MATCH PREVIEW AND TEAM SELECTION - Round 15

[Demonland 64,494]

RED ALERT by The Oracle

This could only happen to Melbourne.

Last Sunday, St. Kilda which had hitherto won just four games this season played a game against Essendon which was also on the same number of wins. The Bombers started as slight favourite and produced a performance that was so monumentally pathetic that it has to rank up there with the phenomenon known as "186" that was visited upon the Melbourne Football Club in 2011. After all, Geelong which inflected that defeat on the Demons went on to win the flag that year while the Saints who vanquished the Bombers at Etihad Stadium last weekend were not long ago considered wooden spoon favourite.

They were so limp that they allowed the young Saints 141 more possessions, 23 more inside 50s, double the number of marks on the day (142 marks to 71) and effortless goal after effortless goal and in light of this, their 110-point loss, the seventh worst in their entire history was their equivalent of "186". The only difference was that the Essendon Board didn't sack the coach.

Then came the news that Essendon skipper Jobe Watson has been ruled out for the rest of the season with a shoulder injury to join a swag of other household names at Bomberland sitting on the sidelines. Names like Paul Chapman (groin - 1-2 weeks), Adam Cooney (hamstring - 2 weeks), Tom Bellchambers (foot - 8 weeks), Travis Colyer (foot - 6-8 weeks), Jake Carlisle (ankle - 4-6 weeks) and the wonderful Orazio Fantasia (groin - 1-2 weeks). And the oldest man in the game, Dustin Fletcher who was in the game long before many current day competitors surfaced in their maternity wards has been missing for several weeks since he played his 400th AFL game.

So the Bombers appear to be at their lowest ebb at the very same time when they face the Demons. They are so down in the dumps that the betting agencies have installed Melbourne as the favourite to win this week's game at the G and that's where the red flag comes into contention.

When, in recent history, has Melbourne ever won a game starting as the favourite?

Oh you might say that the Melbourne of 2015 is a different team to that of years gone by - that it's been competitive without actually winning more games than, say last year when it had the same number of wins at this stage of the journey. But let's not forget that Essendon still occupies one position higher by dint of its superior percentage (admittedly only by 1.6%).

But how different is Melbourne right at this minute to the Melbourne of the past?

Much was made of the fact that the team introduced seven new faces for the opening game of the season to go with some of the young up and comers introduced in the past year or so. I was contemplating this very thing in the early moments of last Saturday night's game in Darwin. Of the "seven", only Jeff Garlett and Jesse Hogan were still on the ground, the latter returning after missing a game through hamstring soreness. Where were the rest of the magnificent seven?

Angus Brayshaw (subbed off with a neck injury after just two minutes);
Sam Frost (missing since round three with a broken toe);
Heritier Lumumba (foot);
Ben Newton (at Casey coming back from concussion);
Aaron Vandenberg (out for a month with a hamstring injury)

And where were those young guns with promise who were there for that round 1 victory over the Suns?

Jay Kennedy-Harris (at Casey after recovering from a groin injury);
Dean Kent (missing since Anzac Day eve with a hamstring injury); and
Christian Salem (also missing with a hammy first incurred two months ago and still 3 weeks away).

All on top of that season-ending knee injury to Christian Petracca incurred back in February.

This all suggests that the team hasn't changed much, that Saturday's game looms as the battle between the Norm Smith curse and the ASADA curse and the red flag has been well and truly raised.

THE GAME Essendon v Melbourne at the MCG Saturday, 11 July, 2015 at 1.40pm.

