Jump to content

joeboy

Life Member
  • Content count

    994
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    1

Everything posted by joeboy

  1. joeboy

    Petracca in a rut?

    The only issue in dropping him is that there are many others who are less value to the team and equally as unproductive: Hannan, Neal Bullen,Vince, Tyson, etc, etc. Where do you draw the line?
  2. Jones - unusually fumbled often Viney - brave and relentless T.McDonald - held second half Hannan - opportunistic but limited Melksham - was rarely sighted Petracca - overrated and disappointing Salem - lost under pressure T.Smith - little to enthuse Fritsch - classy and exciting Gawn - bravely fought alone Hogan - lost his way Neal-Bullen - was rarely noticed Brayshaw - brave and relentless Harmes - excellent tagging game Hibberd - surprisingly poor disposal Jetta - brave and important Lewis - calming but worrying O.McDonald - was unusually undisciplined Oliver - was rarely clean J.Smith - not a defender Tyson - had little impact Vince - best has passed
  3. joeboy

    Lever in the coaches box

    A little bit of overkill regarding Lever’s loss to the team. In reality he was pretty poor-average for most of his games with us apart from 2, so to blame his injury on our backline’s dysfunctionality is a little presumptive and plainly wrong Notwithstanding the above, he WILL be a fantastic addition to our team in the future
  4. joeboy

    New CEO - Gary Pert

    I’m pretty sure our ‘saviour’ Jackson left Essendon under acrimonious circumstances... that obviously didn’t impinge on the results he’s achieved with us
  5. joeboy

    Perspective

    Other clubs will note that applying ‘full court press’ will lead us to crumble like little boys.. we’ve done it for years , and nothing shown this year yet has proved otherwise
  6. Jones - totally lacked finesse Viney - taught a lesson T.McDonald - wonderful second half Hannan - was mostly irrelevant Harmes - probably not playing Neal-Bullen - was rarely noticed Fritsch - not the worst Gawn - tried but overwhelmed Oliver - prolific but wasteful Brayshaw - no heroics today Hogan - slow and confused Melksham - lost at sea Spargo - bambi amongst wolves Hibberd - fumbled and erred Jetta - loose and slow Lewis - tried but friendless O.McDonald - close to horrible Pedersen - game has passed Petracca - continued disappointing season Salem - rarely imbued confidence Smith - little to commend Vince - gave us nothing
  7. Jones - captain our captain Hogan - continued outstanding season T.McDonald - important as Gawn Neal-Bullen - consistent and versatile Hannan - a quiet achiever Brayshaw - now a weapon Fritsch - impressive and reliable Petracca - missing too often Melksham - played his part Gawn - toyed with opponents Oliver - engine room master Harmes - played different role Hibberd - not always convincing Jetta - never been better Lever - the curse continues Lewis - experience was evident O.McDonald - dependable and safe Salem - disposal from heaven Smith - didn’t take chances Spargo - quiet but valuable Vince - much like Lewis Viney - still finding feet
  8. Jones - outstanding all game Hogan - continued memorable year Brayshaw - in impressive form Neal- Bullen - proving doubters wrong Petracca - unselfish and dynamic Melksham - valuable and classy T.McDonald - significantly wasn’t important Smith - certainly a bull Hannan - quieter but valuable Spargo - knows his limitations Gawn - dominated centre again Viney - Viney of old Fritsch - love his finesse Harmes - hard and valuable Hibberd - outstanding attacking defender Jetta - was rarely troubled Lever - everything is justified Lewis - intelligent and safe O.McDonald - continued to excell Oliver - tireless and impressive Salem - mistakes but classy Vince - dominated taller opponent
  9. Jones - an indefatigable leader Melksham - perfect forward’s game T .McDonald - wonderful first half Neal-Bullen - persisted and achieved Hannan - great second efforts Fritsch - continues to impress Gawn - dominated the square Hogan - couldn’t get going Harmes - impressive grunt work Petracca - impressive first half Oliver - probably broke even Viney - understandably limited output Smith - tough and uncompromising Spargo - dropped for Garlett Salem - quieter but classy Brayshaw - impressive and inspiring Hibberd - there when needed Jetta - quiet but effective Lever - impressive and safe O.McDonald - under little pressure Vince - disposal sometimes worrying Lewis - the backline marshall
  10. Tyson - Joeboy finally vindicated
  11. joeboy

    My 3 word pre game analysis V Carlton

    As if Goodwin would say he was crap?
  12. Jones - dynamic and consistent Hogan - quieter but focused Oliver - prolific and clean Tyson - a momentum killer T.McDonald - outstanding first half Hannan - always looked dangerous Neal-Bullen - finally justified retention Salem - silky smooth mover Spargo - provided forward pressure Brayshaw - continued impressive form Melksham - clever and unselfish Gawn - provided first use Hibberd - back to best Harmes - prolific ball winner Petracca - just a game Fritsch - a classy mover Jetta - reliable when needed Lever - safe and steady Lewis - the consummate professional O.McDonald - almost always safe Vince - consistently good decisions Weidemann - another irrelevant game
  13. joeboy

