Jump to content


  • Content Count

  • Joined

  • Last visited

Community Reputation

71 Excellent

About Melb-A-Toast

  • Rank

Recent Profile Visitors

The recent visitors block is disabled and is not being shown to other users.

  1. Melb-A-Toast

    Farewell Jesse Hogan

    I agree! At the time, I thought that Port played it really well, and I was expecting Watts to make us regret the move. I also wish Watts more success for the rest of his career, though not when he plays against Melbourne. Jesse has every reason to play a fantastic year at Melbourne, and then he can again consider his options as to whether he will return to Perth - hopefully with a medal or two.
  2. Melb-A-Toast

    Farewell Jesse Hogan

    I think that trade negotiations is about playing the long game. So if you negotiate really hard, or if you have a great coup, then you will have a reputation that will be harder to deal with in the future. So, being seen to be fair and reasonable provides more opportunities to do more deals in the future. If the List Management team is able to execute well, then the deal will look like a small loss at the first point, but a great success later down the track. Think Watts at 31.
  3. Melb-A-Toast

    2018 Player Reviews: # 12 Dom Tyson

    Tyson is a great ball winner, when playing on the ball. Does he think he has more time to get rid of the ball? He has also been compromised by trying to shrug tackles. These two aspects have caused turnovers. So if he eradicates these aspects, he will be a great win for North. At Melbourne he would have been getting less time in the middle, and his impact would continue to drop. I wish him well
  4. Melb-A-Toast

    2018 Player Reviews: # 2 Nathan Jones

    Nathan Jones has been stoic, and been the light for such a long time. For the last two years, I have seen him needing to play a different role (other than inside mid), and that has not helped him maintain his high standard. My main concern with him is his kicking efficiency for 40+ metre kicks. As he has been playing wing a fair bit, the long kick into the forward 50 is an incredibly important component of the arsenal. His short passes are very good, sometimes elite, and sometimes regretful... He has been an exceptional leader and great team mate. His work in media representing the club has been wonderful to see and hear. So to me the questions that remain: How long does he keep the co-captaincy? and how long does he want to? What is the best role for him? Wing, high half forward, midfield depth, or defence? He was probably carrying an injury towards the end of the season, as he didn't have the same impact I was expecting. His leadership on the field is only known by the coaching group and players, but Viney has surpassed him as an impact player/leader from an outsider's viewpoint. I truly hope that he has relevance and is impactful when we finally get the chance to win a grand final.
  5. Melb-A-Toast

    Demonland Podcast Featuring Peter Jackson (17/10)

    Question for Peter. Rather than do a wholesale clean out when you took the reins, there were some key people retained. What were the aspects of some of those people and did you redefine their roles/day to day functions significantly to suit the revised goals of the Club?
  6. Melb-A-Toast

    Jordan Lewis is absolutely cooked, never pick him again

    Nice post Mydee. Hysteria and diatribe are common however. We are a better team because of their significant contributions.
  7. Melb-A-Toast

    Lynden Dunn

    Yes. He was always positive even when Melbourne was at its lowest. Wish him well in his recovery. When Simon Goodwin said at the after match press conference "We are far from Dunn (done)" I was waiting for someone to comment - so now it is me! :-)
  8. Melb-A-Toast


    Just another relaxing win.
  9. Melb-A-Toast

    Allen Jakovich on The Front Bar (9/8)

    Yes. Anytime he can have a dig at Collingwood supporters it makes the story more enjoyable
  10. Melb-A-Toast

    Allen Jakovich on The Front Bar (9/8)

    That was fantastic. Love the last story of his view of Glen and he fighting and his mother arbitrating
  11. Melb-A-Toast


    Could be Tightrope
  12. Melb-A-Toast

    Nathan Jones' 250th.

    It would be fantastic if Lewis gets there, as it means that he is contributing well and the team is getting those benefits. It would be rather challenging for him to make it to 100 club games. Nathan Jones record will stand along very nicely with David Neitz, Melbourne and AFL Hall of Famer.
  13. Melb-A-Toast

    The Jack Viney made me cry thread

    Chris Judd just said, "He's so hard that when he does push ups, the Earth moves" Love it!
  14. Melb-A-Toast

    2018 AFL National Draft prospects: The next batch

    I believe that Xavier is nephew of Jamie.
  15. Melb-A-Toast

    Looking forward to the Free Agency & Trade Period

    James Morrison Dawes?