needs to show some urgency when he has the ball...at least to make the opposition players have to be more active.

Low football IQ, that's only demonstrated on Demonland

If Nev has the opportunity to play on quickly he does, yesterday there weren't many opportunities to do that

Edited April 3, 2017 by Satyriconhome

[nutbean 8,837]

4 minutes ago, Satyriconhome said:

Low football IQ, that's only demonstrated on Demonland

If Nev has the opportunity to play on quickly he does, yesterday there weren't many opportunities to do that

Of all our backline players, he is the one I feel most relaxed with when the ball is in his hands. Played the loose for a lot of the game and looked very safe getting to the right spots to take uncontested marks. Plays on when he can or holds it up if he has to. 

[Wrecker45 3,378]

On 4/2/2017 at 7:59 PM, Deemented Are Go! said:

MFC - Out Of Jail

Jordan Lewis - Go directly to jail. Do not pass go.