FAREWELL JEREMY HOWE

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

18 minutes ago, SaberFang said:

Howe certainly was 'armless yesterday.

[Undeeterred 2,816]

1 hour ago, PaulRB said:

Looks like Jeremy's transition to the Collingwood team is now complete.

Blind and gummy?

[Ethan Tremblay 28,288]

7 hours ago, Is Dom Is Good said:

It was fitting that his first game against us was similar to the majority of games he played for us.....

He will have the odd game where he has 20 touches and kicks 3 goals but these are too few and far between. Getting a guy like Kennedy who gives his all every game is so much more valuable than the odd highlight from Howe!

Can't compare the attitude of the two can you. Kennedy is assisting with setting the standard, Howe is happy to plod along in the background.

[jnrmac 18,914]

10 hours ago, It's Time said:

That'd be the 193cm Oxley?

Yeah, I was winging that one. Didn't work did it?

The others are midgets tho...

[Deestroy All 14,261]

1 hour ago, Clint Bizkit said:

Howe certainly was 'armless yesterday.

wtf. Once you see it...

[Ethan Tremblay 28,288]

He didn't really lose his forearm, it's just being covered by the ball.

[Redleg 37,474]

On 18 April 2016 at 5:37 PM, P-man said:

So you'd rather knock the 20 year old who gave his all and left when offered an unprecedented multi-million dollar contract, over a player who put in half hearted efforts and left to fulfill a dream of playing for his beloved Pies under the coach whose signature he had stashed in his wallet.

I'd rather knock the latter, personally.

Yes, I would rather knock the player who lied to a dying President and Club great, when asked in confidence if he was leaving, as was verified in writing, by the said now deceased great's widow. The player then continued to lie to his club and supporters. The player then lied even at Sydney airport, when he said he was just having a look around and then signed the next day with his new club, which immediately had ready advertising material which had been done weeks earlier.

No I don't blame him for going for the money, I blame him for his continual lying.

Jeremy Howe was forced out of Melbourne, because the club wouldn't agree to the contract he wanted, even after he reduced the amount sought, after his 7 years with us. He was being shopped by us to the Suns and other clubs. He chose the Pies for less money but because they were his team of support and he idolized the Coach as a player.

I know who I'd rather knock.

 

[P-man 13,154]

2 hours ago, Redleg said:

Yes, I would rather knock the player who lied to a dying President and Club great, when asked in confidence if he was leaving, as was verified in writing, by the said now deceased great's widow. The player then continued to lie to his club and supporters. The player then lied even at Sydney airport, when he said he was just having a look around and then signed the next day with his new club, which immediately had ready advertising material which had been done weeks earlier.

No I don't blame him for going for the money, I blame him for his continual lying.

Jeremy Howe was forced out of Melbourne, because the club wouldn't agree to the contract he wanted, even after he reduced the amount sought, after his 7 years with us. He was being shopped by us to the Suns and other clubs. He chose the Pies for less money but because they were his team of support and he idolized the Coach as a player.

I know who I'd rather knock.

 

I have little doubt a man of Jim's calibre would've gotten over that a long time ago. The fact it is such a sticking point with some supporters is a little weird to me.

The kid could've handled a situation he was totally unprepared for a little better, with smarter people advising him, but ultimately the Scully hate is fine in a theatrical sense but is generally out of whack. I'm so over him leaving, especially considering what we got in return.

Howe's gushing over all things Collingwood since his decision to go there has been embarrassing, and his efforts towards the end of his career at Melbourne even moreoso. Although having watched him in black and white, maybe laziness on the field is just in his DNA.

Anyhow, you have your villain, I have mine. Everybody wins.

Edited April 18, 2016 by P-man

[Biffen 12,298]

Guys like Howe,Goddard,Dal Santo,Griffen,Clark and Scully who ditch their clubs for success deserve a long nose dive.

Lake,Hale,Frawley and Burgoyne got their medals as top ups if we are honest.

Sea Howey-wouldn't want be ya!!

[nutbean 8,837]

Kennedy - works hard

Howe - lazy

[jnrmac 18,914]

Jeremy has done us a favour. We should thank him.

In fact we should thank $cully, Clark and $ylvia as well. They have all done us favours.

 

Edited April 18, 2016 by jnrmac

[Devil is in the Detail 880]

17 minutes ago, jnrmac said:

Jeremy has done us a favour. We should thank him.

In fact we should thank $cully, Clark and $ylvia as well. They have all done us favours.

 

Frawley? got us Brayshaw

[Slartibartfast 15,724]

13 hours ago, Redleg said:

Yes, I would rather knock the player who lied to a dying President and Club great, when asked in confidence if he was leaving, as was verified in writing, by the said now deceased great's widow.

