If he gets rubbed out then our sport has some serious problems. I feel for Shiel being unable to continue but in a high contact sport like AFL these things happen. I have no faith in the MRP but surely common sense can apply here.
There is no way the Crows will let him go into the PSD for nil return. You would take 10 and 27 over that any day of the week, plus they could easily on trade those picks to Carlton who should in theory accept that for Gibbs.
Most boring finals series (exception Port v West Coke) that I can recall. Weird considering how even the season was.
If the Giants can pull it off it would have to be the best "franchise win" of all time.