    Casey Demons v Box Hill Hawks - Round 6

    It’s not country football?‍♂️
  14. Hogan - continued outstanding season T.McDonald - a significant impact Weideman - junk time possessions Neal-Bullen - replace with Viney Petracca - was obviously underdone Jones - impressive captain’s game Brayshaw - career best game Gawn - was masterful again Harmes - important but careless Oliver - back to best Spargo - love his endeavour Tyson - prolific but wasteful Hannan - made an impact Melksham - not as potent Fritsch - lots to like Hibberd - returned to best Hunt - effective but lacking Jetta - brave and reliable Lever - improving each game Lewis - professional and important O.McDonald - underrated and important Vince - barely wasted possessions
  15. Hannan - pace and movement Spargo - feisty and clever Gawn - made a statement Brayshaw - important second half Fritsch - some exciting plays Hogan - never moved freely Neal -Bullen - continued poor season Harmes - overplays his abilities Hibberd - found energy again Hunt - displayed more run Jetta - statistics belied effectiveness Jones - wonderful captain’s game T.McDonald - an impressive return O.McDonald - steady and safe Tyson - often butchered momentum Lever - steady and effective Lewis - a mixed bag Vince - just a game Oliver - was quiet again Salem - enjoyed more freedom Weideman- quiet when needed Melksham - has rediscovered confidence
  16. Jones - never stopped trying Jetta - just a shadow McDonald - disciplined and impressive Hibberd - brave but flawed Oliver - mostly wasted possessions Salem - soft under pressure Tyson - missing second half Hogan - played with heart Stretch - just a plodder Brayshaw - just a game Harmes - continued poor season Petracca - talents are wasted Vince - game has passed Neal-Bullen - irrelevant and fading Gawn - effective but friendless Kent - quiet before injury Lever - 4 solid quarters Wagner - disappeared after first Weideman -little to excite Hunt - continues downward spiral Garlett - waste of space Melksham - took his chances
  17. Jetta - invisible and irrelevant O.McDonald - tried but overwhelmed Hibberd - continued disappointing season Vince - steady but slowing Frost - little to commend Lewis - a total liability Gawn - our only winner Jones - probably broke even Neal-Bullen - little to commend Oliver - prolific but ineffective Melksham - gave us nothing Hogan - one great quarter Kent - an impressive game Bugg - an embarrassing liability Harmes - slow and ineffective Lever - continued to disappoint Petracca - conditions inhibited performance Brayshaw - an impressive return Fritsch - tried but limited Garlett - not on field Wagner - was hardly seen Salem - never stopped trying
  18. Jones - continued excellent season Bugg - bobbed up effectively Kent - an encouraging return Garlett - no heroics today Oliver - was surprisingly held Hogan - prolific all game Petracca - tough and dynamic Fritsch - some impressive touches Lewis - important but wayward Vince - steady in defence Melksham - struggling for form Salem - just a game Tyson - prolific but wasteful Wagner - increasing in confidence Frost - exciting but iffy Gawn - dominated the centre Harmes - tough but limited Hibberd - was disappointing again Jetta - just a shadow Lever - learning to adjust McDonald - made important decisions Neal-Bullen - didn’t show out
  19. You keep promising that you’d never read my 3 worders again ?
  20. Jetta - livelier but careless Lever - just a game Hibberd - consistently gave drive Hunt - lacking customary drive McDonald - continued good form Jones - indefatigable and inspiring Gawn - dominant from centre Oliver - classy and consistent Vince - not a tagger Salem - ineffective on ball Neal-Bullen - had little impact Lewis - almost always solid Petracca - classy and impressive Pedersen - was rarely sighted Harmes - tough and effective Fritsch - classy and brave Garlett - perfect forward’s game Hogan - 3 great quarters Wagner - didn’t imbue confidence Bugg - tried but failed Tyson - was mostly reliable Melksham - was almost effective
  21. joeboy

    Demonland Player of the Year - Round 2

    6 - Oliver - 4 consistently reliable quarters and his kicking is a weapon 5 - Garlett - finally back to the dangerous forward we love 4 - Hogan - 3 great quarters 3 - Petracca - exciting and inspiring all game 2 - McDonald - continues to defy criticism 1 - Jones - occasionally took wrong options but was reliable and effective
  22. Jetta - loose and slow Lever - disappointing debut game Hibberd - looked disinterested early Hunt - poor first half McDonald - made no errors Jones - indefatigable and inspiring Gawn - dominant all game Oliver - maintained the rage Vince - better second half Salem - impressive first half Neal-Bullen - just lacks finesse Lewis - important but costly Petracca - outstanding 3 quarters Pedersen - was rarely involved Harmes - tried but limited Fritsch - cause for optimism Garlett - disappointingly often missing Hogan - had little impact Wagner - just lacks skill Hannan - little peripheral awareness Maynard - out of depth Melksham - a huge disappointment
  23. joeboy

    Demonland Player of the Year 2018 - Round 1

    6 - Gawn ( ruckwork was as dominant as 2016 ) 5 - Petracca ( we can rest assured that he has the motor ) 4 - Oliver ( prolific and he CAN kick) 3 - Jones ( if only others possessed his will to win ) 2 - Vince ( slow to start but become important) 1 - Lewis ( same as Vince )
×