Rather than knock Scully perhaps we should have paid more attention to him.  He left because we were a dysfunctional and unprofessional club run by a bunch of half wits who took us to depths rarely seen and he wanted better. Now there is a shooting offence.  He accepted a once in a lifetime offer to secure the future of his family and particularly his sister. What a shocking person.

He delivered us Hogan - I'm looking for the downside here.

His behaviour regarding leaving was no different to Ablett, Dangerfield and Franklin.  

Really, life is too short to carry on with this sort of stuff so long after the event.  It was a massive win for us.  The way you're going on Red you'll blame him for Jimmy's death soon.

[Redleg 37,474]

2 hours ago, Baghdad Bob said:

Rather than knock Scully perhaps we should have paid more attention to him.  He left because we were a dysfunctional and unprofessional club run by a bunch of half wits who took us to depths rarely seen and he wanted better. Now there is a shooting offence.  He accepted a once in a lifetime offer to secure the future of his family and particularly his sister. What a shocking person.

He delivered us Hogan - I'm looking for the downside here.

His behaviour regarding leaving was no different to Ablett, Dangerfield and Franklin.  

Really, life is too short to carry on with this sort of stuff so long after the event.  It was a massive win for us.  The way you're going on Red you'll blame him for Jimmy's death soon.

BB I don't bring this up, other than to answer another post about the habit of attacking former players, which I don't like, as I said in my post, with one notable exception. I gave my reasons for that and if you don't accept them, so be it.

You were wrong about the first reason you gave for his leaving, our club, it was purely the second, money.

His behaviour was totally different to the three players you named, they were up front in expressing that they could leave. Dangerfield did not go for money, as he was offered more to stay. Ablett and Franklin were offered huge amounts, but their clubs knew they were going and in fact prepared for it.

Our boy lied to us over and over again. As I said he even lied at Sydney Airport, where he said he was just going up for a look around and that afternoon was front and centre of their recruiting, having signed allegedly at the end of his first season with us, while he had a year to go on his contract with us, yet, with a CD already out, showing him in GWS jumper, which clearly had been done a few weeks or months earlier.

I am allowed to dislike the way he treated us. He is the only past player who has gone to another club, that I have booed on the field. That is my right.

I agree it was a massive win for us that he left.

I find your last sentence extremely disappointing and in poor taste.

That aside, hopefully we can catch up again soon, it has been too long.

Edited April 19, 2016 by Redleg

[nutbean 8,837]

2 hours ago, Baghdad Bob said:

 

His behaviour regarding leaving was no different to Ablett, Dangerfield and Franklin.  

 

Whilst I am more than happy with the outcome his behavior was completely different.

In fact the three you mention above actually have one thing in common - they said next to nothing in their final year.  None of them looked down the camera and said - "I want to be a one club player and have an expectation that that will be the case". None of them when straight out asked by the club president stared him down and lied ( in fact Ablett upset Bomber Thompson by refusing to say anything at all about his contract). None of them had their managers on National TV say  "if you are a Melbourne supporter I would have some reason for confidence" ( this was said by Lynch about Scully re-signing) - these comments and more were made after he apparently had already made arrangements to go. 

I have no problem with players moving for fortune or fame and that goes for Scully - I have no problem for players wanting to leave the cesspool of a club that was Melbourne during that time. It is how you do it.

I have moved on. I have no problem with players making lame excuses ( i want to see where the club is headed )  - I have nor problem with a player saying they want to test the FA market and I have no dislike for likes of Rivers, Frawley or Howe - they come they go. I have a problem with flat out liars and whilst I don't lose sleep over Scully I do take joy in him failing.

 

(maybe I have only partially moved on..)

[Blistering 490]

On 19 April 2016 at 1:22 PM, Baghdad Bob said:

Rather than knock Scully perhaps we should have paid more attention to him.  He left because we were a dysfunctional and unprofessional club run by a bunch of half wits who took us to depths rarely seen and he wanted better. Now there is a shooting offence.  He accepted a once in a lifetime offer to secure the future of his family and particularly his sister. What a shocking person.

He delivered us Hogan - I'm looking for the downside here.

His behaviour regarding leaving was no different to Ablett, Dangerfield and Franklin.  

Really, life is too short to carry on with this sort of stuff so long after the event.  It was a massive win for us.  The way you're going on Red you'll blame him for Jimmy's death soon.

Just for the record, the items highlighted were all part of the lie. The offer of huge money was made to Scully's connections a year before he left the club and there were lots of stories bandied about to justify his leaving by various people with various agendas. The start and end of the matter was that he was made an offer in October 2010 which he couldn't refuse which had the full backing of the AFL which was eager to get a marquee player for its fledgling club. The AFL made it impossible for Melbourne to match that offer. 