HEAD TO HEAD

Overall Essendon 127 wins Melbourne 81 wins 2 draws

At the MCG Essendon 64 wins Melbourne 45 wins 1 draw

The last five meetings Essendon 1 win Melbourne 4 wins

The Coaches Hird 0 wins Roos 0 wins

MEDIA

TV - Fox Footy Channel at 1.30pm (live)

RADIO - Triple M 3AW SEN ABC ABC Grandstand

THE BETTING

Essendon $2.35 to win Melbourne $1.59 to win

THE LAST TIME THEY MET

Melbourne 12.6.78 defeated Essendon 10.17.77 Round 13, 2014 at the MCG

This game produced one of the highlights of Melbourne's dismal 2014 season when a chain of disposals ended with a dramatic last minute mark and goal to Christian Salem to the Demons get up by the narrowest of margins against an inaccurate Essendon after trailing at one stage by 33 points. The lowlight was that it was the team's last win for 2014.

THE TEAMS

ESSENDON
​
B: Mark Baguley, Michael Hurley, James Gwilt
HB: Jackson Merrett, Jake Melksham, Ariel Steinberg, Martin Gleeson
C: Brent Stanton, Dyson Heppell, David Zaharakis
HF: Zach Merrett, Joe Daniher, Michael Hibberd
F: Patrick Ambrose, Cale Hooker, Jayden Laverde
FOLL: Shaun McKernan, Ben Howlett, Brendon Goddard
I/C: Alex Browne, Heath Hocking, Nick O'Brien, Jason Ashby, Shaun Edwards
EMG: Jonathan Giles, Elliott Kavanagh, Kyle Langford

IN: Patrick Ambrose, Jason Ashby, Alex Browne, Shaun Edwards, Heath Hocking, Jayden Laverde

OUT: Adam Cooney (hamstring), Courtenay Dempsey (omitted), Elliott Kavanagh (omitted), Jake Melksham (hamstring), Jobe Watson (shoulder)

NEW: Jayden Laverde (19, Western Jets)

MELBOURNE

B: Colin Garland, Lynden Dunn, Neville Jetta
HB: Jeremy Howe, Tom McDonald, Billy Stretch
C: Daniel Cross, Bernie Vince, Heritier Lumumba
HF: Alex Neal-Bullen, Chris Dawes, Jeff Garlett
F: Angus Brayshaw, Jesse Hogan, Jack Watts
Foll: Max Gawn, Nathan Jones, Jack Viney
I/C: Jay Kennedy-Harris, James Harmes, Aaron vandenBerg, Dom Tyson
EMG: Rohan Bail, Mark Jamar, Jack Fitzpatrick

IN: James Harmes, Jay Kennedy-Harris, Heritier Lumumba, Aaron vandenBerg

OUT: Rohan Bail, Matt Jones, Jake Spencer, Jimmy Toumpas (all omitted)

NEW: James Harmes (19, Dandenong Stingrays)

After team selection on Thursday night, two more Essendon players dropped out with injury - Heath Hocking (back) and Jake Melksham (hamstring). They were replaced by virtual unknowns in Jason Ashby and Shaun Edwards - even more bad news for the Demons who probably did zero homework on these blokes who will no doubt be the stars of the game

The game is being billed as the Clash for Cancer and the face of the game from Essendon’s point of view is healed cancer sufferer Adam Ramanauskas. Given the club’s recent history with the illness and the loss of former greats Jim Stynes and Sean Wight and our association with breast cancer awareness, it’s a great cause and worthy of our support.

The Essendon team appears to be falling apart with more injuries announced (as above) since Thursday night’s team selection. This is extremely problematic for Melbourne as the Bombers line up appears to be looking more and more like the one they one they put out on the field for the third NAB Challenge game back in March which was played at Etihad Stadium.

Remember that?

Essendon was coming off two shattering defeats including a pounding at the hands of St. Kilda (ahem). Melbourne had put in a fair performance in Fremantle against the Dockers and followed it up with a win against the Bulldogs in Ballarat. With the Bombers fielding a second rate side bereft of the remaining players among the Essendon 34 who were then awaiting the outcome of the AFL Tribunal decision on the ASADA doping charges, the Demons were raging favourites and a loss to this rag, tag depleted excuse for a football team was regarded as unthinkable.

The unthinkable happened.

