Jump to content


Life Member
  • Content count

  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won


whatwhatsaywhat last won the day on March 11 2017

whatwhatsaywhat had the most liked content!

Community Reputation

5,075 Excellent

About whatwhatsaywhat

Recent Profile Visitors

9,712 profile views
  1. whatwhatsaywhat

    Jason Taylor Resume

    eh? tyson, toumpas (failure), viney, oliver, brayshaw - all 'pure' mids and weideman is NOT a debacle
  2. whatwhatsaywhat


    i'd still go joel smith over wagner, but we shall see they might both come in given our lack of defender options now suffice to say, demonland whipping boys vince and lewis ain't being dropped
  3. whatwhatsaywhat

    Hibberd Ruled Out of Cats Clash with Quad

    yeah most quads are 6-8 stick a fork in him - his 2018 season is likely done
  4. whatwhatsaywhat

    Nic Nat and Max Gawn

    And that was a Gerard Healy special He stans for Nic
  5. whatwhatsaywhat

    Steven Silvagni and Carlton

    Thought he was simultaneously super defensive and aggressive It was not a good performance at all
  6. whatwhatsaywhat

    Pace Or Grunt

    Tyson over Hannan for me We were slaughtered at stoppages against Footscray and we’ll need an extra strong body moving through the middle as I’d expect Scott Selwood to go a hard tag on Oliver which we MAY be able to exploit by rolling him forward Viney has traditionally had a run with role with Joel S - does Harmes get first crack? What about Danger and Jesus? Not to mention Kelly and Duncan? Whole game is a battle of midfielders
  7. whatwhatsaywhat


    Narrow ground has been made narrower as a result of the Ziebell on LED fence injury which - in theory - should help our zone defence and cluster forward formation I’m not remotely confident but am mildly optimistic Hannan out for Tyson the only change I’d look at at this stage, and even that I’m on the fence over Puddy Tatts by 13 points
  8. whatwhatsaywhat

    Brent Harvey says we'll lose Jesse Hogan

    hogan's mum now lives in melbourne and he grew up going for the crows why on earth would he go back to wa now?
  9. whatwhatsaywhat

    Who else do we realistically target at season end?

    Most media has speculated we ‘might’ be interested in him as he’s a free agent and we have no first rounder to trade to being in a player (FWIW I tend to think he’s worth about what a Melksham or a Hibberd - or a Tyson? - might be worth, which is a mid to high second / low third round pick)
  10. whatwhatsaywhat

    Who else do we realistically target at season end?

    In order of my preference we have been ‘linked’ with the following so far this year: Gaff, Dahlhaus, Polec, Beams, Langdon, Taylor
  11. whatwhatsaywhat

    The Clarry Pass

    those burners into garlett and anb = sumptuous
  12. whatwhatsaywhat

    Round 17 Non MFC Games

    Can’t believe what I’m seeing... Come on you Shockers
  13. whatwhatsaywhat

    Round 17 Non MFC Games

    c'mon freo why'd trenners get dropped? i thought he was going okay
  14. whatwhatsaywhat

    Round 17 Non MFC Games

    cracking game
  15. whatwhatsaywhat

    Round 17 Non MFC Games

    i don't get how they'd go a game ahead of us; don't want that