Scully and his connections could have handled the Melbourne end of things a lot better but we as a club cannot be blamed for not matching the ridiculous sum that he was offered - we could never have done so and to his credit Jimmy handled the situation perfectly.

[Yossarian 1,808]

So anyway, team...

 

[Mazer Rackham 14,968]

17 minutes ago, Blistering said:

Just for the record, the items highlighted were all part of the lie. The offer of huge money was made to Scully's connections a year before he left the club and there were lots of stories bandied about to justify his leaving by various people with various agendas. The start and end of the matter was that he was made an offer in October 2010 which he couldn't refuse which had the full backing of the AFL which was eager to get a marquee player for its fledgling club. The AFL made it impossible for Melbourne to match that offer. 

Scully and his connections could have handled the Melbourne end of things a lot better but we as a club cannot be blamed for not matching the ridiculous sum that he was offered - we could never have done so and to his credit Jimmy handled the situation perfectly.

Nor should we have matched it. He wasn't worth it at the time and events since have shown he hasn't earned it at GWS.

It would have thrown out our player payments and caused unrest amongst the other players.

It's one thing to pay a huge salary to an Ablett or a Buddy. But a Scully?

[Slartibartfast 15,724]

20 minutes ago, Blistering said:

Just for the record, the items highlighted were all part of the lie. The offer of huge money was made to Scully's connections a year before he left the club and there were lots of stories bandied about to justify his leaving by various people with various agendas. The start and end of the matter was that he was made an offer in October 2010 which he couldn't refuse which had the full backing of the AFL which was eager to get a marquee player for its fledgling club. The AFL made it impossible for Melbourne to match that offer. 

Scully and his connections could have handled the Melbourne end of things a lot better but we as a club cannot be blamed for not matching the ridiculous sum that he was offered - we could never have done so and to his credit Jimmy handled the situation perfectly.

What is your source?

[DeeZone 7,660]

We all loved Howe'y when he was soaring above the packs and taking those great spekkies even if he usually hand balled it off to no avail. We loved him because he made us feel good when we had little to smile about because he was our's. Now he is Their's and the love is gone. But not the memories!!!!

[bush demon 1,875]

On 4/18/2016 at 7:11 AM, Biffen said:

Guys like Howe,Goddard,Dal Santo,Griffen,Clark and Scully who ditch their clubs for success deserve a long nose dive.

Lake,Hale,Frawley and Burgoyne got their medals as top ups if we are honest.

Sea Howey-wouldn't want be ya!!

I like the sentiment, but where does Ronald Dale fit into this scenario? No lap of honour, no valedictory. Just woke up one morning in a Carlton jumper with threee thousand pounds in his pocket.

[Biffen 12,298]

1 minute ago, bush demon said:

I like the sentiment, but where does Ronald Dale fit into this scenario? No lap of honour, no valedictory. Just woke up one morning in a Carlton jumper with threee thousand pounds in his pocket.

The day my dad stopped following football.

But RDB was so good he dragged clubs to Flags on his own.

[juzzk1d 1,354]

 

[bush demon 1,875]

6 minutes ago, Biffen said:

The day my dad stopped following football.

But RDB was so good he dragged clubs to Flags on his own.

Would have tarnished his brand staying at Melbourne. You've just got to read Red Fox where Norm Smith resented Crompton playing out of position in GF, even though it won us the premiership. I think the club had become a weird place by mid-60's with too much success. 

[Blistering 490]

1 hour ago, Baghdad Bob said:

What is your source?

I made a number of statements and you didn't specify as to which you requested the source. The subject has been covered in detail over the years and, given the volume of the material, I'm not really prepared to go back to locate every piece of information that's been broadcast (any more than I think you would be prepared to do with respect to the things you claimed). However ...

(i) the story about Scully's connections negotiating with GWS as early as in October, 2010 (at the end of his debut season) was reported in the media a couple of months after the defection was announced and, as far as I'm aware, was not commented upon and therefore not disputed by the Scully camp, GWS or the AFL. The timing of the above agreement coincides roughly with Scully's ill-fated China trip which was the subject of a substantial amount of untrue scuttlebutt.

(ii) my uncle is a builder who used the services of Scully's father's roof tiling business for about 10 years until Scully Senior  sold out his share in the company in 2011 (several months before Tom announced he was leaving). Phil Scully told my uncle at the time Tom left the China trip why he had done so. The reason was personal and related to a serious family illness and had absolutely nothing to do with the scuttlebutt mentioned above and which were spread about a long time after the event.

Yes, so lies were told and I wonder why?