Todd Viney?

[Sir Why You Little 34,407]

Any idea how long Todd is contracted to the Dawks? He is one person we definately need back Home.

I am not suprised that Hawthorn have once again become mean & nasty again. It's also the way Todd played.

A true Hard Nut. The MFC needs Viney teaching our midfield

[deeflog 679]

The sooner he comes back to the club in any capacity the better. You are right WYL the hawks ahve become one of the toughest teams and im sure most of it would be put down to Viney

[Sir Why You Little 34,407]

The sooner he comes back to the club in any capacity the better. You are right WYL the hawks ahve become one of the toughest teams and im sure most of it would be put down to Viney

I was staggered at the Hawks Toughness last Saturday. That is what we have to aim for. Don't forget Clarkson & Viney played together for two years at the MFC. Both were Tough.

Priority Jimmy-Get Todd Back Home, Can we use our no. 1 Draft Pick!!!!!

[Mono 454]

The sooner he comes back to the club in any capacity the better. You are right WYL the hawks ahve become one of the toughest teams and im sure most of it would be put down to Viney

Heard a comment on Saturday that many of the hard nut Hawk mids were drafted while Brereton was in charge of Football dept - and he insisted on toughness being a criteria.

They certainly play with mongrel. Will be interesting to see if they control it against the cats. Last year they totally lost it against the kangas in the final they lost; 3? reports.

[Hannabal 4]

The sooner he comes back to the club in any capacity the better. You are right WYL the hawks ahve become one of the toughest teams and im sure most of it would be put down to Viney

Rubbish. They've been building this side of their game ever since the line in the sand game against Essendon a few years ago when Brereton fired them up in the rooms at half time. Vandenberg was a dud but he instilled this ethos as captain. Clarkson is a tough bugger as is Hardwicke. Viney is another part of the puzzle, but you do the others a disservice to give him the bulk of the credit.

[Sir Why You Little 34,407]

Heard a comment on Saturday that many of the hard nut Hawk mids were drafted while Brereton was in charge of Football dept - and he insisted on toughness being a criteria.

They certainly play with mongrel. Will be interesting to see if they control it against the cats. Last year they totally lost it against the kangas in the final they lost; 3? reports.

They won't give a stuff about getting reported on Saturday-I am tipping a very Brutal Game. If the Cats win Back to Back they will sure earn it. Luke Hodge set an example last week. Blood will be spilt just like the Classic of '89. (The Greatest game of Pure Aussie Rules i have ever witnessed) I Hope all of the MFC watch it closely.

[Red and Blue Flame 142]

not just viney- clarkson and hardwick were both tough nuts in their days

i wouldve chosen hardwick after bailey as the new melbourne coach

but agreed- get viney back to the club..his son might be playing there in 7 years or so

[Trisul 636]

Viney has been with the Hawks since the beginning of (the woeful) 2004 yes?

[Tony Tea 2,784]

Viney has been with the Hawks since the beginning of (the woeful) 2004 yes?

No.

Clarkson was appointed at the end of 2004.

[Mono 454]

not just viney- clarkson and hardwick were both tough nuts in their days

i wouldve chosen hardwick (after) before bailey as the new melbourne coach

....................

Me too. Apart from skill and talent (sic), MFC needs steel and hardness.

[Trisul 636]

No.

Clarkson was appointed at the end of 2004.

Funnily enough I wasn't trying to imply 2004 was Viney's fault, but that he has had control over the transition period.

While over-playing his role has occurred, so has under-playing.

[Dee tention 611]

Hawks are the bench mark now! Hardwick is a coach in waiting. Viney should be acquired by us immediately. Good mates with Clarko and would be sure he would want to go back to back with the Hawks. He will come back, just a matter of when!

[grazman 6,414]

He's still a massive unit, how'd you like to arm wrestle with him?

[Dee tention 611]

He's still a massive unit, how'd you like to arm wrestle with him?

Very Gary Ayre's like! Both big units. Conan and Hercules!

[dazzledavey36 48,643]

Viney aint massive he is fat! seen the man [censored] on him! by gosh

[grazman 6,414]

Very Gary Ayre's like! Both big units. Conan and Hercules!

Hercules didn't dye his hair though

[Sir Why You Little 34,407]

Hey Stynesy just get in his ear please "Todd come home soon" like a mantra. Viney is needed as much as our number one draft pick.

[H_T 2,941]

OUT: Williams?

In: VINEY

It could see us with momentum and crack the 30,000 barrier for members in 2009.

[Mono 454]

OUT: Williams

That will do for a start. Backs have come on, forwards shown a bit with little opportunity, rucks have come on.

Mids? Ratsh*t. WILLIAMS OUT. :angry:

Actually, the more I think about it, the more convinced I am. Crap delivery to forwards. No defensive pressure on opposition mids delivery. Every time our backs get it out, it comes back faster.

Our midfield is largely non-functional. Williams must go.

[Guest TheVoice]

Ahh yes, I remember the days of the bullocking number 12 wrestling the ball from a pack of mere mortals, leaving broken limbs and destruction in his wake.

Please come back toddy, we need your brutal, barbarianism ways in our wayward centre unit. Maybe you could mould a young brock, jones or moloney into a

younger version of you and transform our midfield into a much feared, bone crunching, machine much like yourself. Maybe Todd, with the help of stinger, could

inform our young men on how to aquire some half decent pipes like the ones they used to parade around back in the day.

[Guest Bozzie_Demons]

Did i miss Clarko forgetting to thank Todd? I'm sure he thank everyone else. Can someone confirm....

We all want Todd back! Campaign we should!

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

Rubbish. They've been building this side of their game ever since the line in the sand game against Essendon a few years ago when Brereton fired them up in the rooms at half time. Vandenberg was a dud but he instilled this ethos as captain. Clarkson is a tough bugger as is Hardwicke. Viney is another part of the puzzle, but you do the others a disservice to give him the bulk of the credit.

Agree. This thread suffers from a bad case of hype.

[H_T 2,941]

That will do for a start. Backs have come on, forwards shown a bit with little opportunity, rucks have come on.

Mids? Ratsh*t. WILLIAMS OUT. :angry:

Actually, the more I think about it, the more convinced I am. Crap delivery to forwards. No defensive pressure on opposition mids delivery. Every time our backs get it out, it comes back faster.

Our midfield is largely non-functional. Williams must go.

Agree. High^5. Fresh coat of paint and a bit of mongrel. I'd like the midfield to return to the vein of form when Ratten was assistant.

[Sir Why You Little 34,407]

Agree. This thread suffers from a bad case of hype.

Say what you like RR Todd Viney is needed back at Melbourne-I wanted him back way before the 2008 GF. We are soft.

[bjgc 0]

He will come back, just a matter of when!

When we sack Bailey so probably at the end of 2009.