So when the ball is bounced for the opening of the game at the MCG, let’s not labour under any delusions. It’s a danger game for the Demons.

Former Bomber Matthew Lloyd has said that he expects the ‘little things’ to tell a big story when the teams meet.

“I’m going to be looking at the first two or three stoppages, the effort around the ball, the contests, the pressure around the ball,” Lloyd said.

“I think that’s where it all stems from, your confidence comes from all the little things.

“The chases, the tackles, the smothers; and the rest just falls into line from there.”

The likelihood of rain, strong winds and possible hailstorms promises a scrappy match in difficult conditions and in those instances, it’s the more settled team that wins in the end.

I will therefore shun the curses, the red alerts, the history of Melbourne losing games when favourite and tip the Demons to finish on top by 22 points.

[Lucifers Hero 36,988]

(Also posted on the Changes vs Ess thread):

SEN just announced that Harmes has been elevated to the seniors list.

A sure hint that he will be selected!

Wish him well for his debut.

[Wadda We Sing 10,685]

Quite severe weather forecast including hail......I think some of the players will need to be careful in these conditions, such as Jack Viney who may mistake Joe Daniher for an icy pole and eat him. ...

[What 18,810]

Quite severe weather forecast including hail......I think some of the players will need to be careful in these conditions, such as Jack Viney who may mistake Joe Daniher for an icy pole and eat him. ...

Joe Daniher will be useless in the forecast conditons

lets hope he plays

[CBDees 3,162]

The fact that all the tipsters picked us has me worried as it is a bad omen. I preferred it when Garry Lyon and all his mates picked against us playing "away" (Geelong) and we made them all look stupid. At least it is another "away" game this Saturday so we have a good excuse if we lose (apart from the curse of the tipster)!

[Wadda We Sing 10,685]

The fact that all the tipsters picked us has me worried as it is a bad omen. I preferred it when Garry Lyon and all his mates picked against us playing "away" (Geelong) and we made them all look stupid. At least it is another "away" game this Saturday so we have a good excuse if we lose (apart from the curse of the tipster)!

Do we wear the clash jumper against essyflog?? I hate the clash jumper.

[Bluey's Dad 3,419]

THE BETTING

Essendon $2.35 to win Melbourne $1.59 to win

[monoccular 16,035]

Do we wear the clash jumper against essyflog?? I hate the clash jumper.

I hate it too, but we did ok in it vs the Druggists last year....just.

[Whispering_Jack 27,934]

Although the Essendon crowd is claiming that the sudden decline in form is related to the ASADA/WADA goings on, it's interesting to note that the Bombers have only introduced one new player to date in 2015. They've been relying on the same old, same olds - possibly to some extent because of limitations on recruiting with other clubs reluctant to trade for their players but a large measure of the problem seems to be the reluctance to introduce new blood to an aging list.

[Bluey's Dad 3,419]

Although the Essendon crowd is claiming that the sudden decline in form is related to the ASADA/WADA goings on, it's interesting to note that the Bombers have only introduced one new player to date in 2015. They've been relying on the same old, same olds - possibly to some extent because of limitations on recruiting with other clubs reluctant to trade for their players but a large measure of the problem seems to be the reluctance to introduce new blood to an aging list.

One other explanation might be found in Jobe's comments last week. He said something like "we're not as close to a premiership than we thought we were". They probably thought they didn't need to bring in too many new players for refreshing the list because they thought they were going for the cup.

[Wadda We Sing 10,685]

One other explanation might be found in Jobe's comments last week. He said something like "we're not as close to a premiership than we thought we were". They probably thought they didn't need to bring in too many new players for refreshing the list because they thought they were going for the cup.

Yup, that fits in with all the delusions..

[La Dee-vina Comedia 16,382]

The Neeld influence at Essendon is staring to shine through. At a media conference earlier today, James Hird reportedly said the following (about the media): "I don't read it, I don't watch it. I deal with what I have to and the rest goes over my head. It is what it is."

