Jump to content

chookrat

Members
  • Content Count

    1,151
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by chookrat

  1. I see your point. Its horrible the way the AFL have set it up where Carlton could be outside the best four teams from a win and % perspective and play in the GF while three teams above them miss out.
  2. I think Plough is right on this. If you finish third in your conference then you dont deserve the right to think about hypotheticals that you dont get to play a grand final because there are at least two teams that finished the regular season above you in your own conference. The farce we have now is that you could be the second top team in wins and percentage yet miss out on finals to Carlton with a win rate of 1/3 and percentage below 80%. The crossover finap would mean that Carlton would need to beat the second team in Conference A to play GF.
  3. Is it possible that the AFL did this on purpose so as to confuse us re their next move?
  4. chookrat

    Calling All MCC Members

    There might be correlation between stinginess and wealth
  5. chookrat

    Calling All MCC Members

    Any MCC member who claims they support Melbourne but won't by a membership is a bum
  6. chookrat

    Calling All MCC Members

    Why cab it when you can use limo service who will wait for you when game finishes
  7. chookrat

    Calling All MCC Members

    I met one a few weeks ago for a business venture and asked point blank if he had signed up as an MFC member and he said no. I told him our business interests would only progress if he signed up. He laughed and I asked why he was laughing and that I was serious.
  8. chookrat

    Richmond membership banner ads on Demonland

    Agree this is a farce. Ive bwen getting Volvo and Want Mature ads. Whats up with that??
  9. chookrat

    Dees Drawing the Logo

    Im furious, the players should be training and not drawing pictures and smiling
  10. chookrat

    Lyon's Plea to Petracca: Be Like Max

    Excuses are the meat of a lie wrapped in the skin of reason
  11. Well done Demonland admins. As a suggestion can send J-Money the link to the Jesse Hogan Trading thread as prereading for the interview and for him to pick his favourite 'mean tweets' to read aloud during the podcast?
  12. Can you ask what Peter thinks about the muppets on here that think they could negotiate trades better than Josh Mahoney and how they could best help next year? E.g.should they come down to the club and advise or do they serve the club best from behind their keyboards.
  13. chookrat

    Jason Taylor Resume

    The jury still out on Col Silvia to Freo trade which netted us Bernie Vince. A full preseason and Col could have been anything.
  14. chookrat

    Farewell Jesse Hogan

    You are a problem, scallywag
  15. chookrat

    Farewell Jesse Hogan

    Apparently we mighy be looking to trade Hogan who has said he is open to returning home to Perth if a mutually agreeable trade can be facilitated. Word is Freo would be the club but apparently their head of football is looking for featgers rather than improving their average list and being diffficult. My sources suggest a trade will either happen or it wont. Stay tuned.
  16. chookrat

    Farewell Jesse Hogan

    May simply trying to make sure GCS get value from trading him. Not onlike when Chip went to Hawthorn.
  17. Not sure im sold on KK as I cannot pronounce his name. Suggest we go after a Jack or a Smith.
  18. chookrat

    Farewell Jesse Hogan

    Mahoney could do the deal, shake Bells hands and say "Belly, go f_$k yourself"
  19. chookrat

    Farewell Jesse Hogan

    Fagan should fight Bell to settle the matter.
  20. chookrat

    Farewell Jesse Hogan

    I nominate Deestroy for post of the year!
  21. chookrat

    Farewell Jesse Hogan

    Can we have a competition where we nominate the most absurd posts in this thread and then ask Peter Jackson to read out the top ten for Wednesdays podcast?
  22. chookrat

    Farewell Jesse Hogan

    What if they throw in McCarthy as steak knives?
  23. chookrat

    Farewell Dom Tyson

    Dom was really important for our young side when he came over from GWS and was arguably our best inside mid. He showed alot of character to work back into form playing in a position he isnt ideally suited on the wing. Hope he plays alot of games with North over the next few years and finishes a 150-200 game player.
  24. chookrat

    Farewell Jesse Hogan

    What would Mitch Cleary know? The media are all over the place with this one and suggests that aside from Hogan, his Manager, Melbourne and Freo the rest of us are in the dark. I'd also suggest that Freo's 'official' offer is noise that means very little. One of four things will happen: 1. Jesse stays at Melbourne 2. Jesse is traded to Freo or another team, most likely in Perth 3. Jesse signs an extension to remain at Melbourne beyond next year. 4. Jesse retires
  25. chookrat

    Farewell Jesse Hogan

    Where has Jesse stated he wants to go to Freo. This is not fact, it is speculation. We have no idea what is driving this, whether it is Jesse wanting to go back to Perth or the club wanting him to declare where his future is this trade period.
×