Edited July 9, 2015 by La Dee-vina Comedia

[Emerald 1,683]

With Neeld in the Bombers corner,we've got this one in the bag.

[Lucifers Hero 36,988]

This is a good game to debut Harmes as it looks like Ess are going to 'play the kids' and ease out their 'dad's army', injured or not (Watson, Fletcher, Cooney, Chapman, Wunderlich).

If its going to be kids vs kids then Stretch, ANB, Brayshaw (if fit), Hogan and JKH will make it a good battle.

The games we have won or done well in have been where the opp has not had a half decent ruckman, which Ess don't have...and our kids will smash theirs!

That would make it a Dees win

Edited July 9, 2015 by Lucifer's Hero

[Lucifers Hero 36,988]

If I ever I needed another reason to loathe Sheedy this is it: http://www.afl.com.au/news/2015-07-09/essendon-to-drop-three-or-four-for-melbourne-clash?utm_medium=RSS

Sheedy recalled one of the worst days of his coaching career: August 1, 1992.

"We got smashed by Hawthorn and, the next week, we played Melbourne and we won."

The 160-point loss to the Hawks was followed by a 32-point victory over the Demons, which remains the Bombers' best form reversal to this day.

You can just see them using this to rev up their players, trying to rub it in to us.

I just hope Roos uses that quote to rev up our players and make them 'eat Sheedy's words' so to speak.

[Seraph 1,713]

Harmes is in.

[dees189227 10,713]

Well we all know how Sheedy hates us. I bet he has the players revved up.

Great that Harmes will debut and he was a Melbourne supporter growing up.

Also good to see Vince and Jones have been his mentors.

I expect changes to be made and we go smaller. I expect Spencer could be dropped, only because I would prefer maxy in the wet conditions.

I hope Gus plays.

Here is the team

MELBOURNE

B: Colin Garland, Lynden Dunn, Neville Jetta

HB: Jeremy Howe, Tom McDonald, Billy Stretch

C: Daniel Cross, Bernie Vince, Heritier Lumumba

HF: Alex Neal-Bullen, Chris Dawes, Jeff Garlett

F: Angus Brayshaw, Jesse Hogan, Jack Watts

Foll: Max Gawn, Nathan Jones, Jack Viney

I/C: Jay Kennedy-Harris, James Harmes, Aaron vandenBerg, Dom Tyson

EMG: Rohan Bail, Mark Jamar, Jack Fitzpatrick

IN: James Harmes, Jay Kennedy-Harris, Heritier Lumumba, Aaron vandenBerg

OUT: Rohan Bail, Matt Jones, Jake Spencer, Jimmy Toumpas (all omitted)

NEW: James Harmes (19, Dandenong Stingrays)

Nice to see vanders back. These conditions will be perfect for him. Toump a surprise drop but maybe not for some.

[Lucifers Hero 36,988]

Aaron is also in back! So is JKH!

That Jimmy is not named as an emergency...must mean he has work to do...

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

Good changes all round.

[Biffen 12,321]

Much better team.

[What 18,810]

Awesome changes for us

Essendons changes are laughable.,,, Hird has no clue, and no balls.

[Wiseblood 24,636]

Can't complain with that at all. Toumpas has a future at the club but we are instantly a better side with these inclusions. Good moves all round.

[Nasher 33,047]

I wouldn't have dropped the Toump and kept him instead of JKH. I saw last week as a setback when he had been building on form and was hoping he'd get some benefit of the doubt. I can live with it though.

The rest are logical and expected changes.

Best of luck to Harmes.

[Young Dee 1,302]

Probably this years best changes - glad we dropped a tall in Spencer.

Would have liked to give Toump another week but we need to field the best team and JKH has proven to be more influential.

Still think we have a few too many inexperienced players with ANB, Stretch, Harmes, Bradshaw, Hogan etc

[dazzledavey36 48,682]

Great selections!

My tip either Vandenberg or Harmes will be the sub.